Trade uncertainty makes interest rates less effective

Subject Financial market outlook. Significance At the annual gathering last month of the world’s central bankers in Jackson Hole, Wyoming, policymakers acknowledged that the economic uncertainty that the US-China trade conflict is generating was undermining the efficacy of monetary policy. James Bullard, the president of the St Louis Federal Reserve (Fed), warned that developed countries are experiencing a “regime shift” in economic conditions, in which trade-war-induced uncertainty -- and the unpredictability of US policy more broadly -- is becoming a permanent feature of policymaking, sapping the potency of forward guidance and overburdening monetary policy. Impacts Since the US tariff increase in May, the global stock of negative-yielding bonds has surged above 16 trillion dollars and will rise further. The dollar is at its highest since May 2017 and seems likely to rise further as US growth is far outpacing other major developed markets. The renminbi/dollar rate fell the most on record in August, raising capital outflow risks, most likely to the United States or Japan.

Subject Central banks’ policy dilemmas. Significance The National Bank of Hungary (MNB) remains extremely reluctant to raise interest rates despite increasing pressure on the forint. While growth in the euro-area is likely to remain weak this year, strengthening the case for rates to remain on hold, a more supportive external environment, underpinned by an easing of US-China trade tensions, would accentuate the policy dilemmas confronting Central Europe’s central banks, especially given rises in inflation. Impacts Germany’s still-negative ten-year bond yield has risen from record lows in September as markets become less pessimistic about global growth. Markets expect Hungarian monetary policy to remain very dovish, as the domestic twelve-month bond-yield’s end-October turn negative shows. The US S&P 500 index surged by nearly 30% last year and if US-China trade tensions ease slightly this should help it to maintain momentum.


Significance Global economic activity is deteriorating widely. This is despite the fact that the US-China trade conflict is not escalating, China is loosening fiscal policy and the United States and euro-area are committing to looser monetary policy. On April 3 the Asian Development Bank reduced its 2019 growth forecast for developing Asia to 5.7%, down from 5.9% a year ago, and the WTO reduced its forecast for 2019 growth in global trade volumes to 2.6%, from 3.7% in September. Impacts David Malpass became World Bank president this month and concerns will linger about his alignment with Trump’s ‘America First’ policies. If the US call to double the IMF’s ‘New arrangements to borrow’ passes, the debate over a permanent capital increase will be pushed back. A no-deal Brexit may push UK GDP into recession, hurting others as Germany, France and Spain’s UK exports sum 10 billion dollars or more. US-EU relations could deteriorate as the US trade body threatens billions of dollars of tariffs in retaliation for EU Airbus subsidies.


Significance This volatility is driven by expectations of further monetary stimulus in response to a slowing economy. Despite persistent concerns about the fallout from the anticipated tightening in US monetary policy and many country-specific risks, such as the standoff between Greece and its creditors, equity market sentiment remains supported by accommodative monetary policies worldwide and expectations of the US monetary policy tightening being gradual. Impacts Market volatility could increase further, as better-than-expected economic data in the euro-area vies with weaker-than-anticipated US data. Decoupling of surging equity prices and weak economic fundamentals threatens the rally's sustainability, increasing scope for volatility. This decoupling is most pronounced in China, where weak economic data prompt buying of equities in anticipation of stimulus measures. The greatest risk in equity markets is uncertainty surrounding US interest rates and their impact on emerging markets.


Subject Monetary policy moves. Significance The Bank of Mexico (Banxico) increased its target interest rate by 25 basis points, to 7.25%, on December 14, responding to a similar move by the US Federal Reserve (Fed) the previous day. The hike was the first to be taken under new Governor Alejandro Diaz de Leon and pushes the rate to its highest level since March 2009. Impacts Tighter monetary policy will weigh on growth in 2018 and may hit the PRI’s electoral prospects. More expensive credit will hit consumption moderately, as interest rates remain relatively low by historical standards. The possibility of wage increases edging up will feed inflationary expectations.


Subject Impact of the US-China tariffs on the energy market. Significance Global trade is slowing, and the US-China trade tariffs are exacerbating the slowdown. US oil and liquefied natural gas (LNG) exporters are finding alternative markets, but competitive pressures are likely to rise as both oil and LNG markets face oversupply. The tariffs on goods imported to the United States are also raising costs for the renewable and non-renewable sectors. Impacts US LNG producers could struggle to place cargoes as European gas storage approaches capacity. The large number of US offshore wind projects underway may be held back because the US-China tariffs are increasing project costs. Weak world trade and GDP growth is capping energy demand, offsetting supply worries and curbing oil price gains.


Subject The impact of US monetary policy tightening. Significance Following the US Federal Reserve's (Fed) historic decision to raise rates for the first time since 2006, the start of the Fed's monetary tightening cycle is accentuating the hawkish stance of Latin America's main central banks. This comes amid a dramatic sell-off in commodity markets, persistent concerns about China's economy and a severe deterioration in economic conditions across the region. Impacts EM asset prices have remained relatively resilient to the rise in US interest rates, in stark contrast to the 'taper tantrum' in 2013. Hitherto-resilient regional local currency government bond markets will face foreign capital outflows due to falling commodity prices. The Brazilian real is 2015's worst-performing major EM currency, but due largely to political and economic difficulties at home.


Significance The meetings are expected to provide forward guidance on monetary policy. With consumer prices reaching a five-and-a-half year high in Hungary and a seven-month high in the Czech Republic, attention has turned to the future trajectory of Central European (CE) interest rates. Tightening would run against the populist streak of governments in both Prague and Budapest. Impacts Rate hikes in the Czech Republic and eventually also in Hungary by mid-2019 may contribute to a broad-based slowdown in growth next year. Tighter rates may moderate the headline inflation rate in January-June 2019, partly offsetting the negative impact of economic overheating. CE currencies may gradually strengthen, helping to shield against excessive capital outflows, as global liquidity conditions tighten. Some monetary policy divergence is likely within CE, as Poland’s central bank is unlikely to push for higher interest rates before end-2019.


Significance In one of the most significant changes in direction in a major emerging market (EM) in recent years, newly appointed TCMB Governor Naci Agbal has tightened monetary policy dramatically while abandoning a convoluted system of multiple interest rates. With another technocrat, Lufti Elvan, appointed finance minister, monetary policy could be returning to normality. Impacts A Biden administration is expected to prove unaccommodating towards Turkey, especially given its purchase of a Russian air defence system. This may be leading Erdogan to extend feelers to the EU, recently promising reforms and insisting Turkey is an “inseparable” part of Europe. Anti-coronavirus vaccines’ late-stage trial results are encouraging market optimism, with the US stock market hitting a record this month.


2020 ◽  
Vol ahead-of-print (ahead-of-print) ◽  
Author(s):  
Nazneen Ahmad ◽  
Sandeep Kumar Rangaraju

PurposeThis paper investigates the impact of a monetary policy shock on the production of a sample of 312 industries in manufacturing, mining and utilities in the United States using a factor-augmented vector autoregression (FAVAR) model.Design/methodology/approachThe authors use a FAVAR model that builds on Bernanke et al. (2005) and Boivin et al. (2009). The main assumption in this model is that the dynamics of a large set of macro variables are captured by some observed and unobserved common factors. The unobserved factors are extracted from a large set of macroeconomic data. The key advantage of using this model is that it allows extracting the impulse responses of a wide range of macroeconomic variables to structural shocks in the federal funds rate.FindingsThe results indicate that industries exhibit differential responses to an unanticipated monetary policy tightening. In general, manufacturing industries appear to be more sensitive compared to mining, and utility industries and durable manufacturing industries are found to be more sensitive than those within nondurable and other manufacturing industries to a monetary policy shock. While all industries respond to the policy shock, most of the responses are reversed between 12 and 22 months.Research limitations/implicationsThe implication of our results is that monetary policy can be used to impact most US industries for four years and beyond. The existence of disparate responses across industries underscores the difficulty of implementing a monetary policy that will generate the same impact across industries. As the effects of the policy are distinct, policymakers may want to attend to the unique impacts and implement industry-specific policy.Practical implicationsThe study is important in the context of the current challenges in the US economy caused by the spread of coronavirus. For example, to tackle the current pandemic, the researchers are trying to come up with cures for COVID-19. A considerable response of the chemical industry that provides materials to pharmaceutical and medicine manufacturing to the monetary policy shock implies that an expansionary monetary policy may facilitate an invention and adequate supply of the cure later on. The same policy may not effectively stimulate production in apparel or leather product industries that are being hard hit by the pandemic.Originality/valueThe study contributes to the literature in broadly two aspects. First, to the best of our knowledge, this is the first paper that investigates the impact of a monetary policy shock on a sample of 312 industries in manufacturing, mining and utilities in the US. Second, to identify structural shocks and investigate the effects of monetary policy shocks on economic activity, the authors diverge from the literature's traditional approach, i.e. the vector autoregression (VAR) method and use a FAVAR method. The FAVAR provides a comprehensive description of the impact of a monetary policy innovation on different industries.


Subject Modelling lower rates for longer. Significance The ‘secular stagnation' thesis argues that as population growth slows, the need of businesses to invest in plant and equipment slows and the supply of funds from households grows as they save more, putting downward pressure on interest rates. New research attempts to quantify this hypothesis and to show what it would take to go back to 'normal'. Impacts 'Forward guidance' will be of little use if there is a recession as there would be no reason to expect an increase in policy rates. Asset bubbles would likely be a feature of any sustained non-fiscal effort to engineer a deeply negative real interest rate. The US trade deficit, usually a welcome source of lower rates, will in this context exacerbate the zero-lower-bound issue in a recession.


Sign in / Sign up

Export Citation Format

Share Document