Magnus Effect: Physical Origins and Numerical Prediction

2011 ◽  
Vol 78 (5) ◽  
Author(s):  
Roxan Cayzac ◽  
Eric Carette ◽  
Pascal Denis ◽  
Philippe Guillen

An overview of the Magnus effect of projectiles and missiles is presented. The first part of the paper is devoted to the description of the physical mechanisms governing the Magnus effect. For yawing and spinning projectiles, at small incidences, the spin induces a weak asymmetry of the boundary layer profiles. At high incidences, increased spin causes the separated vortex sheets to be altered. Vortex asymmetry generates an additional lateral force which gives a vortex contribution to the total Magnus effect. For finned projectiles or missiles, the origin of the Magnus effect on fins is the main issue. There are two principal sources contributing to the Magnus effect. Firstly, the interaction between the asymmetric boundary layer-wake of the body and the fins, and secondly, the spin induced modifications of the local incidences and of the flow topology around the fins. The second part of the paper is devoted to the numerical prediction and validation of these flow phenomena. A state of the art is presented including classical CFD methods based on Reynolds-averaged Navier–Stokes (RANS) and unsteady rans (URANS) equations, and also hybrid RANS/LES approach called ZDES. This last method is a recent advance in turbulence modeling methodologies that allows to take into account the unsteadiness of the flow in the base region. For validation purposes computational results were compared with wind tunnel tests. A wide range of angles of attack, spin rates, Reynolds and Mach numbers (subsonic, transonic and supersonic) have been investigated.

2018 ◽  
Vol 10 (7) ◽  
pp. 168781401879086 ◽  
Author(s):  
Jintao Yin ◽  
Xiaosheng Wu ◽  
Juanmian Lei ◽  
Tianyu Lu ◽  
Xiaodong Liu

Reynolds-averaged simulations of flow over spinning finned missiles with and without canards were carried out at Ma = 0.6, 0.9, 1.5, and 2.5; α = 4°, 8°, and 12.6°; and [Formula: see text] to investigate different mechanisms of the Magnus effect. An implicit dual-time stepping method and the [Formula: see text] transition model were combined to solve the unsteady Reynolds-averaged Navier–Stokes equations. Grid independence study was conducted, and the computed results were compared with archival experimental data. The transient and time-averaged lateral force coefficients were obtained, and the flow field structures were compared at typical rolling angles. The results indicate that in subsonic conditions, the canards interference intensifies the asymmetrical distortion of the body surface boundary layer and flow separation at different angles of attack, doubling the absolute value of the time-averaged body lateral force; the wash flow effect strengthens on the leeward tail due to the canards interference, increasing its time-averaged lateral force; in supersonic conditions, the shock and expansion waves induced by canards, the vortex system, and the flow separation are responsible for the fluctuation of the body lateral force; the direction of the canard induced wash flow alters as angle of attack increases, increasing first and then decreasing the time-averaged tail lateral force.


Author(s):  
Anil K. Tolpadi ◽  
James A. Tallman ◽  
Lamyaa El-Gabry

Conventional heat transfer design methods for turbine airfoils use 2-D boundary layer codes (BLC) combined with empiricism. While such methods may be applicable in the mid span of an airfoil, they would not be very accurate near the end-walls and airfoil tip where the flow is very three-dimensional (3-D) and complex. In order to obtain accurate heat transfer predictions along the entire span of a turbine airfoil, 3-D computational fluid dynamics (CFD) must be used. This paper describes the development of a CFD based design system to make heat transfer predictions. A 3-D, compressible, Reynolds-averaged Navier-Stokes CFD solver with k-ω turbulence modeling was used. A wall integration approach was used for boundary layer prediction. First, the numerical approach was validated against a series of fundamental airfoil cases with available data. The comparisons were very favorable. Subsequently, it was applied to a real engine airfoil at typical design conditions. A discussion of the features of the airfoil heat transfer distribution is included.


1994 ◽  
Vol 269 ◽  
pp. 79-106 ◽  
Author(s):  
T. C. Fu ◽  
A. Shekarriz ◽  
J. Katz ◽  
T. T. Huang

Particle displacement velocimetry is used to measure the velocity and vorticity distributions around an inclined 6: 1 prolate spheroid. The objective is to determine the effects of boundary-layer tripping, incidence angle, and Reynolds number on the flow structure. The vorticity distributions are also used for computing the lateral forces and rolling moments that occur when the flow is asymmetric. The computed forces agree with results of direct measurements. It is shown that when the flow is not tripped, separation causes the formation of a pair of vortex sheets. The size of these sheets increases with increasing incidence angle and axial location. Their orientation and internal vorticity distribution also depend on incidence. Rollup into distinct vortices occurs in some cases, and the primary vortex contains between 20 % and 50 % of the overall circulation. The entire flow is unsteady and there are considerable variations in the instantaneous vorticity distributions. The remainder of the lee side, excluding these vortex sheets, remains almost vorticity free, providing clear evidence that the flow can be characterized as open separation. Boundary-layer tripping causes earlier separation on part of the model, brings the primary vortex closer to the body, and spreads the vorticity over a larger region. The increased variability in the vorticity distribution causes considerable force fluctuations, but the mean loads remain unchanged. Trends with increasing Reynolds number are conflicting, probably because of boundary-layer transition. The separation point moves towards the leeward meridian and the normal force decreases when the Reynolds number is increased from 0.42 × 106 to 1.3 × 106. Further increase in the Reynolds number to 2.1 × 106 and tripping cause an increase in forces and earlier separation.


Author(s):  
Costel Ungureanu ◽  
Costel Iulian Mocanu

"Free surface flow is a hydrodynamic problem with a seemingly simple geometric configuration but with a flow topology complicated by the pressure gradient due to the presence of the obstacle, the interaction between the boundary layer and the free surface, turbulence, breaking waves, surface tension effects between water and air. As the ship appendages become more and more used and larger in size, the general understanding of the flow field around the appendages and the junction between them and the hull is a topical issue for naval hydrodynamics. When flowing with a boundary layer, when the streamlines meet a bluff body mounted on a solid flat or curved surface, detachments appear in front of it due to the blocking effect. As a result, vortex structures develop in the fluid, also called horseshoe vortices, the current being one with a completely three-dimensional character, complicated by the interactions between the boundary layer and the vortex structures thus generated. Despite the importance of the topic, the literature records the lack of coherent methods for investigating free surface flow around junctions, the lack of consistent studies on the influence of the inclination of the profile mounted on the body. As a result, this paper aims to systematically study the influence of profile inclination in respect to the support plate."


1996 ◽  
Vol 118 (3) ◽  
pp. 537-545 ◽  
Author(s):  
J. E. Choi ◽  
M. K. Sreedhar ◽  
F. Stern

Results are reported of a computational study investigating the responses of flat plate boundary layers and wakes to horizontal wave outer flows. Solutions are obtained for temporal, spatial, and traveling waves using Navier Stokes, boundary layer, and perturbation expansion equations. A wide range of parameters are considered for all the three waves. The results are presented in terms of Stokes-layer overshoots, phase leads (lags), and streaming. The response to the temporal wave showed all the previously reported features. The magnitude and nature of the response are small and simple such that it is essentially a small disturbance on the steady solution. Results are explainable in terms of one parameter ξ (the frequency of oscillation). For the spatial wave, the magnitude and the nature of the response are significantly increased and complex such that it cannot be considered simply a small disturbance on the without-wave solution. The results are explainable in terms of the two parameters λ−1 and x/λ (where λ is the wavelength). A clear asymmetry is observed in the wake response for the spatial wave. An examination of components of the perturbation expansion equations indicates that the asymmetry is a first-order effect due to nonlinear interaction between the steady and first-harmonic velocity components. For the traveling wave, the responses are more complex and an additional parameter, c (the wave speed), is required to explain the results. In general, for small wave speeds the results are similar to a spatial wave, whereas for higher wave speeds the response approaches the temporal wave response. The boundary layer and perturbation expansion solutions compares well with the Navier Stokes solution in their range of validity.


Author(s):  
Y. K. Ho ◽  
G. J. Walker ◽  
P. Stow

Performance calculations for a NASA controlled-diffusion compressor blade have been carried out with a coupled inviscid-boundary layer code and a time-marching Navier-Stokes solver. Comparisons with experimental test data highlight and explain the strengths and limitations of both these computational methods. The boundary layer code gives good results at and near design conditions. Loss predictions however deteriorated at off-design incidences. This is mainly due to a problem with leading edge laminar separation bubble modelling; coupled with an inability of the calculations to grow the turbulent boundary layer at a correct rate in a strong adverse pressure gradient. Navier-Stokes loss predictions on the other hand are creditable throughout the whole incidence range, except at extreme positive incidence where turbulence modeling problems similar to those of the coupled boundary layer code are observed. The main drawback for the Navier-Stokes code is the slow rate of convergence for these low Mach number cases. Plans are currently under review to address this problem. Both codes give excellent predictions of the blade surface pressure distributions for all the cases considered.


Author(s):  
Ulf Bunge ◽  
Andreas Gurr ◽  
Frank Thiele

The incompressible flow around a rectangular body with a length to height ratio of L/H = 2 and its flow–induced oscillatory behavior is numerically investigated at different Re–numbers in a range between 1 to 6 · 104. The body has one degree of freedom perpendicular to the mean–flow direction with a linear spring and linear damping. To compute the flow a finite–volume based Navier–Stokes CFD-code is used, which is enhanced by a finite–difference based algorithm to solve the vibration differential equation. Target is the numeric simulation of a incident flow velocity where resonance occurs and the exact determination of the physical mechanisms especially in the flowing medium. Particular substantial parameters of the total model, e.g. turbulence modeling, time step or grid, which exert influence on the quality of the simulation are examined. To achieve this aim simulations with steady and oscillating body are compared with experimental data and deviations are analyzed.


1995 ◽  
Vol 296 ◽  
pp. 1-38 ◽  
Author(s):  
P. Koumoutsakos ◽  
A. Leonard

The development of a two-dimensional viscous incompressible flow generated from a circular cylinder impulsively started into rectilinear motion is studied computationally. An adaptative numerical scheme, based on vortex methods, is used to integrate the vorticity/velocity formulation of the Navier–Stokes equations for a wide range of Reynolds numbers (Re = 40 to 9500). A novel technique is implemented to resolve diffusion effects and enforce the no-slip boundary condition. The Biot–Savart law is employed to compute the velocities, thus eliminating the need for imposing the far-field boundary conditions. An efficient fast summation algorithm was implemented that allows a large number of computational elements, thus producing unprecedented high-resolution simulations. Results are compared to those from other theoretical, experimental and computational works and the relation between the unsteady vorticity field and the forces experienced by the body is discussed.


1985 ◽  
Vol 158 ◽  
pp. 399-446 ◽  
Author(s):  
Madeleine Coutanceau ◽  
Christian Ménard

The early phase of the establishment of the flow past a circular cylinder started impulsively into rotation and translation is investigated by visualizing the flow patterns with solid tracers and by analysing qualitatively (flow topology) and quantitatively (velocity distributions and singular-point trajectories) the corresponding photographs. The range considered corresponds to moderate Reynolds numbers (Re [les ] 1000). The rotating-to-translating-speed ratio α increases from 0 to 3.25 and the motion covers a period during which the cylinder translates 4.5 or even 7 times its diameter. The details of the mechanisms of the near-wake formation are considered in particular and the increase of the flow asymmetry with increase in rotation is pointed out. Thus the existence of two regimes has been confirmed with the creation or non-creation of alternate eddies after an initial one E1 Furthermore, the new phenomena of saddle-point transposition and intermediate-eddy coalescence have been identified in the formation or shedding of respectively the odd and even subsequent eddies Ei (i = 2,3,…) when they exist. The very good agreement between these experimental data and the numerical results of Badr & Dennis (1985), obtained by solving the Navier-Stokes equations and presented in a parallel paper, confirms their respective validity and permits the determination of the flow characteristics not accessible, or accessible only with difficulty, to the present experiments. These flow properties such as drag and vorticity are capable of providing information on the Magnus effect for the former property and on unsteady separated flows for the latter.


2009 ◽  
Vol 625 ◽  
pp. 75-96 ◽  
Author(s):  
A. RUBIO ◽  
J. M. LOPEZ ◽  
F. MARQUES

Thermal convection in a rotating cylinder near onset is investigated using direct numerical simulations of the Navier–Stokes equations with the Boussinesq approximation in a regime dominated by the Coriolis force. For thermal driving too small to support convection throughout the entire cell, convection sets in as alternating pairs of hot and cold plumes in the sidewall boundary layer, the so-called wall modes of rotating convection. We subject the wall modes to small amplitude harmonic modulations of the rotation rate over a wide range of frequencies. The modulations produce harmonic Ekman boundary layers at the top and bottom lids as well as a Stokes boundary layer at the sidewall. These boundary layers drive a time-periodic large-scale circulation that interacts with the wall-localized thermal plumes in a non-trivial manner. The resultant phenomena include a substantial shift in the onset of wall-mode convection to higher temperature differences for a broad band of frequencies, as well as a significant alteration of the precession rate of the wall mode at very high modulation frequencies due to the mean azimuthal streaming flow resulting from the modulations.


Sign in / Sign up

Export Citation Format

Share Document