Prediction of Closure Bolt Loads in Small Pressure Vessels: NUREG/CR-6007 vs. Detailed Finite Element Analysis
Closure bolt loads in a flanged cylindrical containment vessel under internal pressure are determined by detailed Finite Element Analysis (FEA) and compared to values determined using NUREG/CR-6007 equations. The containment vessel is of small diameter with an inwardly dished bolted head that geometrically contrasts with the large, flat lidded casks which the NUREG addressed. The comparison showed a significant difference in the magnitude of pressure driven prying load between the FEA model and the NUREG approximate equations. This difference affected the predicted pressure that overcomes preload, and the rate of load increase after preload was exceeded. The difference was likely due to the contrasts between this vessel’s closure shape compared to the more typical flat cask lid shape used in the NUREG development.