Difference in Critical Reynolds Number Between Hagen-Poiseuille and Plane Poiseuille Flows

Author(s):  
Hidesada Kanda

Abstract For plane Poiseuille flow, results of previous investigations were studied, focusing on experimental data on the critical Reynolds number, the entrance length, and the transition length. Consequently, concerning the natural transition, it was confirmed from the experimental data that (i) the transition occurs in the entrance region, (ii) the critical Reynolds number increases as the contraction ratio in the inlet section increases, and (iii) the minimum critical Reynolds number is obtained when the contraction ratio is the smallest or one, and there is no-shaped entrance or straight parallel plates. Its value exists in the neighborhood of 1300, based on the channel height and the average velocity. Although, for Hagen-Poiseuille flow, the minimum critical Reynolds number is approximately 2000, based on the pipe diameter and the average velocity, there seems to be no significant difference in the transition from laminar to turbulent flow between Hagen-Poiseuille flow and plane Poiseuille flow.

1975 ◽  
Vol 72 (4) ◽  
pp. 731-751 ◽  
Author(s):  
M. Nishioka ◽  
S. Iid A ◽  
Y. Ichikawa

Stability experiments were made on plane Poiseuille flow generated in a long channel of a rectangular cross-section with a width-to-depth ratio of 27·4. By reducing the background turbulence down to a level of 0·05 %, we succeeded in maintaining the flow laminar at Reynolds numbers up to 8000, which is much larger than the critical Reynolds number of the linear theory, about 6000. The downstream development of the sinusoidal disturbance introduced by the vibrating ribbon technique was studied in detail at various frequencies in the range of Reynolds number from 3000 to 7500. This paper presents the experimental results and clarifies the linear stability, the nonlinear subcritical instability and the breakdown leading to the transition.


The stability of plane Poiseuille flow in a channel forced by a wavelike motion on one of the channel walls is investigated. The amplitude Є of this forcing is taken to be small. The most dangerous modes of forcing are identified and it is found in general the critical Reynolds number is changed by O (Є) 2 . However, we identify two particular modes of forcing which give rise to decrements of order Є 2/3 and Є in the critical Reynolds number. Some types of forcing are found to generate sub critical stable finite amplitude perturbations to plane Poiseuille flow. This contrasts with the unforced case where the only stable solution is the zero amplitude solution. The forcing also deforms the unstable subcritical limit cycle solution from its usual circular shape into a more complicated shape. This has an effect on the threshold amplitude ideas suggested by, for example, Meksyn & Stuart (1951). It is found that the phase of disturbances must also be considered when finding the amplitude dependent critical Reynolds numbers.


1974 ◽  
Vol 96 (4) ◽  
pp. 384-388 ◽  
Author(s):  
M. A. Karnitz ◽  
M. C. Potter ◽  
M. C. Smith

The transition process of laminar flow between parallel plates is investigated experimentally. This problem has recently gained much attention with several reported works; however, the maximum transition Reynolds number reported has been approximately 3000 (based on average velocity and channel height) whereas the theoretical critical Reynolds number is 7700. Primary emphasis in this work is on approaching the theoretical limit in an experimental facility. A high aspect ratio (70 to 1) channel was used with air as the fluid. As the disturbance level at the entrance to the parallel plate section was reduced the transition Reynolds number increased monotonically. At a disturbance level of 0.3 percent the transition Reynolds number was 6700. Near transition small nearly sinusoidal waves in the critical shear layer were observed. The frequency of the waves was approximately 70 hertz, close to the frequency associated with the Tollmien-Schlichting waves of the critical point of linear theory. Sinusoidal waves preceded a turbulent burst which possessed an essentially plane front as it traveled downstream. As the Reynolds number was increased the bursting rate increased and the flow eventually became completely turbulent.


2008 ◽  
Vol 603 ◽  
pp. 189-206 ◽  
Author(s):  
S. MASUDA ◽  
S. FUKUDA ◽  
M. NAGATA

We analyse the stability of plane Poiseuille flow with a streamwise system rotation. It is found that the instability due to two-dimensional perturbations, which sets in at the well-known critical Reynolds number, Rc = 5772.2, for the non-rotating case, is delayed as the rotation is increased from zero, showing a stabilizing effect of rotation. As the rotation is increased further, however, the laminar flow becomes most unstable to perturbations which are three-dimensional. The critical Reynolds number due to three-dimensional perturbations at this higher rotation case is many orders of magnitude less than the corresponding value due to two-dimensional perturbations. We also perform a nonlinear analysis on a bifurcating three-dimensional secondary flow. The secondary flow exhibits a spiral vortex structure propagating in the streamwise direction. It is confirmed that an antisymmetric mean flow in the spanwise direction is generated in the secondary flow.


2019 ◽  
Vol 880 ◽  
pp. 478-496 ◽  
Author(s):  
Shengqi Zhang ◽  
Zhenhua Xia ◽  
Yipeng Shi ◽  
Shiyi Chen

Spanwise rotating plane Poiseuille flow (RPPF) is one of the canonical flow problems to study the effect of system rotation on wall-bounded shear flows and has been studied a lot in the past. In the present work, a two-dimensional-three-component (2D/3C) model for RPPF is introduced and it is shown that the present model is equivalent to a thermal convection problem with unit Prandtl number. For low Reynolds number cases, the model can be used to study the stability behaviour of the roll cells. It is found that the neutral stability curves, critical eigensolutions and critical streamfunctions of RPPF at different rotation numbers ($Ro$) almost collapse with the help of a rescaling with a newly defined Rayleigh number $Ra$ and channel height $H$. Analytic expressions for the critical Reynolds number and critical wavenumber at different $Ro$ can be obtained. For a turbulent state with high Reynolds number, the 2D/3C model for RPPF is self-sustained even without extra excitations. Simulation results also show that the profiles of mean streamwise velocity and Reynolds shear stress from the 2D/3C model share the same linear laws as the fully three-dimensional cases, although differences on the intercepts can be observed. The contours of streamwise velocity fluctuations behave like plumes in the linear law region. We also provide an explanation to the linear mean velocity profiles observed at high rotation numbers.


When two parallel plates move normal to each other with a slow time-dependent speed, the velocity field developed in the intervening film of fluid is approximately that of plane Poiseuille flow, except that the magnitude of the velocity is dependent on time and on the coordinate parallel to the planes. This fact is intrinsic to Reynolds’ lubrication theory, and can be shown to follow from the Navier-Stokes equations when both the modified Reynolds number ( Re M ) and an aspect ratio ( δ ) are small. The modified Reynolds number is the product of δ and an actual Reynolds number ( Re ), which is based on the gap between the planes and on a characteristic velocity. The occurrence of flow instability and of turbulence in the film depend on Re . Typical values of Re , which are known to be required for the linear instability of plane Poiseuille flow, are of order 6000. This condition can be achieved, even if Re M is of order 1, provided that δ is of order 10 -4 . Such parameter values are typical of lubrication problems. The Orr-Sommerfeld equation governing flow instability is derived in this paper by use of the WKBJ technique, δ being the approximate small parameter to represent the small length-scale of the disturbance oscillations compared with the larger scale of the basic laminar flow. However, the coefficients in the Orr-Sommerfeld equation depend on slow space and time variables. Consequently the eigenrelation, derivable from the Orr-Sommerfeld equation and the associated boundary conditions, constitutes a nonlinear first-order partial differential equation for a phase function. This equation is solved by use of Charpit’s method for certain special forms of the time-dependent gap between the planes, followed by detailed numerical calculations. The relation between time-dependence and flow instability is delineated by the calculated results. In detail the nature of the instability can be described as follows. We consider a disturbance wave at or near a particular station, the initial distribution of amplitude being gaussian in the slow coordinate parallel to the planes. In the context of the Orr-Sommerfeld equation and its eigenrelation, the particular station implies an equivalent Reynolds number, while the initial distribution of the disturbance wave implies an equivalent wavenumber. As time increases, the disturbance wave can be considered to move in the instability diagram of equivalent wavenumber against Reynolds number, in the sense that these parameters are time- and space-dependent for the evolution of the disturbance-wave system. For our detailed calculations we use a quadratic approximation to the eigenrelation, an approximation which is quite accurate. If the initial distribution implies a point within the neutral curve, when the plates are squeezed together the equivalent wavenumber falls while the equivalent Reynolds number rises, and amplification takes place until the lower branch of the neutral curve is nearly crossed. If the plates are pulled apart (dilatation) the equivalent wavenumber rises, while the Reynolds number drops, and amplification takes place until the upper branch of the neutral curve has been just crossed. In the case of dilatation the transition from amplification to damping takes place more quickly than for the case of squeezing, in part due to the geometry of the neutral curve.


Author(s):  
Fethi Aloui ◽  
Amal Elawady ◽  
Khaled J. Hammad

Abstract The study is an experimental investigations using PIV. The measurements were obtained by PIV for an unsteady laminar flow across a rectangular channel with a cross-section 300 × 30mm2, in the middle of which is located a cylindrical or a square obstacle. In the case of the cylindrical configuration and due to the confinement, PIV measurements in the range of 40 < Re < 200 clearly show that the von Karman vortex shedding appears at a critical Reynolds number which is about 66. A post-processing of these PIV measurements using the Proper Orthogonal Decomposition (POD) technique is by keeping only the first most energetic six modes, can be used as a filtering process to remove noise from instantaneous velocity signals. In the case of the square obstacle, PIV measurements obtained in the range of 30 < Re < 350 show the absence of vortex detachments and the chaotic behavior of the wake behind the obstacle beyond a certain Reynolds number. By examining the POD post-possessing results, the existence of a dynamic detachments’ regime (instantaneous breaking and coalescence of vortices), can be clearly observed. Given the chaotic behavior of the wake behind the obstacle, the application of the POD filtering process to only the first most energetic modes, cannot lead to good results.


1980 ◽  
Vol 102 (1) ◽  
pp. 5-12 ◽  
Author(s):  
A. Scha¨ffler

The general effect of Reynolds Number on axial flow compressors operating over a sufficiently wide range is described and illustrated by experimental data for four multistage axial compressors. The wide operating range of military aircraft engines leads in the back stages of high pressure ratio compression systems to three distinctly different regimes of operation, characterized by the boundary layer conditions of the cascade flow: • laminar separation, • turbulent attached flow with hydraulically smooth blade surface, • turbulent attached flow with hydraulically rough blade surface. Two “critical” Reynolds Numbers are defined, the “lower critical Reynolds Number” below which laminar separation occurs with a definite steepening of the efficiency/Reynolds Number relation and an “upper critical Reynolds Number” above which the blade surface behaves hydraulically rough, resulting in an efficiency independant of Reynolds Number. The permissible blade surface roughness for hydraulically smooth boundary layer conditions in modern high pressure ratio compression systems is derived from experimental data achieved with blades produced by grinding, electrochemical machining and forging. A correlation between the effect of technical roughness and sand type roughness is given. The potential loss of efficiency in the back end of compression systems due to excessive blade roughness is derived from experimental results. The repeatedly experienced different sensitivity of front and back stages towards laminar separation in the low Reynolds Number regime is explained by boundary layer calculations as a Mach Number effect on blade pressure distribution, i.e. transonic versus subsonic flow.


Sign in / Sign up

Export Citation Format

Share Document