HMOS—ANOTHER ROADBLOCK FOR ALZHEIMER'S DRUG
The first Cognex auguries are not promising. These signs of resistance come from two of the nation's largest HMOs, Northern California Kaiser Permanente and the Group Health Cooperative of Puget Sound. Northern California Kaiser has already decided to ban Cognex from its formulary... Cognex is expected to cost about $1,300 to $1,500 annually per patient, and this does not include the costs of blood tests and physician visits required to guard against side effects. Against this Kaiser argues that Cognex helps only some victims of Alzheimer's Disease; the gain is not very great in many patients; and some who take Cognex suffer liver toxicity that the HMOs would have to treat. So from an HMO's point of view, Cognex is not "cost-effective," the magic mantra of HMO health care. But for anyone who's aware of the living hell in which many Alzheimer's patients and their families live, this argument does not wash... Americans still expect their doctors to put patients' interests first. As the Cognex incident at the two major HMOs shows, that expectation need not be satisfied in HMO health care. Mr. Clinton, his health reform, and the American people can only benefit if the president takes specific measures to ensure that patients' expectations and HMO reality are congruent.