Species distribution model transferability and model grain size – finer may not always be better

Abstract Research has shown that varying spatial scale through the selection of the total extent of investigation and the grain size of environmental predictor variables has effects on species distribution model (SDM) results and accuracy, but there has been minimal investigation into the interactive effects of extent and grain. To do this, we used a consistently sampled range-wide dataset of giant panda occurrence across southwest China and modeled their habitat and distribution at 4 extents and 7 grain sizes. We found that increasing grain size reduced model accuracy at the smallest extent, but that increasing extent negated this effect. Increasing extent also generally increased model accuracy, but the models built at the second-largest (mountain range) extent were more accurate than those built at the largest, geographic range-wide extent. When predicting habitat suitability in the smallest nested extents (50 km2), we found that the models built at the next-largest extent (500 km2) were more accurate than the smallest-extent models but that further increases in extent resulted in large decreases in accuracy. Overall, this study highlights the impacts of the selection of spatial scale when evaluating species’ habitat and distributions, and we suggest more explicit investigations of scale effects in future modeling efforts.

Download Full-text

A Test of Species Distribution Model Transferability Across Environmental and Geographic Space for 108 Western North American Tree Species

Frontiers in Ecology and Evolution ◽

10.3389/fevo.2021.689295 ◽

2021 ◽

Vol 9 ◽

Author(s):

Noah D. Charney ◽

Sydne Record ◽

Beth E. Gerstner ◽

Cory Merow ◽

Phoebe L. Zarnetske ◽

...

Keyword(s):

Species Distribution ◽

Tree Species ◽

Species Distribution Model ◽

Predictive Performance ◽

Environmental Data ◽

Distribution Model ◽

Species Ranges ◽

Model Transferability ◽

Geographic Space ◽

Environmental Space

Predictions from species distribution models (SDMs) are commonly used in support of environmental decision-making to explore potential impacts of climate change on biodiversity. However, because future climates are likely to differ from current climates, there has been ongoing interest in understanding the ability of SDMs to predict species responses under novel conditions (i.e., model transferability). Here, we explore the spatial and environmental limits to extrapolation in SDMs using forest inventory data from 11 model algorithms for 108 tree species across the western United States. Algorithms performed well in predicting occurrence for plots that occurred in the same geographic region in which they were fitted. However, a substantial portion of models performed worse than random when predicting for geographic regions in which algorithms were not fitted. Our results suggest that for transfers in geographic space, no specific algorithm was better than another as there were no significant differences in predictive performance across algorithms. There were significant differences in predictive performance for algorithms transferred in environmental space with GAM performing best. However, the predictive performance of GAM declined steeply with increasing extrapolation in environmental space relative to other algorithms. The results of this study suggest that SDMs may be limited in their ability to predict species ranges beyond the environmental data used for model fitting. When predicting climate-driven range shifts, extrapolation may also not reflect important biotic and abiotic drivers of species ranges, and thus further misrepresent the realized shift in range. Future studies investigating transferability of process based SDMs or relationships between geodiversity and biodiversity may hold promise.

Download Full-text

A Robust Prediction Model for Species Distribution Using Bagging Ensembles with Deep Neural Networks

Remote Sensing ◽

10.3390/rs13081495 ◽

2021 ◽

Vol 13 (8) ◽

pp. 1495

Author(s):

Jehyeok Rew ◽

Yongjang Cho ◽

Eenjun Hwang

Keyword(s):

Neural Networks ◽

Species Distribution ◽

Best Practice ◽

Deep Neural Networks ◽

Species Distribution Models ◽

Species Distribution Model ◽

Environmental Data ◽

Distribution Model ◽

Distribution Models ◽

Robust Prediction

Species distribution models have been used for various purposes, such as conserving species, discovering potential habitats, and obtaining evolutionary insights by predicting species occurrence. Many statistical and machine-learning-based approaches have been proposed to construct effective species distribution models, but with limited success due to spatial biases in presences and imbalanced presence-absences. We propose a novel species distribution model to address these problems based on bootstrap aggregating (bagging) ensembles of deep neural networks (DNNs). We first generate bootstraps considering presence-absence data on spatial balance to alleviate the bias problem. Then we construct DNNs using environmental data from presence and absence locations, and finally combine these into an ensemble model using three voting methods to improve prediction accuracy. Extensive experiments verified the proposed model’s effectiveness for species in South Korea using crowdsourced observations that have spatial biases. The proposed model achieved more accurate and robust prediction results than the current best practice models.

Download Full-text