scholarly journals Prediction and Analysis of Impact of Thermal Barrier Coating Oxidation on Gas Turbine Creep Life

Author(s):  
E. A. Ogiriki ◽  
Y. G. Li ◽  
Th. Nikolaidis

Thermal barrier coatings (TBCs) have been widely used in the power generation industry to protect turbine blades from damage in hostile operating environment. This allows either a high turbine entry temperature (TET) to be employed or a low percentage of cooling air to be used, both of which will improve the performance and efficiency of gas turbine engines. However, with continuous increases in TET aimed at improving the performance and efficiency of gas turbines, TBCs have become more susceptible to oxidation. Such oxidation has been largely responsible for the premature failure of most TBCs. Nevertheless, existing creep life prediction models that give adequate considerations to the effects of TBC oxidation on creep life are rare. The implication is that the creep life of gas turbines may be estimated more accurately if TBC oxidation is considered. In this paper, a performance-based integrated creep life model has been introduced with the capability of assessing the impact of TBC oxidation on the creep life and performance of gas turbines. The model comprises of a thermal, stress, oxidation, performance, and life estimation models. High pressure turbine (HPT) blades are selected as the life limiting component of gas turbines. Therefore, the integrated model was employed to investigate the effect of several operating conditions on the HPT blades of a model gas turbine engine using a creep factor (CF) approach. The results show that different operating conditions can significantly affect the oxidation rates of TBCs which in turn affect the creep life of HPT blades. For instance, TBC oxidation can speed up the overall life usage of a gas turbine engine from 4.22% to 6.35% within a one-year operation. It is the objective of this research that the developed method may assist gas turbine users in selecting the best mission profile that will minimize maintenance and operating costs while giving the best engine availability.

Author(s):  
E. A. Ogiriki ◽  
Y. G. Li ◽  
Th. Nikolaidis

Thermal Barrier Coatings (TBC) have been widely used in the power generation industry to protect turbine blades from damage in hostile operating environment. This allows either a high Turbine Entry temperature (TET) to be employed or a low percentage of cooling air to be used, both of which will improve the performance and efficiency of gas turbine engines. However, with continuous increases in turbine entry temperature aimed at improving the performance and efficiency of gas turbines, TBCs have become more susceptible to oxidation. Such oxidation has been largely responsible for the premature failure of most TBCs. Nevertheless, existing creep life prediction models that give adequate considerations to the effects of TBC oxidation on creep life are rare. The implication is that the creep life of gas turbines may be estimated more accurately if TBC oxidation is considered. In this paper, a performance-based integrated creep life model has been introduced with the capability of assessing the impact of TBC oxidation on the creep life and performance of gas turbines. The model comprises of a thermal, stress, oxidation, performance, and life estimation models. High Pressure Turbine (HPT) blades are selected as the life limiting component of the gas turbine. Therefore the integrated model was employed to investigate the effect of several operating conditions on the HPT blades of a model gas turbine engine using a Creep Factor approach. The results show that different operating conditions can significantly affect the oxidation rates of TBCs which in turn affect the creep life of HPT blades. For instance, TBC oxidation can speed up the overall life usage of a gas turbine engine from 4.22% to 6.35% within one year operation. It is the objective of this research that the developed method may assist gas turbine users in selecting the best mission profile that will minimize maintenance and operating costs while giving the best engine availability.


Author(s):  
J. Zelina ◽  
D. T. Shouse ◽  
J. S. Stutrud ◽  
G. J. Sturgess ◽  
W. M. Roquemore

An aero gas turbine engine has been proposed that uses a near-constant-temperature (NCT) cycle and an Inter-Turbine Burner (ITB) to provide large amounts of power extraction from the low-pressure turbine. This level of energy is achieved with a modest temperature rise across the ITB. The additional energy can be used to power a large geared fan for an ultra-high bypass ratio transport aircraft, or to drive an alternator for large amounts of electrical power extraction. Conventional gas turbines engines cannot drive ultra-large diameter fans without causing excessively high turbine temperatures, and cannot meet high power extraction demands without a loss of engine thrust. Reducing the size of the combustion system is key to make use of a NCT gas turbine cycle. Ultra-compact combustor (UCC) concepts are being explored experimentally. These systems use high swirl in a circumferential cavity about the engine centerline to enhance reaction rates via high cavity g-loading on the order of 3000 g’s. Any increase in reaction rate can be exploited to reduce combustor volume. The UCC design integrates compressor and turbine features which will enable a shorter and potentially less complex gas turbine engine. This paper will present experimental data of the Ultra-Compact Combustor (UCC) performance in vitiated flow. Vitiation levels were varied from 12–20% oxygen levels to simulate exhaust from the high pressure turbine (HPT). Experimental results from the ITB at atmospheric pressure indicate that the combustion system operates at 97–99% combustion efficiency over a wide range of operating conditions burning JP-8 +100 fuel. Flame lengths were extremely short, at about 50% of those seen in conventional systems. A wide range of operation is possible with lean blowout fuel-air ratio limits at 25–50% below the value of current systems. These results are significant because the ITB only requires a small (300°F) temperature rise for optimal power extraction, leading to operation of the ITB at near-lean-blowout limits of conventional combustor designs. This data lays the foundation for the design space required for future engine designs.


Author(s):  
Eugene P. Weinert ◽  
Gilbert A. Carlton

The gas-turbine engine in naval service is subjected to severe operating conditions. By far the most consistent troublemaker is sea salt. In either liquid or solid state, sea salt causes problems in corrosion of hot and cold surfaces, fouling of fuel systems, and deterioration of compressor performance. Such problems are reviewed and solutions discussed.


Procedia CIRP ◽  
2015 ◽  
Vol 38 ◽  
pp. 228-233 ◽  
Author(s):  
Ebi A. Ogiriki ◽  
Yiguang G. Li ◽  
Theoklis Nikolaidis ◽  
ThankGod E. Isaiah ◽  
Gowon Sule

Author(s):  
W. Mohamed ◽  
S. Eshati ◽  
P. Pilidis ◽  
S. Ogaji ◽  
P. Laskaridis ◽  
...  

Peak load operation requires gas turbines to operate at high firing temperature with consequence reduction in the useful lives of components. This paper studies the quantitative relationship between gas turbine power setting and the hot gas-path components’ life consumption. A 165MW gas turbine engine is modelled and investigated in this study. A comparative lifing model, which performs stress and thermal analyses, estimates the minimum creep life of components using the parametric Larson Miller method. This lifing model was integrated with in-house performance simulation software to simulate the engine performances at design point and off-design conditions. The results showed that the combined effect of the operating environment and the power demand could have significant impact on blade creep life. Predicting this impact will aid gas turbine users in the decision making processes associated with gas turbine operation.


Author(s):  
Peter L. Meitner ◽  
Anthony L. Laganelli ◽  
Paul F. Senick ◽  
William E. Lear

A semi-closed cycle, turboshaft gas turbine engine was assembled and tested under a cooperative program funded by the NASA Glenn Research Center with support from the U.S. Army. The engine, called HPRTE (High Pressure, Recuperated Turbine Engine), features two distinct cycles operating in parallel; an “inner,” high pressure, recuperated cycle, in which exhaust gas is recirculated, and an “open” through-flow cycle. Recuperation is performed in the “inner,” high pressure loop, which greatly reduces the size of the heat exchanger. An intercooler is used to cool both the recirculated exhaust gas and the fresh inlet air. Because a large portion of the exhaust gas is recirculated, significantly less inlet air is required to produce a desired horsepower level. This reduces the engine inlet and exhaust flows to less than half that required for conventional, open cycle, recuperated gas turbines of equal power. In addition, the reburning of the exhaust gas reduces exhaust pollutants. A two-shaft engine was assembled from existing components to demonstrate concept feasibility. The engine did not represent an optimized system, since most components were oversized, and the overall pressure ratio was much lower than optimum. New cycle analysis codes were developed that are capable of accounting for recirculating exhaust flow. Code predictions agreed with test results. Analyses for a fully developed engine predict almost constant specific fuel consumption over a broad power range. Test results showed significant emissions reductions. This document is the first in a series of papers that arc planned to be presented on semi-closed cycle characteristics, issues, and applications, addressing the impact of recirculating exhaust flow on combustion and engine components.


Author(s):  
M. F. Abdul Ghafir ◽  
Y. G. Li ◽  
R. Singh ◽  
K. Huang ◽  
X. Feng

A thorough assessment of component life is very important to ensure both the safety and economics of gas turbine operation. As a component’s life given by OEM is based on certain ambient and operating conditions, its actual life may vary substantially when the ambient, operating and engine health conditions change. Therefore possessing knowledge on how those conditions affect actual component life will be valuable in making informed maintenance decisions, maximising operation effectiveness and cutting down operating costs. In this paper, an impact analysis on component creep life due to different operating and engine health conditions using an introduced Creep Factor is performed, which aims to provide useful insights on the relationship between gas turbine performance change and hot section component’s creep life. As the Creep Factor is defined as the ratio between the actual creep life and a reference creep life at a user-defined condition, the magnitude of the impact can be quantified with the change of the Creep Factor. The developed creep life analysis approach was applied to a model single spool turboshaft gas turbine engine operated at various operating and health conditions. A physics-based model combined with the Creep Factor approach was then used to estimate the creep life variation of the high pressure turbine of the model engine. The results showed that for a clean engine, the change in the rotational speed has given the highest impact on the creep life consumption. Also the presence of blade cooling and component degradation is seen to significantly reduce the blade’s creep life and as the degradation effects are combined, the degree of reduction increases even more. It also shows that the Creep Factor is good indicator of creep life consumption and provides a good technique to rank the influencing factor according to the threat they imposed.


2020 ◽  
Vol 0 (0) ◽  
Author(s):  
Benny George ◽  
Nagalingam Muthuveerappan

AbstractTemperature probes of different designs were widely used in aero gas turbine engines for measurement of air and gas temperatures at various locations starting from inlet of fan to exhaust gas from the nozzle. Exhaust Gas Temperature (EGT) downstream of low pressure turbine is one of the key parameters in performance evaluation and digital engine control. The paper presents a holistic approach towards life assessment of a high temperature probe housing thermocouple sensors designed to measure EGT in an aero gas turbine engine. Stress and vibration analysis were carried out from mechanical integrity point of view and the same was evaluated in rig and on the engine. Application of 500 g load concept to clear the probe design was evolved. The design showed strength margin of more than 20% in terms of stress and vibratory loads. Coffin Manson criteria, Larsen Miller Parameter (LMP) were used to assess the Low Cycle Fatigue (LCF) and creep life while Goodman criteria was used to assess High Cycle Fatigue (HCF) margin. LCF and HCF are fatigue related damage from high frequency vibrations of engine components and from ground-air-ground engine cycles (zero-max-zero) respectively and both are of critical importance for ensuring structural integrity of engine components. The life estimation showed LCF life of more than 4000 mission reference cycles, infinite HCF life and well above 2000 h of creep life. This work had become an integral part of the health monitoring, performance evaluation as well as control system of the aero gas turbine engine.


2020 ◽  
Vol 0 (0) ◽  
Author(s):  
Benny George ◽  
Nagalingam Muthuveerappan

Abstract Temperature probes of different designs were widely used in aero gas turbine engines for measurement of air and gas temperatures at various locations starting from inlet of fan to exhaust gas from the nozzle. Exhaust Gas Temperature (EGT) downstream of low pressure turbine is one of the key parameters in performance evaluation and digital engine control. The paper presents a holistic approach towards life assessment of a high temperature probe housing thermocouple sensors designed to measure EGT in an aero gas turbine engine. Stress and vibration analysis were carried out from mechanical integrity point of view and the same was evaluated in rig and on the engine. Application of 500 g load concept to clear the probe design was evolved. The design showed strength margin of more than 20% in terms of stress and vibratory loads. Coffin Manson criteria, Larsen Miller Parameter (LMP) were used to assess the Low Cycle Fatigue (LCF) and creep life while Goodman criteria was used to assess High Cycle Fatigue (HCF) margin. LCF and HCF are fatigue related damage from high frequency vibrations of engine components and from ground-air-ground engine cycles (zero-max-zero) respectively and both are of critical importance for ensuring structural integrity of engine components. The life estimation showed LCF life of more than 4000 mission reference cycles, infinite HCF life and well above 2000 h of creep life. This work had become an integral part of the health monitoring, performance evaluation as well as control system of the aero gas turbine engine.


Author(s):  
S. Eshati ◽  
M. F. Abdul Ghafir ◽  
P. Laskaridis ◽  
Y. G. Li

This paper investigates the relationship between design parameters and creep life consumption of stationary gas turbines using a physics based life model. A representative thermodynamic performance model is used to simulate engine performance. The output from the performance model is used as an input to the physics based model. The model consists of blade sizing model which sizes the HPT blade using the constant nozzle method, mechanical stress model which performs the stress analysis, thermal model which performs thermal analysis by considering the radial distribution of gas temperature, and creep model which using the Larson-miller parameter to calculate the lowest blade creep life. The effect of different parameters including radial temperature distortion factor (RTDF), material properties, cooling effectiveness and turbine entry temperatures (TET) is investigated. The results show that different design parameter combined with a change in operating conditions can significantly affect the creep life of the HPT blade and the location along the span of the blade where the failure could occur. Using lower RTDF the lowest creep life is located at the lower section of the span, whereas at higher RTDF the lowest creep life is located at the upper side of the span. It also shows that at different cooling effectiveness and TET for both materials the lowest blade creep life is located between the mid and the tip of the span. The physics based model was found to be simple and useful tool to investigate the impact of the above parameters on creep life.


Sign in / Sign up

Export Citation Format

Share Document