Abstract
Funding Acknowledgements
Type of funding sources: None.
Background/Introduction
Heart failure has a poor prognosis, and the number of patients continues to increase. Moreover, since it is a disease that causes various sufferings, substantial end-of-life care is needed. Advanced care planning (ACP) is a part of end-of-life care for patients with heart failure. ACP provides patient decision-making opportunities, documenting end-of-life preferences, and increasing end-of-life conversation. However, the ACP intervention for patients with heart failure is not integrated, and studies are insufficient. In addition, Japan follows a non-Western culture, in which participation in the medical decision-making is reluctant and considered to be less prepared for ACP. Clarifying the effects of systematic ACP on patients with heart failure in Japan can be used to determine effective interventions in Japan and may provide effective ACP intervention for patients who have no preparedness worldwide.
Purpose
This study aimed to identify the effect of protocol-based intervention on the outcomes of ACP in Japanese outpatients with heart failure.
Methods
This is a single-center retrospective observational study. Data on patient attributes, conversation records, and document information from medical records of patients who have undergone intervention using the predeveloped ACP protocol were collected. Numerical data were statistically analyzed. ACP results were evaluated by performing deductive content analysis on the basis of existing frameworks. A subgroup analysis was performed on differences in ACP outcomes based on patient attributes.
Results
Data were collected from 13 patients who underwent ACP intervention. The median age was 69 years. Moreover, 76% were male, 84% were married, 76% were living with family, and 46% were receiving home-visit nursing care. New York Heart Association functional classification II was the most common in the severity classification of heart failure, and ischemic cardiomyopathy was the most common etiology. Documenting patient’s wishes, recording patient’s wishes in medical record, and identifying what brings value to patient"s life were achieved in 76% of the participants. Deciding surrogate decision makers, discussing values and care preferences with the surrogate, and discussing values and care preferences with health care professionals were achieved in 69% of the participants. Differences in patient attributes, such as age and presence or absence of home-visit nursing, did not affect ACP outcomes.
Conclusion
Protocol-based ACP allows patients with heart failure to determine surrogate decision makers and discuss care preferences with healthcare professionals, identify what they value, and record their wishes. The protocol-based ACP had a positive impact on ACP outcomes, without being restricted by patient attributes.
“Sometimes we can’t fix things”: a qualitative study of health care professionals’ perceptions of end of life care for patients with heart failure
