Abstract
Printed circuit board (PCB) sensors using low-cost commercial printed circuit board fabrication processes have been demonstrated for environmental sensing applications. One configuration of these sensors uses exposed electrodes to measure saltwater concentration in freshwater/seawater mixtures, through monitoring the resistance between the electrodes when they are immersed in the saltwater/freshwater solution. The lowest cost commercial PCB processes use an immersion Sn HASL surface finish on exposed copper cladding, including the sensing electrodes. This commercial PCB process has been demonstrated to make an effective, low-cost, short-lifetime sensor for saltwater concentration testing. The Sn finish, however, may not be optimal for this application. Sn oxidizes, which can interfere with sensor performance. Additionally, Sn and Sn oxides are potentially reactive with chemical constituents in seawater and seawater/freshwater solutions. An immersion Au (ENIG) surface finish is certainly less reactive with the atmosphere and chemicals likely present in the testing environment. However, an immersion Au finish increases the cost of the sensors by 30% to 40%. To investigate if the possible benefits of the more expensive Au surface finish are worth the extra expense, a study was performed where identical PCB sensors were procured from a commercial vendor with their standard low-cost Sn HASL finish and with their standard ENIG surface finish. Both sets of sensors were then evaluated in concentrations of seawater and freshwater, from 0% to 100% seawater concentration, using freshwater samples from a natural freshwater source near the coast where the seawater was obtained. Testing demonstrated an insignificant difference in sensor performance between the Sn HASL and the ENIG coated sensing electrodes. The results of this investigation indicated that for applications where the sensors will not be used for long periods of time, the added expense of an immersion Au surface finish is not worth the added cost.
