Effects of statistical learning in passive and active contexts on reproduction and recognition of auditory sequences
Implicit statistical learning is thought to play an important role in acquiring the structure of cultural communication signals such as speech and music. These are distinguished from other sensory phenomena by the fact that we not only perceive, but also reproduce them. While research has suggested an effect of implicit learning on auditory sequence reproduction, the effect has not been specifically related to statistical learning, nor has it been compared with that of passive exposure. In eight individual experiments with different task and stimulus configurations, the present research addresses these issues by presenting artificial pure-tone languages with controlled statistical properties in passive exposure, active sequence reproduction, and explicit sequence recognition tasks. The results demonstrate that statistical learning – during either passive familiarisation or sequence reproduction – surprisingly has no effect on reproduced sequence length. However, it does induce a characteristic pattern of error position effects, newly reported here, such that errors occur more often at points of low transition probability. While sequence reproduction engages statistical learning mechanisms, there is no additive influence of passive exposure and active reproduction when the two are combined, either in terms of reproduction or recognition performance. Finally, across a large sample of participants, there is no correlation between performance on the recognition and reproduction tasks. The results are consistent with an account of statistical learning in which listeners estimate the probabilistic structure of sequential auditory stimuli during passive exposure and reproduction, and then subsequently extract and memorise chunks based on this information when asked to do so in an explicit recognition task.