Two-Dimensional Axisymmetric Thermostructural Analysis of APR1400 Reactor Vessel Lower Head for Full-Core Meltdown Accident

2016 ◽  
Vol 195 (1) ◽  
pp. 15-28
Author(s):  
Hyo-Nam Kim ◽  
Ihn Namgung
Author(s):  
Juan Luo ◽  
Jiacheng Luo ◽  
Lei Sun ◽  
Peng Tang

In the core meltdown severe accident, in-vessel retention (IVR) of molten core debris by external reactor vessel cooling (ERVC) is an important mitigation strategy. During the IVR strategy, the core debris forming a melt pool in the reactor pressure vessel (RPV) lower head (LH) will produce extremely high thermal and mechanical loadings to the RPV, which may cause the failure of RPV due to over-deformation of plasticity or creep. Therefore, it is necessary to study the thermomechanical behavior of the reactor vessel LH during IVR condition. In this paper, under the assumption of IVR-ERVC, the thermal and structural analysis for the RPV lower head is completed by finite element method. The temperature field and stress field of the RPV wall, and the plastic deformation and creep deformation of the lower head are obtained by calculation. Plasticity and creep failure analysis is conducted as well. Results show that under the assumed conditions, the head will not fail due to excessive creep deformation within 200 hours. The results can provide basis for structural integrity analysis of pressure vessels.


Author(s):  
Jun Yeong Jung ◽  
Yong Hoon Jeong

In-Vessel Retention by External Reactor Vessel Cooling (IVR-ERVC) is method of removing the decay heat by cooling reactor vessel after corium relocation, and is also one of severe accident management strategies. Estimating heat transfer coefficients (HTCs) is important to evaluate heat transfer capability of the ERVC. In this study, the HTCs of outer wall of reactor vessel lower head were experimentally measured under the IVR-ERVC situation of Large Loss of Coolant Accident (LLOCA) condition. Experimental equipment was designed to simulate flow boiling condition of ERVC natural circulation, and based on APR+ design. This study focused on effects of real reactor vessel geometry (2.5 m of radius curvature) and material (SA508) for the HTCs. Curved rectangular water channel (test section) was design to simulate water channel which is between the reactor vessel lower head outer wall and thermal insulator. Radius curvature, length, width and gap size of the test section were respectively 2.5 m, 1 m, 0.07 m and 0.15 m. Two connection parts were connected at inlet and outlet of the test section to maintain fluid flow condition, and its cross section geometry was same with one of test section. To simulate vessel lower head outer wall, thin SA508 plate was used as main heater, and test section supported the main heater. Thickness, width, length and radius curvature of the main heater were 1.2 mm, 0.07 m, 1 m and 2.5 m respectively. The main heater was heated by DC rectifier, and applied heat flux was under CHF value. The test section was changed for each experiment. The HTCs of whole reactor vessel lower head (bottom: 0 ° and top: 90 °) were measured by inclining the test section, and experiments were conducted at four angular ranges; 0–22.5, 22.5–45, 45–67.5 and 67.5–90 °. DI water was used as working fluid in this experiment, and all experiments were conducted at 400 kg/m2s of constant mass flux with atmospheric pressure. The working fluid temperatures were measured at two point of water loop by K-type thermocouple. The main heater surface temperatures were measured by IR camera. The main heater was coated by carbon spray to make uniform surface emissivity, and the IR camera emissivity calibration was also conducted with the coated main heater. The HTCs were calculated by measured main heater surface temperature. In this research, the HTC results of 10, 30, 60 and 90 ° inclination angle were presented, and were plotted with wall super heat.


Author(s):  
Osamu Kawabata ◽  
Masao Ogino

When the primary reactor system remain pressurized during core meltdown for a typical PWR plant, loop seals formed in the primary reactor system would lead to natural circulations in hot leg and steam generator. In this case, the hot gas released from the reactor core moves to a steam generator, and a steam generator tube would be failed with cumulative creep damage. From such phenomena, a high-pressure scenario during core meltdown may lead to large release of fission products to the environment. In the present study, natural circulation and creep damage in the primary reactor system accompanying the hot gas generation in the reactor core were discussed and the combining analysis with MELCOR and FLUENT codes were performed to examine the natural circulation behavior. For a typical 4 loop PWR plant, MELCOR code which can analyze for the severe accident progression was applied to the accident analyses from accident initiation to reactor vessel failure for the accident sequence of the main steam pipe break which is maintained at high pressure during core meltdown. In addition, using the CFD code FLUENT, fluid dynamics in the reactor vessel plenum, hot leg and steam generator of one loop were simulated with three-dimensional coordinates. And the hot gas natural circulation flow and the heat transfer to adjoining structures were analyzed using results provided by the MELCOR code as boundary conditions. The both ratios of the natural circulation flow calculated in the hot leg and the steam generator using MELCOR code and FLUENT code were obtained to be about 2 (two). And using analytical results of thermal hydraulic analysis with both codes, creep damage analysis at hottest temperature points of steam generator tube and hot leg were carried out. The results in both cases showed that a steam generator tube would be failed with creep rupture earlier than that of hot leg rupture.


Author(s):  
K. H. Kang ◽  
R. J. Park ◽  
J. T. Kim ◽  
S. B. Kim ◽  
H. D. Kim

The analysis of the LAVA (Lower-plenum Arrested Vessel Attack) experimental results focused on gap formation and in-vessel gap cooling characteristics have been performed. In the LAVA experiment, Al2O3/Fe thermite melt (or Al2O3 only) was used as a corium simulant with a 1/8 linear scale mock-up of the reactor vessel lower plenum. The experimental results address the non-adherence of the debris to the lower head vessel and the consequent gap formation in case there was an internal pressure load across the vessel. The thermal behaviors of the lower head vessel during the cooldown period were mainly affected by the heat removal characteristics through this gap, which were mainly determined by the possibilities of the water ingression into the gap. The possibility of heat removal through the gap in the LAVA experiments was confirmed from that the vessel cooled down with the conduction heat flux through the vessel by 70 to 470 kW/m2. Also the quantitative evaluations of the in-vessel coolability using gap cooling model based on counter current flow limits (CCFL) have been performed for the LAVA experiments in parallel. It could be inferred from the analysis for the LAVA experiments that the vessel could effectively cooldown via heat removal through the gap cooling even if 2mm thick gap should form between the interface of the melt and the vessel in the 30 kg of Al2O3 melt tests. In the case of large melt mass of 70 kg of Al2O3 melt, however, the infinite possibility of heat removal through a small size gap such as 1 to 2 mm thick couldn’t be guaranteed due to the difficulties of water ingression through the gap into the lower head vessel bottom induced by the CCFL. Synthesized the experimental results and the analytical evaluations using the CCFL model, it could be found that the coolability through gap cooling was affected mainly by the melt composition and mass and also the gap thickness.


Author(s):  
Walter Villanueva ◽  
Chi-Thanh Tran ◽  
Pavel Kudinov

An in-vessel stage of a severe core melt accident in a Nordic type Boiling Water Reactor (BWR) is considered wherein a decay-heated pool of corium melt inflicts thermal and mechanical loads on the lower-head vessel wall. This process induces creep leading to a mechanical failure of the reactor vessel wall. The focus of this study is to investigate the effect of Control Rod Guide Tube (CRGT) and top cooling on the modes of global vessel failure of the lower head. A coupled thermo-mechanical creep analysis of the lower head is performed and cases with and without CRGT and top cooling are compared. The debris bed heat-up, re-melting, melt pool formation, and heat transfer are calculated using the Phase-change Effective Convectivity Model and transient heat transfer characteristics are provided for thermo-mechanical strength calculations. The creep analysis is performed with the modified time hardening creep model and both thermal and integral mechanical loads on the reactor vessel wall are taken into account. Known material properties of the reactor vessel as a function of temperature, including the creep curves, are used as an input data for the creep analysis. It is found that a global vessel failure is imminent regardless of activation of CRGT and top cooling. However, if CRGT and top cooling is activated, the mode and timing of failure is different compared to the case with no CRGT and top cooling. More specifically, with CRGT and top cooling, there are two modes of global vessel failure depending on the size of the melt pool: (a) ‘ballooning’ of the vessel bottom for smaller pools, and (b) ‘localized creep’ concentrated within the vicinity of the top surface of the melt pool for larger pools. Without CRGT and top cooling, only a ballooning mode of global vessel failure is observed. Furthermore, a considerable delay (about 1.4 h) on the global vessel failure is observed for the roughly 30-ton debris case if CRGT and top cooling is implemented. For a much larger pool (roughly 200-ton debris), no significant delay on the global vessel failure is observed when CRGT and top cooling is implemented, however, the liquid melt fraction and melt superheat are considerably higher in non-cooling case.


Author(s):  
K. H. Kang ◽  
R. J. Park ◽  
K. M. Koo ◽  
S. B. Kim ◽  
H. D. Kim

Feasibility experiments were performed for the assessment of improved In-Vessel Corium Retention (IVR) concepts using an internal engineered gap device and also a dual strategy of In/Ex-vessel cooling using the LAVA experimental facility. The internal engineered gap device made of carbon steel was installed inside the LAVA lower head vessel and it made a uniform gap with the vessel by 10 mm. In/Ex-vessel cooling in the dual strategy experiment was performed installing an external guide vessel outside the LAVA lower head vessel at a uniform gap of 25 mm. The LAVA lower head vessel was a hemispherical test vessel simulated with a 1/8 linear scale mock-up of the reactor vessel lower plenum with an inner diameter of 500 mm and thickness of 25 mm. In both of the tests, Al2O3 melt was delivered into about 50K subcooled water inside the lower head vessel under the elevated pressure. Temperatures of the internal engineered gap device and the lower head vessel were measured by K-type thermocouples embedded radially in the 3mm depth of the lower head vessel outer surface and in the 4mm depth of the internal engineered gap device, respectively. In the dual strategy experiment, the Ex-vessel cooling featured pool boiling in the gap between the lower head vessel and the external guide vessel. It could be found from the experimental results that the internal engineered gap device was intact and so the vessel experienced little thermal and mechanical attacks in the internal engineered gap device experiment. And also the vessel was effectively cooled via mutual boiling heat removal in- and ex-vessel in the dual strategy experiment. Compared with the previous LAVA experimental results performed for the investigation of the inherent in-vessel gap cooling, it could be confirmed that the Ex-vessel cooling measure was dominant over the In-vessel cooling measure in this study. It is concluded that the improved cooling measures using a internal engineered gap device and a dual strategy promote the cooling characteristics of the lower head vessel and so enhance the integrity of the vessel in the end.


Author(s):  
D. L. Knudson ◽  
J. L. Rempe

Molten core materials may relocate to the lower head of a reactor vessel in the latter stages of a severe accident. Under such circumstances, in-vessel retention (IVR) of the molten materials is a vital step in mitigating potential severe accident consequences. Whether IVR occurs depends on the interactions of a number of complex processes including heat transfer inside the accumulated molten pool, heat transfer from the molten pool to the reactor vessel (and to overlying fluids), and heat transfer from exterior vessel surfaces. SCDAP/RELAP5-3D© has been developed at the Idaho National Engineering and Environmental Laboratory to facilitate simulation of the processes affecting the potential for IVR, as well as processes involved in a wide variety of other reactor transients. In this paper, current capabilities of SCDAP/RELAP5-3D© relative to IVR modeling are described and results from typical applications are provided. In addition, anticipated developments to enhance IVR simulation with SCDAP/RELAP5-3D© are outlined.


Sign in / Sign up

Export Citation Format

Share Document