XXIV.—On the Equation of Motion of a Free Particle in the Expanding Universe of Kinematical Relativity
In a recent paper in these Proceedings, Dr G. C. McVittie has published some criticisms of kinematical relativity. These criticisms are to a large extent based on his formula (4.10), namely,It must be stated at the outset that McVittie's interpretation of his derivation of (1) as a derivation of “Milne's formula for the acceleration of a ‘free particle moving in the presence of a substratum,’ for the special case of one spatial co-ordinate only” is wrong. McVittie does not derive the result, as he claims, from what he calls the “axioms of kinematical relativity” alone; he deduces it from these axioms together with an additional assumption, which is equivalent to begging the answer to the whole problem it was my object to solve. Instead of considering a free particle, as I did—that is, a particle whose motion we do not a priori know—he prescribes a priori the motion of his particle as being constrained to obey the rule, in his notation,