Do dipole sonic logs measure group or phase velocity (revisited)?
We have revisited the debate about whether flexural waves from dipole sonic tools and standard processing algorithms measure group or phase velocities in anisotropic formations. We observe that much of the confusion arises from a failure to understand the different meanings of group and phase velocities. Using a transversely isotropic medium with a vertical axis of symmetry that exhibits a triplication in its S-wave group slowness surface, we generate synthetic flexural sonic waveforms corresponding to boreholes at angles of 0°–90° with respect to the anisotropy symmetry axis in 1° increments. We processed these synthetic data using standard time- and frequency-domain semblance methods. The results conclusively demonstrate that dipole sonic logs measure the group slowness for the group angle corresponding to the angle between the borehole and the anisotropic symmetry axis. In addition, data that we have evaluated suggest that current tool geometries and semblance processing may not always be sensitive enough to resolve all branches of the group slowness triplication surface.