Biliary Atresia and Liver Transplantation: The National Institutes of Health Point of View
In August 1983, a bulletin, Liver Transplantation,1 printed and distributed under the aegis of the National Institutes of Health (NIH), was mailed to physicians throughout the United States. The bulletin was the product of a concensus panel convened to consider offered evidence (expert presentation of the available data) about liver transplantation. The panel was composed of a singular assortment of individuals including physicians in private practice, medical and pediatric department chairmen, a dean, a hospital director, and a person with a PhD in mathematics and statistics. Whatever the validity of their transplantation conclusions, the panel's recommendations about extrahepatic biliary atresia appear arbitrary and suspect, if not downright erroneous.