A synthesis of local adaptation to climate through reciprocal common gardens

2021 ◽  
Author(s):  
Christopher J. Lortie ◽  
José L Hierro
Author(s):  
Hillary Cooper ◽  
Gerard Allan ◽  
Lela Andrews ◽  
Rebecca Best ◽  
Kevin Grady ◽  
...  

Widespread tree species span large climatic gradients that often lead to high levels of local adaptation and phenotypic divergence across their range. To evaluate the relative roles of selection and drift in driving divergence in phenotypic traits, we compared molecular and quantitative genetic variation in Populus fremontii (Fremont cottonwood), using data from > 9000 SNPs and genotypes from 16 populations reciprocally planted in three common gardens that span the species’ climatic range. We present three major findings: 1) There is significant within- and among-population variation in functional traits expressed in each of the common gardens. 2) There is evidence from all three gardens that population divergence in leaf phenology and specific leaf area has been driven by divergent selection (QST > FST). In contrast, QST-FST comparisons for performance traits like height and basal diameter were highly dependent on growing environment, indicating divergent, stabilizing, or no selection across the three gardens. We show this is likely due to local adaptation of source populations to contrasting growing environments. 3) Climate is a primary selective force driving trait divergence, where the traits showing the strongest correlations with a genotype’s provenance climate also had the highest QST values. We conclude that climatic gradients have contributed to significant phenotypic differences and local adaptation in Fremont cottonwood. These results are important because as climate is changing much more rapidly, traits such as phenology that are finely tuned to local conditions may now be subject to intense selection or quickly become maladaptive.


2019 ◽  
Author(s):  
M-A. Fustier ◽  
N.E. Martínez-Ainsworth ◽  
A. Venon ◽  
H. Corti ◽  
A. Rousselet ◽  
...  

AbstractLocal adaptation across species range is widespread. Yet, much has to be discovered on its environmental drivers, the underlying functional traits and their molecular determinants. Because elevation gradients display continuous environmental changes at a short geographical scale, they provide an exceptional opportunity to investigate these questions. Here, we used two common gardens to phenotype 1664 plants from 11 populations of annual teosintes. These populations were sampled across two elevation gradients in Mexico. Our results point to a syndrome of adaptation to altitude with the production of offspring that flowered earlier, produced less tillers, and larger, longer and heavier grains with increasing elevation. We genotyped these plants for 178 outlier single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs), which had been chosen because they displayed excess of allele differentiation and/or correlation with environmental variables in six populations with contrasted altitudes. A high proportion of outlier SNPs associated with the phenotypic variation of at least one trait. We tested phenotypic pairwise correlations between traits, and found that the higher the correlation, the greater the number of common associated SNPs. In addition, allele frequencies at 87 of the outlier SNPs correlated with an environmental component best summarized by altitudinal variation on a broad sample of 28 populations. Chromosomal inversions were enriched for both phenotypically-associated and environmentally-correlated SNPs. Altogether, our results are consistent with the set-up of an altitudinal syndrome promoted by local adaptation of teosinte populations in the face of gene flow. We showed that pleiotropy is pervasive and potentially has constrained the evolution of traits. Finally, we recovered variants underlying phenotypic variation at adaptive traits. Because elevation mimics climate change through space, these variants may be relevant for future maize breeding.Author summaryAcross their native range, species encounter a diversity of habitats promoting local adaptation of geographically distributed populations. While local adaptation is widespread, much has yet to be discovered about the conditions of its emergence, the targeted traits, their molecular determinants and the underlying ecological drivers. Here we employed a reverse ecology approach, combining phenotypes and genotypes, to mine the determinants of local adaptation of teosinte populations distributed along two steep altitudinal gradients in Mexico. Evaluation of 11 populations in two common gardens located at mid-elevation pointed to the set-up of an altitudinal syndrome, in spite of gene flow. We scanned genomes to identify loci with allele frequencies shifts along elevation. Interestingly, variation at these loci was commonly associated to variation of phenotypes. Because elevation mimics climate change through space, these variants may be relevant for future maize breeding.


2018 ◽  
Author(s):  
A. Cornille ◽  
A. Salcedo ◽  
H. Huang ◽  
D. Kryvokhyzha ◽  
K. Holm ◽  
...  

AbstractSpecies having experienced rapid range expansion represent unique opportunities to evaluate the dynamics of adaptation during colonization of new environments. We investigated the consequences of range expansion on local adaptation of a successful worldwide colonizer, the shepherd’s purse Capsella bursa-pastoris. This species is an annual weed that originated recently in Eurasia and has now broadly colonized both temperate and subtropical areas. We assessed the performance, genetic diversity, and phenology of field-collected accessions belonging to three distinct genetic clusters of decreasing age (Middle East, Europe and Asia) in three common gardens in Europe, Asia and North America. To understand the genetic basis of local adaptation in this species, we also tested for correlation between SNP allele frequencies and environmental factors in Europe and Asia. Overall, we showed that patterns of local adaptation depended on population history: some older populations were weakly adapted to local conditions while those closer to the front of the colonization wave, far from the origin of the species, were maladapted whatever the common gardens. Altogether, our results have important consequences for the understanding of the evolution and adaptation of self-fertilizing plant during range expansion.


2019 ◽  
Author(s):  
Shira Penner ◽  
Yuval Sapir

SummaryPlants have diverse strategies to cope with stress, including early flowering to “escape” abiotic stress and late flowering to mitigate biotic stress. Plants are usually exposed to multiple stresses simultaneously, but little is known about the impact of multiple co-occurring stresses on plant evolution.We tested for adaptation to both aridity and interspecific competition of the model plant Brachypodium spp., collected along the aridity gradient in Israel. We recorded flowering time and estimated fitness in a controlled watering experiment, with treatments mimicking Mediterranean and arid precipitation, and in two common gardens located in the extremes of the gradient (i.e., desert and mesic Mediterranean). At the latter we also manipulated interspecific competition to examine the combined effect of competition and aridity.Plants from arid environments always flowered earlier, but we found no selection on flowering time in the watering experiment. In the common gardens, however, the direction of selection on flowering time differed between sites and competition treatments.We conclude that interactions between aridity and competition drive local adaptation of Brachypodium in the Eastern Mediterranean basin. Variation in flowering time is an important adaptive mechanism to aridity and multiple selection agents can have interactive effects on the evolution of this trait.


Sign in / Sign up

Export Citation Format

Share Document