What Do We Know About Student Transition?
Understanding how changing schools affects children can help educators in their efforts to create welcoming and supportive school environments. It is also important to be aware of the different types of transitions a student may experience between prekindergarten and high school. While the purpose of this book is to highlight the different ways educators can support children and families changing schools, it’s still important to look at the many reasons why they are changing. School moves are commonly classified as one of two types: structural or nonstructural. Structural changes occur when students are required to switch schools because of the distinct features of or changes within the education system. The most common example of a structural change is promotional, such as when a child finishes 5th grade and goes to a new school for 6th grade. These promotional moves are typically viewed as transitions rather than school moves. The development of new schools to address overcrowding, the rezoning of school boundaries, or the closing of low- performing schools are other examples of structural changes. While students and parents might not always feel positive about a structural move, a student tends to move with peers when these changes happen and thus is not considered a “new student.” Nonstructural mobility, on the other hand, is any school change that is not created by the features of the school system and can be the result of a multitude of life circumstances. These can include a parent’s new job, a divorce, a change in custody or foster family for a child, the result of a disciplinary action at a school, or a conflict with a teacher or another student. Students may also switch schools because they— or their parents— are seeking a specific type of academic program, such as a magnet program or a charter school. According to Dr. Russell Rumberger at the University of California Santa Barbara, 60% of students nationally make unscheduled school changes at some point between kindergarten and 12th grade. A smaller proportion of students experience many more of these changes. The scientific literature shows that both promotional and nonpromotional changes may create challenges.