Abstract
Introduction
Visual search is important in many operational tasks, such as passive sonar monitoring in naval operations. Shift work can contribute to fatigue and task performance impairment; in particular, backward rotating shift schedules have been shown to impair vigilant attention performance. However, the impact on visual search performance, above and beyond impaired vigilant attention, is unknown. We investigated the effects of two distinct shift work schedules using a visual search task with properties of real-life visual search performance.
Methods
N=13 adult males (ages 18–39) completed a 6-day/5-night laboratory study with an acclimation day, four simulated shift days, and a recovery day. Shift days involved either a 5h-on/15h-off backward rotating schedule (n=8) or a 3h-on/9h-off fixed schedule (n=5). The visual search task was performed once per shift at varying time of day depending on shift. Participants viewed search arrays where stimuli consisted of colored letters of different shapes. Over three trial blocks of 24 trials each, participants determined if a target was present or absent among 1, 5, 15, or 30 distractors. Similarity between targets and distractors was manipulated between blocks, such that targets differed from distractors by color only, shape only, or either color or shape but not both. For each distinct target feature block, and separately for presence or absence of a target, slopes of response times regressed against number of stimuli were calculated to quantify visual search rates. Mixed-effects ANOVA was used to analyze visual search rates by shift schedule and shift day.
Results
There were no significant effects of shift schedule (all p>0.30), shift day (all p>0.13), or their interaction (all p>0.22) on visual search rates.
Conclusion
Previous work showed degraded vigilant attention in the shift schedules considered here, especially in the backward rotating schedule, which may compromise operational performance. However, while our sample may have been too small to have adequate statistical power, we failed to identify specific impairments in visual search with statistical significance. It remains to be determined whether greater levels of fatigue, such as could be induced by total sleep deprivation, would reveal significant visual search deficits.
Support (if any)
Naval Postgraduate School award N62271-13-M-1228
Predicting Search Performance in Heterogeneous Scenes: Quantifying the Impact of Homogeneity Effects in Efficient Search
