When using gaseous fuels for the C.F.R. engine, the lubricating oil decomposed to finely divided carbon when the gas was hydrogen and optimum spark advance nearly zero. When town gas was used, optimum spark advance varied from 85 to 15 degrees of crank angle, according to mixture strength, and the lubricant yielded carbon of the hard adherent graphitic variety. When using an L head engine having a combustion chamber with a large surface-to-volume ratio and with the spark plug so placed that optimum spark advance for town gas was approximately half that required with the C.F.R. engine, no appreciable carbon deposit of any variety was obtained. Conditions were therefore such that knocking combustion observed on adding finely divided carbon to the gas–air mixture was not caused to any appreciable degree by carbon derived from the lubricant. It was then found on adding carbon, as graphite dust, at a measured rate to the entering mixture, that approximately 0.3 mgm. in the end gas caused a knock intensity of the degree required to reduce brake horsepower by from 10 to 14%.