scholarly journals Review of: Photoacoustic hygrometer for icing wind tunnel water content measurement: Design, analysis and intercomparison by Lang et al.

2020 ◽  
Author(s):  
Anonymous
2021 ◽  
Vol 14 (3) ◽  
pp. 2477-2500
Author(s):  
Benjamin Lang ◽  
Wolfgang Breitfuss ◽  
Simon Schweighart ◽  
Philipp Breitegger ◽  
Hugo Pervier ◽  
...  

Abstract. This work describes the latest design, calibration and application of a near-infrared laser diode-based photoacoustic (PA) hygrometer developed for total water content measurement in simulated atmospheric freezing precipitation and high ice water content conditions with relevance in fundamental icing research, aviation testing, and certification. The single-wavelength and single-pass PA absorption cell is calibrated for molar water vapor fractions with a two-pressure humidity generator integrated into the instrument. Laboratory calibration showed an estimated measurement accuracy better than 3.3 % in the water vapor mole fraction range of 510–12 360 ppm (5 % from 250–21 200 ppm) with a theoretical limit of detection (3σ) of 3.2 ppm. The hygrometer is examined in combination with a basic isokinetic evaporator probe (IKP) and sampling system designed for icing wind tunnel applications, for which a general description of total condensed water content (CWC) measurements and uncertainties are presented. Despite the current limitation of the IKP to a hydrometeor mass flux below 90 gm-2s-1, a CWC measurement accuracy better than 20 % is achieved by the instrument above a CWC of 0.14 g m−3 in cold air (−30 ∘C) with suitable background humidity measurement. Results of a comparison to the Cranfield University IKP instrument in freezing drizzle and rain show a CWC agreement of the two instruments within 20 %, which demonstrates the potential of PA hygrometers for water content measurement in atmospheric icing conditions.


2020 ◽  
Author(s):  
Benjamin Lang ◽  
Wolfgang Breitfuss ◽  
Simon Schweighart ◽  
Philipp Breitegger ◽  
Hugo Pervier ◽  
...  

Abstract. This work describes the latest design, calibration and application of a near-infrared laser diode-based photoacoustic (PA) hygrometer, developed for total water content measurement in simulated atmospheric freezing precipitation and high ice water content conditions with relevance in fundamental icing research, as well as aviation testing and certification. The single-wavelength and single-pass PA absorption cell is calibrated for molar water vapor fractions with a two-pressure humidity generator integrated into the instrument. Laboratory calibration showed an estimated measurement accuracy better than 3.3 % in the water vapor mole fraction range of 510–12,360 ppm (5 % from 250–21,200 ppm) with a theoretical limit of detection (3 sigma) of 3.2 ppm. The hygrometer is examined in combination with a basic isokinetic evaporator probe (IKP) and sampling system designed for icing wind tunnel application, for which a general description of total condensed water content (CWC) measurement and uncertainties are presented. Despite the current limitation of the IKP to a hydrometeor mass flux below 90 g m−2 s−1, a CWC measurement accuracy better than 20 % is achieved by the instrument above a CWC of 0.14 g m−3 in cold air (−30 °C) with suitable background humidity measurement. Results of a comparison to the Cranfield University IKP instrument in freezing drizzle and rain show a CWC agreement of the two instruments within 20 %, which demonstrates the potential of PA hygrometers for water content measurement in atmospheric icing conditions.


2021 ◽  
Vol 42 (3) ◽  
Author(s):  
Rudolf Aro ◽  
Mohamed Wajdi Ben Ayoub ◽  
Ivo Leito ◽  
Éric Georgin ◽  
Benoit Savanier

AbstractIn the field of water content measurement, the calibration of coulometric methods (e.g., coulometric Karl Fischer titration or evolved water vapor analysis) is often overlooked. However, as coulometric water content measurement methods are used to calibrate secondary methods, their results must be obtained with the highest degree of confidence. The utility of calibrating such instruments has been recently demonstrated. Both single and multiple point calibration methods have been suggested. This work compares these calibration methods for the evolved water vapor analysis technique. Two uncertainty estimation approaches (Kragten’s spreadsheet and M-CARE software tool) were compared as well, both based on the ISO GUM method.


Sign in / Sign up

Export Citation Format

Share Document