Pigment pattern morphospace of Danio fishes: evolutionary diversification and mutational effects

ABSTRACT Molecular and cellular mechanisms underlying variation in adult form remain largely unknown. Adult pigment patterns of fishes in the genus Danio, which includes zebrafish, Danio rerio, consist of horizontal stripes, vertical bars, spots and uniform patterns, and provide an outstanding opportunity to identify causes of species level variation in a neural crest derived trait. Understanding pigment pattern variation requires quantitative approaches to assess phenotypes, yet such methods have been mostly lacking for pigment patterns. We introduce metrics derived from information theory that describe patterns and pattern variation in Danio fishes. We find that these metrics used singly and in multivariate combinations are suitable for distinguishing general pattern types, and can reveal even subtle phenotypic differences attributable to mutations. Our study provides new tools for analyzing pigment pattern in Danio and potentially other groups, and sets the stage for future analyses of pattern morphospace and its mechanistic underpinnings.

Differential growth is a critical determinant of zebrafish pigment pattern formation

The skin patterns of vertebrates are formed by complex interactions between pigment-producing cells during development. Adult zebrafish (Danio rerio), a model organism for investigating the underlying patterning processes, display alternating horizontal blue and golden stripes, generated by the self-organisation of three pigment cell-types. Mathematical studies in which these cells are modelled as individual agents communicating via short- and long-range interactions have produced breakthroughs in the understanding of pattern development. These models, incorporating all experimentally evidenced cell-cell interactions, replicate many aspects of wild-type and mutant zebrafish patterns. Although received wisdom suggested that initial iridophore distribution was pivotal in orienting patterning, here we show that growth can override its influence. Altered growth sequences can generate further pattern modulation, including vertical stripes and maze-like patterns. We demonstrate that ventrally-biased (asymmetric) growth of the skin field explains two key zebrafish pattern development features which are otherwise obscure (dorso-ventral pattern asymmetry, and predominant ventral-to-dorsal migration of melanophores) in wild-type and multiple zebrafish mutants, and in the related species Danio nigrofasciatus. By identifying biased growth as a novel patterning mechanism, our study will inform future investigations into the mechanisms and evolution of fish pigment patterning and vertebrate pigment pattern formation. Furthermore, our work has implications for the mechanistic basis of human pigmentation defects.

Pigment pattern morphospace of Danio fishes: evolutionary diversification and mutational effects

Molecular and cellular mechanisms underlying differences in adult form remain largely unknown. Adult pigment patterns of fishes in the genus Danio, which includes zebrafish, D. rerio, include horizontal stripes, vertical bars, spots and uniform patterns, and provide an outstanding opportunity to identify causes of species level variation in a neural crest derived trait. Yet understanding such variation requires quantitative approaches to assess phenotypes, and such methods have been mostly lacking for pigment patterns. We introduce metrics derived from information theory that describe patterns and pattern variation in Danio fishes. We find that such metrics used singly and in multivariate combinations are suitable for distinguishing general pattern types, and can reveal even subtle phenotypic differences attributable to mutations. Our study provides new tools for analyzing pigment pattern in Danio and potentially other groups, and sets the stage for future analyses of pattern morphospace and its mechanistic underpinnings.

A complex genetic architecture in zebrafish relatives Danio quagga and D. kyathit underlies development of stripes and spots

Vertebrate pigmentation is a fundamentally important, multifaceted phenotype. Zebrafish, Danio rerio, has been a valuable model for understanding genetics and development of pigment pattern formation due to its genetic and experimental tractability, advantages that are shared across several Danio species having a striking array of pigment patterns. Here, we use the sister species D. quagga and D. kyathit, with stripes and spots, respectively, to understand how natural genetic variation impacts phenotypes at cellular and organismal levels. We first show that D. quagga and D. kyathit phenotypes resemble those of wild-type D. rerio and several single locus mutants of D. rerio, respectively, in a morphospace defined by pattern variation along dorsoventral and anteroposterior axes. We then identify differences in patterning at the cellular level between D. quagga and D. kyathit by repeated daily imaging during pattern development and quantitative comparisons of adult phenotypes, revealing that patterns are similar initially but diverge ontogenetically. To assess the genetic architecture of these differences, we employ reduced-representation sequencing of second-generation hybrids. Despite the similarity of D. quagga to D. rerio, and D. kyathit to some D. rerio mutants, our analyses reveal a complex genetic basis for differences between D. quagga and D. kyathit, with several quantitative trait loci contributing to variation in overall pattern and cellular phenotypes, epistatic interactions between loci, and abundant segregating variation within species. Our findings provide a window into the evolutionary genetics of pattern-forming mechanisms in Danio and highlight the complexity of differences that can arise even between sister species. Further studies of natural genetic diversity underlying pattern variation in D. quagga and D. kyathit should provide insights complementary to those from zebrafish mutant phenotypes and more distant species comparisons.Author SummaryPigment patterns of fishes are diverse and function in a wide range of behaviors. Common pattern themes include stripes and spots, exemplified by the closely related minnows Danio quagga and D. kyathit, respectively. We show that these patterns arise late in development owing to alterations in the development and arrangements of pigment cells. In the closely related model organism zebrafish (D. rerio) single genes can switch the pattern from stripes to spots. Yet, we show that pattern differences between D. quagga and D. kyathit have a more complex genetic basis, depending on multiple genes and interactions between these genes. Our findings illustrate the importance of characterizing naturally occuring genetic variants, in addition to laboratory induced mutations, for a more complete understanding of pigment pattern development and evolution.

A quantitative modelling approach to zebrafish pigment pattern formation

Pattern formation is a key aspect of development. Adult zebrafish exhibit a striking striped pattern generated through the self-organisation of three different chromatophores. Numerous investigations have revealed a multitude of individual cell-cell interactions important for this self-organisation, but it has remained unclear whether these known biological rules were sufficient to explain pattern formation. To test this, we present an individual-based mathematical model incorporating all the important cell-types and known interactions. The model qualitatively and quantitatively reproduces wild type and mutant pigment pattern development. We use it to resolve a number of outstanding biological uncertainties, including the roles of domain growth and the initial iridophore stripe, and to generate hypotheses about the functions of leopard. We conclude that our rule-set is sufficient to recapitulate wild-type and mutant patterns. Our work now leads the way for further in silico exploration of the developmental and evolutionary implications of this pigment patterning system.