The Evolution of Gas Turbine Generator Set Reliability in the U.S. Navy

Author(s):  
Dennis M. Russom ◽  
Ivan Pin˜eiro

This paper looks back at the evolution of the Gas Turbine Generator sets (GTGs) in the U.S. Navy’s DDG 51 Class, reviewing lessons learned, successes and areas where work is still required. Topics are discussed in the context of Mean Time Between Failure (MTBF) Total Ownership Cost (TOC) and maintainability. It reviews changes that resulted in MTBF increasing by a factor of five and TOC dropping by a factor of four. It also looks to the future, identifying potential areas of further improvement.

Author(s):  
Morgan L. Hendry ◽  
B. Michael Zekas

The U.S. Navy has nearly forty years of experience using SSS (Synchro-Self-Shifting) Clutches in main reduction gears of gas-turbine-driven ships and propulsion systems with combinations of gas turbines and diesel engines or electric motors, and in steam-turbine propulsion plants for use with electric motor drives. Over 900 SSS Clutches have been installed in fourteen different classes of U.S. Navy ships, some in service for over thirty years. This paper presents a brief overview of the principle SSS Clutch design features and the operating experience in naval propulsion systems worldwide, including operation in various propulsion plants such as controllable reversible pitch (CRP) propellers, fixed-pitch propellers (FPP), etc. The paper will also focus on SSS Clutch designs for specific U.S. Navy applications and installations, U.S. Navy experience, and design changes and improvements that have been implemented since the initial U.S. Navy use of SSS Clutches. Detailed metric (statistical) data, used by the U.S. Navy to evaluate equipment performance and life cycle costs, such as mean time between failure (MTBF), mean time to repair (MTTR), mean logistics delay time (MLDT), and operational availability (Ao) will be used to support experience. In-service experience and failure modes will also be explained as well as findings from the evaluation of clutches that have been subjected to extreme operation/incidents such as overspeed, overtorque, high shock blast, and flood damage. The final part of the paper will discuss current/future applications on U.S. Navy vessels such as the LHD-8, LCS and others; and how the design/features of those SSS Clutch designs will satisfy the operational, reliability, and maintainability requirements established for each ship platform. The metrics and lessons learned will be shown to be equally applicable to clutches for critical auxiliary drive applications such as naval gas turbine generator starting and naval steam turbine generator turning gear systems and how these metrics and lessons learned are being applied for current and future U.S. Navy ship systems.


Author(s):  
Dennis M. Russom ◽  
Russell A. Leinbach ◽  
Helen J. Kozuhowski ◽  
Dana D. Golden

Operational availability of Gas Turbine Generator Sets (GTGs) aboard the U.S. Navy’s DDG 51 Class ships is being enhanced through the combined capabilities of the ship’s Integrated Condition Assessment System (ICAS) and the GTG’s Full Authority Digital Control (FADC). This paper describes the ICAS and FADC systems; their current capabilities and the vision of how those capabilities will evolve in order to improve equipment readiness and reduce life cycle costs.


Author(s):  
Dennis M. Russom ◽  
William E. Masincup ◽  
John Eghtessad

The Redundant Independent Mechanical Start System (RIMSS) is a gas turbine powered, mechanically coupled start system for the Allison AG9140 Ship Service Gas Turbine Generator Sets (SSGTGs) of the U.S. Navy’s DDG-51 Class ships. The system will be original equipment on DDG-86 and follow. It will also be a candidate for backfit onto earlier DDG-51 Class ships. This paper describes RIMSS and details a very successful phase of the RIMSS program. All U.S. Navy testing was conducted on an Allison AG9140 located at the Carderock Division, Naval Surface Warfare Center-Ship Systems Engineering Station, DDG-51 Gas Turbine Ship Land Based Engineering Site (NSWCCD-SSES LBES), Figure 1. The test agenda included 516 SSGTG starts and 75 SSGTG motoring cycles. The primary goal was to validate engine life predictions for the Allison 250-C20B gas turbine engine in the RIMSS application. A secondary goal was to evaluate the overall RIMSS system during an extended period of operation.


Author(s):  
Eleanor M. Allison ◽  
Edward M. House

Four Textron Lycoming TF40B marine gas turbine engines are used to power the U.S. Navy’s Landing Craft Air Cushion (LCAC) vehicle. This is the first hovercraft of this configuration to be put in service for the Navy. Operation and test of the first production craft revealed deficiencies and less than desirable reliability, but confirmed the validity of its design and ability to perform the mission. After intensive efforts to resolve these problems, reliability trends began to improve as a result of corrective actions incorporated. Today, the LCAC fleet has accrued over 50,000 engine operating hours. Presented here are the changes which have been incorporated into the configuration of the TF40B engine to eliminate both engine unique and vehicle related discrepancies revealed through fleet experience. These changes have contributed significantly toward the improvement of the engine’s mean time between removal (MTBR) and mean time between failure (MTBF) rates.


Author(s):  
Dennis M. Russom ◽  
Robert L. Jernoske

The Rolls-Royce Allison (RRA) 501-K34 serves as the prime mover for the Ship Service Gas Turbine Generator sets (SSGTGs) of the U.S. Navy’s DDG-51 Class ships. Navy experience with the 501-K34 began in 1988 with the testing of the first prototype. Experience to date includes over 700,000 fired hours on a growing fleet of engines. This paper explores that operating experience and discusses future plans to improve the engine’s operational availability while lowering life cycle costs.


Author(s):  
Daniel E. Caguiat

Currently, the U.S. Navy DDG-51 class ships employ a system of piping, tanks, and nozzles for washing the four Gas Turbine Main (GTM) engines and three Ship Service Gas Turbine Generator (SSGTG) engines. The wash system employed, referred to as the crankwash system, allows the user to wash the compressor section of a gas turbine only when the turbine in question is not operating. On a DDG-51 class ship, it is possible to utilize the existing crankwash piping, tank, and overall architecture to supply water to an online water wash system. An online water wash system allows the compressor section to be cleaned while the gas turbine is in operation. This is intended to reduce the periodicity of crankwashing and associated starter cycling costs. Online water wash is also intended to maintain compressor cleanliness in the interval between crankwashes. NAVSEA Philadelphia researched appropriate online water wash system designs, methods for collecting data to address fuel savings and engine performance issues, and installation methods. GTM and SSGTG Online Water Wash Systems were then installed on USS PREBLE (DDG-88) in late 2008. USS PREBLE subsequently deployed for a period of six months beginning January 2009. During the deployment, data was collected as the systems were operated. This paper will discuss the system design, provide data analysis results, and discuss lessons learned.


Author(s):  
Dennis M. Russom

The Ship Service Gas Turbine Generator sets (SSGTGs) on the U.S. Navy’s DDG-51 Class ships have experienced several gas turbine engine failures resulting from seawater contamination of the lube oil. The seawater enters the turbine lube oil system after a corrosion related failure of the lube oil cooler. This paper examines the system design, failure mechanism, and consequence of the failure. It also discusses maintenance actions intended to minimize the possibility of cooler failures, methods that have been used to clean up contaminated systems and alternate cooler designs that are being considered for backfit.


2006 ◽  
Vol 129 (3) ◽  
pp. 785-791 ◽  
Author(s):  
Morgan L. Hendry ◽  
Matthew G. Hoffman

Most gas turbine generators rely on an automatic-engaging, free-wheel clutch to connect a starting motor to accelerate the gas turbine generator from zero to some intermediate speed to enable ignition and then provide torque assistance to a higher speed until the gas turbine is self-sustaining. The U.S. Navy has used various designs of starter motors and clutches for its gas turbine fleet. In addition, there has been a requirement to periodically borescope each gas turbine, which has necessitated removal of the starting system and clutch assembly in each instance. This paper examines the U.S. Navy experience with starting clutches and provides details of the development and testing of a synchronous-self-shifting clutch with an additional, stationary, manual turning feature to provide very slow and precise gas turbine rotor rotation for borescope purposes. This paper also gives details of the installation of the first two prototype clutches on the USS Ramage, DDG 61, operating experience for approximately four years, and possible future installations of this type of clutch in U.S. Navy gas turbine generator sets.


Author(s):  
John J. McGroarty

The Design Development and Implementation Program (DDIP) evolved as a result of an organized progression of In-Service Engineering (ISE) responsibilities required to implement improvements to Gas Turbine Generator Sets (GTGS) in the U.S. Navy. The DDIP was established to bring a design concept, whether it be to correct a problem or to make a design improvement, from the drawing board through testing and development to the implementation of a Technical Directive as quickly as possible. Presently all engineering improvements on U.S. Navy Gas Turbine Generator Sets are implemented through the DDIP. Providing this central point of engineering has helped the Naval Sea Systems Command implement improvements in a well tested and timely manner. This paper describes the sequential processes in the DDIP methodology and further discusses specific engineering problems and solutions using the DDIP process.


Author(s):  
Morgan L. Hendry ◽  
Matthew G. Hoffman

Most gas turbine generators rely on an automatic-engaging, free-wheel clutch to connect a starting motor to accelerate the gas turbine generator from zero to some intermediate speed to enable ignition and then provide torque assistance to a higher speed until the gas turbine is self-sustaining. The U.S. Navy has used various designs of starter motors and clutches for its gas turbine fleet. In addition, there has been a requirement to periodically borescope each gas turbine and this has necessitated removal of the starting system and clutch assembly in each instance. This paper examines the U.S. Navy experience with starting clutches and provides details of the development and testing of a synchronous-self-shifting clutch with an additional, stationary, manual turning feature to provide very slow and precise gas turbine rotor rotation for borescope purposes. This paper also gives details of the installation of the first two prototype clutches on the USS Ramage, DDG 61, operating experience for approximately four years, and possible future installations of this type of clutch in U.S Navy gas turbine generator sets.


Sign in / Sign up

Export Citation Format

Share Document