Classification of Thin-Walled Conical Vessels for Design Against Axisymmetric Plastic Collapse Under External Pressure

Author(s):  
Patrick Meehan ◽  
Robert Frith

This paper presents the results of a study that investigates the propensity of thin walled vessels with cone-cylinder junctions to plastically collapse under external pressure. The investigation focuses on the conical portion of the vessel collapsing in an axisymmetric mode prior to buckling in a classical lobar mode. Using a parametric study, comparison is made between the factor of safety afforded by design-by-rule approaches such as that offered in ASME Section VIII Div. 1, ASME Section VIII Div. 2 Part 4.4 and elastic-plastic design by analysis approaches prescribed by ASME Section VIII Div.2 Part 5. Further, the results of the parametric study are used to determine the key parameters that result in the occurrence of an axisymmetric collapse mode before the classical lobar buckling mode. The research has led to the development of a set of criteria to indicate susceptibility of geometry to axisymmetric collapse prior to classical lobar buckling.

2006 ◽  
Vol 06 (04) ◽  
pp. 457-474 ◽  
Author(s):  
M. A. BRADFORD ◽  
A. ROUFEGARINEJAD ◽  
Z. VRCELJ

Circular thin-walled elastic tubes under concentric axial loading usually fail by shell buckling, and in practical design procedures the buckling load can be determined by modifying the local buckling stress to account empirically for the imperfection sensitive response that is typical in Donnell shell theory. While the local buckling stress of a hollow thin-walled tube under concentric axial compression has a solution in closed form, that of a thin-walled circular tube with an elastic infill, which restrains the local buckling mode, has received far less attention. This paper addresses the local buckling of a tubular member subjected to axial compression, and formulates an energy-based technique for determining the local buckling stress as a function of the stiffness of the elastic infill by recourse to a transcendental equation. This simple energy formulation, with one degree of buckling freedom, shows that the elastic local buckling stress increases from 1 to [Formula: see text] times that of a hollow tube as the stiffness of the elastic infill increases from zero to infinity; the latter case being typical of that of a concrete-filled steel tube. The energy formulation is then recast into a multi-degree of freedom matrix stiffness format, in which the function for the buckling mode is a Fourier representation satisfying, a priori, the necessary kinematic condition that the buckling deformation vanishes at the point where it enters the elastic medium. The solution is shown to converge rapidly, and demonstrates that the simple transcendental formulation provides a sufficiently accurate representation of the buckling problem.


Author(s):  
Mitch Hokazono ◽  
Clayton T. Smith

Integral light-water reactor designs propose the use of steam generators located within the reactor vessel. Steam generator tubes in these designs must withstand external pressure loadings to prevent buckling, which is affected by material strength, fabrication techniques, chemical environment and tube geometry. Experience with fired tube boilers has shown that buckling in boiler tubes is greatly alleviated by controlling ovality in bends when the tubes are fabricated. Light water reactor steam generator pressures will not cause a buckling problem in steam generators with reasonable fabrication limits on tube ovality and wall thinning. Utilizing existing Code rules, there is a significant design margin, even for the maximum differential pressure case. With reasonable bend design and fabrication limits the helical steam generator thermodynamic advantages can be realized without a buckling concern. This paper describes a theoretical methodology for determining allowable external pressure for steam generator tubes subject to tube ovality based on ASME Section III Code Case N-759-2 rules. A parametric study of the results of this methodology applied to an elliptical cross section with varying wall thicknesses, tube diameters, and ovality values is also presented.


2011 ◽  
Vol 64 (1) ◽  
pp. 201-210 ◽  
Author(s):  
Sarat Kumar Das ◽  
Rajani Kanta Biswal ◽  
N. Sivakugan ◽  
Bitanjaya Das

2018 ◽  
Vol 123 ◽  
pp. 214-221 ◽  
Author(s):  
Zhaochao Li ◽  
Yan Tang ◽  
Fujian Tang ◽  
Yizheng Chen ◽  
Genda Chen

2010 ◽  
Vol 133 (1) ◽  
Author(s):  
Sotiria Houliara ◽  
Spyros A. Karamanos

The present paper investigates structural response and buckling of long unstiffened thin-walled cylindrical steel shells, subjected to bending moments, with particular emphasis on stability design. The cylinder response is characterized by cross-sectional ovalization, followed by buckling (bifurcation instability), which occurs on the compression side of the cylinder wall. Using a nonlinear finite element technique, the bifurcation moment is calculated, the post-buckling response is determined, and the imperfection sensitivity with respect to the governing buckling mode is examined. The results show that the buckling moment capacity is affected by cross-sectional ovalization. It is also shown that buckling of bent elastic long cylinders can be described quite accurately through a simple analytical model that considers the ovalized prebuckling configuration and results in very useful closed-form expressions. Using this analytical solution, the incorporation of the ovalization effects in the design of thin-walled cylinders under bending is thoroughly examined and discussed, considering the framework of the provisions of the new European Standard EN1993-1-6.


Author(s):  
Hanxun Jin ◽  
Alexander K. Landauer ◽  
Kyung-Suk Kim

Here, we report the closure resistance of a soft-material bilayer orifice increases against external pressure, along with ruga-phase evolution, in contrast to the conventional predictions of the matrix-free cylindrical-shell buckling pressure. Experiments demonstrate that the generic soft-material orifice creases in a threefold symmetry at a limit-load pressure of p / μ  ≈ 1.20, where μ is the shear modulus. Once the creasing initiates, the triple crease wings gradually grow as the pressure increases until the orifice completely closes at p / μ  ≈ 3.0. By contrast, a stiff-surface bilayer orifice initially wrinkles with a multifold symmetry mode and subsequently develops ruga-phase evolution, progressively reducing the orifice cross-sectional area as pressure increases. The buckling-initiation mode is determined by the layer's thickness and stiffness, and the pressure by two types of the layer's instability modes—the surface-layer-wrinkling mode for a compliant and the ring-buckling mode for a stiff layer. The ring-buckling mode tends to set the twofold symmetry for the entire post-buckling closure process, while the high-frequency surface-layer-wrinkling mode evolves with successive symmetry breaking to a final closure configuration of two- or threefold symmetry. Finally, we found that the threefold symmetry mode for the entire closure process provides the orifice's strongest closure resistance, and human saphenous veins remarkably follow this threefold symmetry ruga evolution pathway.


1974 ◽  
Vol 18 (04) ◽  
pp. 272-277
Author(s):  
C. T. F. Ross

Numerical solutions have been produced for the asymmetric instability of thin-walled circular cylindrical and truncated conical shells under external pressure. The solutions for the circular cylinder have shown that the assumed buckling configurations of Nash [l]2 and Kaminsky [2] were quite reasonable for fixed ends. Comparison was also made of the finite-element solution of conical shells with other analyses. From these calculations, it was shown that the numerical solutions were superior to the analytical ones, as the former could be readily applied to vessels of varying thickness or those subjected to unsymmetrical loading or with complex boundary conditions.


Sign in / Sign up

Export Citation Format

Share Document