A ductile tearing assessment diagram to estimate load resistance versus crack extension for welded connections with surface cracks

2021 ◽  
Vol 169 ◽  
pp. 108435
Author(s):  
Tianyao Liu ◽  
Xudong Qian ◽  
Wei Wang ◽  
Yiyi Chen
2016 ◽  
Vol 853 ◽  
pp. 3-7
Author(s):  
Jie Yang

In this paper, the plate with different surface cracks (different constraints) was selected, the finite element numerical simulation method was used to mod el the J-integral and the equivalent plastic strain (εp) distributions ahead of crack front, after the unified constraint characterization parameter Ap was calculated, a new parameter which considered both J-integral and constraint effectwasdefined and a new methodology was provided to ensure the maximum crack extension location of surface crack. The results show that if the location of the maximum is defined as the maximum crack extension location, the prediction results is consistent with the measured results in experiments. The parameter which considered both crack driving force and material resistance force is a suitable parameter, and can be used to predict the maximum crack extension location.


Author(s):  
Osama Terfas ◽  
Bostjan Bezensek

The development of the shape and size of a flaw in a pressure vessel is important in fitness-for-service evaluations such as leak-before-break. In this work finite element modelling is used to evaluate the mean stresses and the J-integral around a front of a surface-breaking flaw. These results show non-uniform constraint levels and crack driving forces around the crack front at large deformation levels, which contrast those at low deformation levels. A new procedure is developed to estimate the amount of ductile crack extension around a surface-breaking crack on the basis of ductile tearing resistance curves of deep and shallow cracked fracture mechanics samples. The procedure is applied to surface flaws to simulate ductile crack extension under ductile tearing and show the evolution of the initial flaw shape. Results show that both, initially semi-circular and initially semi-elliptical flaws develop towards the same shape in bending.


Author(s):  
G. Wilkowski ◽  
S. Kalyanam ◽  
Y. Hioe ◽  
F. W. Brust ◽  
S. Pothana ◽  
...  

Abstract Work published for the first time at the ASME PVP 2017 conference showed that when on the upper-shelf, the toughness measured directly from surface-cracked pipe tests decreased as the flaw depth increased. A similar trend existed in SENT tests. Initially it was found that this flaw depth sensitivity of the toughness occurred for a very tough material like TP304 stainless steel. The significance of that result was that even for a material where limit-load was thought to exist, as the flaw depth increased the toughness dropped appreciably, and the failure analysis mode changed from limit-load to elastic-plastic fracture. Experimentally, this made sense because it explained the observed phenomena of load-controlled leak-versus-break behavior for circumferential surface-cracked pipes (as will be shown for several pipe tests), but that LBB behavior is not predictable from circumferential flaw limit-load analysis. Furthermore, the flaw depth effect on toughness also exists for axial surface cracks and even in flat plates with surface cracks. For axial surface cracks the implication was that the long-used empirical surface-crack bulging factor from Maxey/Kiefner (incorporated in many international codes and standards) actually incorporated both the bulging factor and the toughness changes with flaw depth. Because of the change in toughness with flaw depth, when using detailed finite-element fracture analyses for the crack-driving force it is possible to have more error in the failure stress predictions if a constant toughness is assumed for all surface-flaw depths. In fact, in another paper in the ASME 2019 PVP conference it will be shown that the toughness in a wrought TP304 elbow at crack initiation of a circumferential surface crack that was 68% of the thickness was about 1/3rd of the toughness from a standard 1T CT specimen made from the same material. Those results will also be reviewed. Similar results of toughness decreasing with flaw depth in surface-cracked pipes and SENT specimens for various materials over a large range of strain-hardening behavior will show the toughness decrease trend with flaw depth is consistent. To understand these trends more theoretically, 3D FE analyses were also conducted for one initial set of TP304 SENT specimens with a wide range of a/w values (0.3 < a/w < 0.9). The initiation toughness decreased by a factor of 5 to 6 as the crack depth increased; however, the Q value coinciding to the load at the start of ductile tearing was constant for the wide range of a/W values. Q at the start of ductile tearing in the SENT (Qi) was more consistent at normalized distances from the crack tip, rσo/J that were in the range from 0.25 to 1.5 rather than just the popularly considered rσo/J = 2. Hence, by having one SENT test result with a single a/W value, the Ji value for any other a/W can then be calculated. This is consistent with the experimental trends to date, but unfortunately Ji was found to be not proportional to the Q values as is conventionally assumed by many researchers at this time.


Author(s):  
Philippa L. Moore ◽  
Menno Hoekstra ◽  
Alex Pargeter

Abstract Hydrogen is well known to have a detrimental influence on the ductility of low alloy steels, reducing the fracture toughness. Standard test methods to characterize fracture toughness of steels in terms of ductile tearing resistance curves have not been developed to account for any hydrogen-driven contribution to the crack extension, Δa. Simply plotting J or CTOD against Δa is not necessarily appropriate for defining the initiation fracture toughness for tests performed in a hydrogen-charging environment. This paper explores a method to further analyse experimental data collected during fracture toughness tests, which allows the contribution of plasticity (i.e. when blunting precedes ductile tearing) to be considered separately from the initiation of crack extension (which could be by stable tearing and/or by hydrogen-driven crack extension). The principle is based on the assumption that a crack growing by a hydrogen-driven mechanism in a quasi-static fracture mechanics test performed in environment may not be associated with significant ductility in the plastic zone (which would accompany crack growth by stable tearing). The analytical method presented in this paper compares the different points of deviation from linear behavior of the components of J, to isolate the effects of ductility within the plastic zone from pure crack extension. In this way, the point of crack initiation can be defined in order to determine the relevant initiation fracture toughness; whether by blunting and stable tearing, or by hydrogen-driven crack growth. This approach offers a screening method which is illustrated using examples of fracture mechanics specimens tested in environments of varying severity (air, seawater with cathodic protection, and sour service). This method can be used to identify the relevant definition of initiation fracture toughness while allowing for a combination of ductile tearing, hydrogen-driven crack extension, or both, to be present during the test.


Author(s):  
Christian Thaulow ◽  
Bjo̸rn Skallerud ◽  
K. R. Jayadevan ◽  
Espen Berg

Surface cracks pose major challenges for the structural integrity of pipelines. In fracture assessment programs the use of constraint parameters, such as the T-stress, along with K, J or CTOD are important to account for the limitations of single-parameter fracture mechanics. However, the three-dimensional nature of surface cracks precludes detailed 3-D finite element modeling for routine calculations. Here line-spring/shell-element models are demonstrated to be an efficient and reasonably accurate tool for constraint estimation even under large deformation levels when general yielding prevails in the pipe. Envisaging the potential use of this procedure in fracture analysis of pipelines, a new software, LINKpipe, has been developed. The program has been developed as a part of the Joint Industry project Fracture Control Offshore Pipelines. The objective of this project is to study the behaviour of defected girth welds in pipelines subject to construction and operational loads ever experienced before. The calculations have been performed in close cooperation with the project participants; see presentations of project-colleagues at OMAE 2005: Bruschi et al (2005), O̸stby (2005), Nyhus et al (2005) and Sandvik et al (2005). In this paper the line-spring calculations are compared with 3-D FE calculations and computations according to BS 7910. A pipe geometry, with OD = 400mm, was selected for the comparisons. The line-spring calculations were close to the 3-D calculations, while BS7910 was very conservative for long cracks and unconservative for short cracks. In highly ductile materials, such as pipeline steels, considerably amount of stable crack growth can be tolerated prior to the final failure of the structure. A simple method for simulating ductile tearing in surface cracked pipes with the line-spring model has been developed. A detailed parametric study has been performed to examine the effect of ductile tearing for pipes loaded in tensile, bending and with internal pressure. A significant reduction in deformation capacity from the stationary case is noticed. As the crack depth increases, the effect of ductile tearing becomes more important. And under biaxial loading a significant reduction of the deformation capacity is found as the internal pressure is increased. The development of the line-spring methodology paves the way for a transition from to-days rule-based design to direct calculations.


Author(s):  
Jo¨rg Hohe ◽  
Marcus Brand ◽  
Dieter Siegele

The present study is concerned with the fracture behavior of sub-clad and surface cracks in components consisting of ferritic steels with an austenitic welded cladding. For this purpose, two tests on large scale specimens have been performed. The residual stress field has been determined by means of a numerical simulation of the welding and heat treatment processes. Based on the results, a numerical simulation of the component tests was performed in order to enable a fracture mechanics assessment of the conditions leading to crack initiation and arrest in the ferritic and austenitic regions. It was observed that in the present tests failure was initiated in the ferritic material whereas the austenitic cladding remained stable even in the case of a limited crack extension in the ferritic base metal.


1996 ◽  
Vol 11 (12) ◽  
pp. 3057-3063 ◽  
Author(s):  
D. Basu ◽  
B. K. Sarkar

Short surface cracks were generated by Vickers indentation on the polished surface of alumina and different zirconia toughened alumina (ZTA) specimens, and their morphology was studied by serial sectioning. These cracks were grown in three-point bend tests under stepwise loading, and variation of toughness with crack extension was plotted to graphically separate the contributions from residual stress intensity and applied stress intensity factors. The plateau toughness determined from the intercept height of the crack extension plots exhibited an upward trend with zirconia content up to 15 vol % ZrO2 addition in the composition, which was proportional to the fraction of transformable tetragonal grains contributing to transformation toughening.


Sign in / Sign up

Export Citation Format

Share Document