scholarly journals Questioning medical competence: Should the Covid-19 crisis affect the goals of medical education?

2021 ◽  
pp. 1-7
Author(s):  
Olle ten Cate ◽  
Karen Schultz ◽  
Jason R. Frank ◽  
Marije P. Hennus ◽  
Shelley Ross ◽  
...  
Author(s):  
Marie Giroux ◽  
Luce Pélissier-Simard

AbstractSome highly challenging, seemingly “unsolvable” situations that arise in medical education could be the result of autistic traits (AT) in learners. AT exist in physicians and learners, ranging from profiles compatible with DSM-5’s criteria for autism spectrum disorder (ASD) to more subtle manifestations of ASD’s “broader phenotype.” Often associated with strengths and talents, AT may nonetheless pose significant challenges for learning, teaching, and practising medicine. Since AT remain widely under-recognized and misunderstood by educators, clinicians, and affected individuals alike, they represent a blind spot in medical education. The use of a “neurodiversity lens” to examine challenging situations may help educators consider different pedagogical approaches to address those potentially stemming from AT.This paper aims to raise awareness and understanding of AT-related difficulties in struggling medical learners. To overcome the blind spot challenge and help develop this “neurodiversity lens,” we explore different angles. Beyond any diagnostic consideration, we offer a series of contextual examples, paralleled with explanatory concepts from the field of ASD. We also underline the role of context on functional impact and describe the often ill-defined pattern of challenges encountered, as well as the fertile grounds for interpersonal misunderstandings and disrespect. We propose historical, cultural, and clinical reasons likely contributing to the blind spot. Mindful of the potential risks of prejudice associated with identifying AT-related difficulties, we underline the necessity and feasibility of conciliating diversity and dignity with accountability standards for medical competence.


2021 ◽  
Vol 8 ◽  
Author(s):  
Jared A. Danielson

This perspective explores six key assumptions of a competency-based approach to medical-sciences education, as they relate to veterinary medical education. Those assumptions, derived from characteristics of competency based medical education (CBME) identified by CBME proponents are: (1) There are sufficient shortcomings in the medical competence of graduate veterinarians that solutions are necessary, and changes in the way we teach veterinarians will address those problems. (2) It is feasible to identify generally accepted core competencies in veterinary medical practice. (3) Teaching to defined learning outcomes will produce greater achievement for learners than approaches that do not emphasize clearly defined outcomes. (4) In veterinary medical education, it is possible to articulate the development of competence sequentially in a manner that is relatively consistent across learners, and carefully planning and sequencing learning activities will produce better learning outcomes. (5) Competency-focused instruction, which tailors the pace and progression of instruction to learners, is feasible in veterinary medical education, and will produce better outcomes than instruction that moves all students through an equivalent process in a set time frame. (6) Programmatic Assessment, including numerous direct observations with feedback, will improve learning outcomes, and is feasible in veterinary medical education. While available research does not unequivocally support all six assumptions, overall the potential benefits of adopting a competency-based approach seem promising for veterinary medical education.


Author(s):  
Tuulikki Keskitalo ◽  
Heli Ruokamo

Medical education can be emotionally charged for many reasons, while simulation-based activities in particular are designed to generate emotional reactions. However, few studies have concentrated on the relationship between learning and emotions in this field, despite widespread interest in the topic in other areas. The aim of this research was to study the emotional experiences of participants before and after simulation-based teaching and learning activities. Data were collected from 238 participants using pre- and post-questionnaires and analysed using descriptive statistics, a paired samples t test, factor analysis, Cronbach’s alpha, a linear regression analysis and k-means cluster analysis. Participants were clustered into engaged, neutral and anxious learners based on their emotional profiles. The results showed that simulation-based learning invoked mainly positive emotions, whereas negative emotions decreased to a slight degree during an educational course. This study also revealed variables that may explain emotional variations. The article provides practical implications of the findings for simulation-based medical education and higher education in general. Implications for practice or policy: Positive emotions in simulation-based education can be promoted by challenging participants and providing activities at the appropriate level of difficulty. Learners may benefit from individual guidance and support, reducing their anxiety and building their sense of medical competence. Being cognisant of emotional subgroups among participants can help tailor instruction for individual learners. Simulation-based education can be targeted to educate learners to cope with difficult emotions and how to seek help.


Author(s):  
Christine Tjahjadinata ◽  
Natalia Puspadewi ◽  
Elisabeth Rukmini

Background: Based on the existing research, medical competence achievements in DKI Jakarta’s primary health care was lower than other provinces in Indonesia. Some of the competence achievements in preclinical years were also lower than the level of competence achievement in the Standard of Indonesian Doctor Competence, regardless the diseases are at the third and fourth levels. This research aimed at exploring the factors which influenced the competence achievement of the preclinical years based on student’s perceptions.Methods: The research was a descriptive analytic study with a qualitative approach using Focus Group Disscussion (FGD). Nine preclinical students of 2013 batch were chosen purposefully based on the recommendation from faculty members and students. Data were analyzed qualitatively using thematic analysis method.Results: There are several factors that influence the competence achievement of the preclinical students. These included the factors of student, curriculum, faculty, environmental, and facility.  There were four participants in the first meeting and five participants in the second meeting.Conclusion: Based on student’s perception, the factors which affect the competence achievements in preclinical years are student factors, curriculum factors, faculty factors, environmental factors, and facility factors. Keywords: competence, medical education, preclinical, qualitative


2000 ◽  
Vol 34 (12) ◽  
pp. 1016-1018 ◽  
Author(s):  
Harri Hyppola ◽  
Esko Kumpusalo ◽  
Irma Virjo ◽  
Kari Mattila ◽  
Liisa Neittaanmaki ◽  
...  

Sign in / Sign up

Export Citation Format

Share Document