Relevancy of Force Concept Inventory and Mechanics Baseline Test in Excerpting Conceptual Understanding of High-Performing Students

2021 ◽  
Vol 03 (04) ◽  
Author(s):  
Bernard Ricardo

In the topics of mechanics, readily available instruments such as the Force Concept Inventory (FCI) and the Mechanics Baseline Test (MBT) have been extensively used to assess students’ conceptual understanding, especially for high school and undergraduate students. In this paper, the relevancy of these two instruments in excerpting conceptual understanding of high-performing students was examined and the results were elaborated. The findings in this paper suggest that the FCI and MBT are indeed effective to show students’ basic conceptual understanding in mechanics but should not be used to assess improvement after learning intervention or to differentiate students’ conceptual understanding in a population of high performers. More advanced assessments, such as those that comprise higher order thinking questions, should be used for such purposes.

2010 ◽  
Vol 39 (1) ◽  
Author(s):  
Phimpho Luangrath ◽  
Thongloon Vilaythong

This paper presents the situation of physics teaching and learning at the Science Foundation Studies program at National University of Laos. The study has focused on the students’ understanding of concepts in mechanics, and the situation of the laboratory work activities. The research tools used in this study were the Force Concept Inventory test, interviews and questionnaires. The results show that in an international comparison the Lao students reveal a low level of conceptual understanding in mechanics. They also show no improvement in their conceptual understanding after teaching. The students have little experience of laboratory work. They had expectations that laboratory work would be an interesting part of Physics Foundation Studies Course. However, few of the students do get involved in the actual measurements and handling of equipment during the practical activities. So, many of them do not feel that they learn much physics through laboratory work. This corresponds to their teachers’ understandings as well. Some strategies for improving the above mentioned aspects of physics teaching based on physics education research will be suggested. Cet article présentera la situation des processus d’enseignement et d’apprentissage de la physique au sein des classes préparatoires scientifiques de l’Université Nationale du Laos. Le but de ces classes est que les étudiants comprennent les concepts de mécanique et la situation des activités de laboratoire. Afin de mener cette étude, nous avons utilisé le test Force Concept Inventory (Inventaire des Concepts de Force), mené des interviews et appliqué des questionnaires. Au niveau international, les résultats montrent que les étudiants laotiens ont un niveau bas de compréhension des concepts de mécanique. Ils montrent également que ces mêmes étudiants n’améliorent pas leur compréhension après avoir participé au cours. Les étudiants possèdent peu d’expérience en laboratoire. Ils s’attendaient à ce que le travail de laboratoire soit une partie intéressante des classes préparatoires. Cependant, peu d’étudiants s’impliquent vraiment dans les mesures et dans la manipulation de l’équipement pendant les sessions de pratique. La plupart d’entre eux pensent donc ne pas apprendre grand-chose en physique pendant les pratiques de laboratoire. Cette sensation est également partagée par les professeurs. Notre objectif est donc de proposer quelques stratégies d’enseignement, soutenues par les recherches effectuées dans le domaine de l’enseignement de la physique.


2018 ◽  
Vol 9 (2) ◽  
pp. 117-130
Author(s):  
Martina Kekule ◽  
Jouni Viiri

This study sought to assess the representational format of task options in the representational variant of the force concept Inventory (R-FCI) test, namely its impact on students’ problem-solving approaches. This was done with the help of eye-tracking equipment. 35 high-school students solved four tasks, mainly from the R-FCI test, which sought to assess the student’s understanding of Newton’s 1st and 2nd Law of Motion. As they were trying to solve the problems, their gazes were tracked by TobiiTX300. A comparison between students who provided the correct and incorrect answer was subsequently carried out. The correctly answering students very quickly found the correct solution both in verbal and graph representation. For motion map representation, they usually compared and made decision between two options. The incorrectly answering students did not show any consistent strategy except they paid the least attention to the correct answer. Moreover, two case stud studies of correctly and incorrectly answering students were described.


2021 ◽  
Author(s):  
Ilva Cinite ◽  
◽  
Girts Barinovs ◽  

Education research has repeatedly shown that active learning in physics is pedagogically more efficient than traditional lecture courses. Widespread application of the active learning is slowed down by the lack of data on the performance of the active learning in widely varying circumstances of different educational systems. We measured the level of understanding of basic physics concepts using Force Concept inventory for students who enrol at different universities in Latvia in calculus-based and non-calculus-based groups and compared the student performance to the pre-test results elsewhere in the world. We measured the growth of concept inventory test results and studied the dependence of the growth on the teaching approach used by university lecturers. About 450 undergraduate students from 12 groups of science and engineering courses taught by 8 lecturers were involved in the study at three universities in Latvia. The Force Concept Inventory multiple-choice test was translated to Latvian and used for pre-/post-tests. The pre-test results showed that the maximum of the distribution of correct answers for non-calculus groups is around 20%, which is the value obtained by the random guessing of test answers, whereas the pre-test results of calculus-based groups was about 50% of correct answers. The test score after taking post-test confirmed that the growth of students’ tests results is closely related to the teaching approach chosen by lecturer, showing that in order to provide physics graduates with a good conceptual understanding of physics, student centred teaching approach was crucial. The use of concept inventories in undergraduate physics education to measure the progress of learning appears to be particularly important in the current situation with a small number of students in physics and a critically small number of future physics teachers, when efficiency of teaching is of crucial importance. Keywords: STEM education quality, conceptual understanding, student-centred approach


Pedagogika ◽  
2021 ◽  
Vol 143 (3) ◽  
pp. 223-239
Author(s):  
Nursultan Japashov ◽  
Aizhan Mansurova ◽  
Nuri Balta

In this work, we tried to check whether students can overcome their mistakes in conceptual physics questions by peer discussion. For this purpose, we administered Force Concept Inventory to high school students and university students. Our study showed that high school students and university students could not overcome their mistakes in the conceptual physics questions by peer discussion. We separately found out that males are better than females at conceptual physics questions.


Author(s):  
Siera M. Stoen ◽  
Mark A. McDaniel ◽  
Regina F. Frey ◽  
K. Mairin Hynes ◽  
Michael J. Cahill

Sign in / Sign up

Export Citation Format

Share Document