scholarly journals The attainment of herd immunity with a restructured risk of contact infection in compartmental models

2021 ◽  
Author(s):  
Kian Boon Law ◽  
Kalaiarasu M Peariasamy ◽  
Hishamshah Ibrahim ◽  
Noor Hisham Abdullah
Keyword(s):  
Infectious Disease ◽  
Herd Immunity ◽  
Approximate Solutions ◽  
Sir Model ◽  
Compartmental Models ◽  
Mixed Population ◽  
Reproduction Ratio ◽  
Force Of Infection ◽  
Infection Dynamics ◽  
The Difference

Abstract Introduction: The risk of contact infection among susceptible individuals in a randomly mixed population can be reduced by the presence of immune individuals and this concept is referred as herd immunity. Although herd immunity is observed in vaccinated population for some infectious diseases, it has never been truly attained in compartmental models such as the susceptible-infectious-recovered (SIR) model. This paper introduces a new SIR framework to overcome the limitation of the conventional SIR model in attaining herd immunity.Methods: Two SIR models were newly developed based on the reduced risk of contact infection. The first model A assumes that the risk of contact infection reduces as soon as susceptible individuals are infected and move from class S(t) to I(t), therefore incorporating prevalence of both infectious and susceptible individuals into its force of infection. The second model B assumes the risk of contact infection would reduce after infected individuals have recovered from infection and move from class I(t) to R(t), therefore incorporating the prevalence of infectious and the inverse of prevalence of recovered individuals into its force of infection. Then, numerical simulations were applied to obtain approximate solutions for all three conventional SIR model, new SIR model A and model B for comparison under exact and arbitrary conditions with β = 0.3 and σ = 0.1 to mimic the infection dynamics with basic reproduction ratio (r0) of 3.0 and herd immunity threshold (HIT) of 0.667 (66.7%).Results and discussion: All three models performed likewise at the initial stage of epidemic. The conventional SIR model simulated the epidemic diminishing when 94.0% of the population had been infected and recovered, way above its HIT. Model A simulated the epidemic waning when 66.7% of the population had been infected and recovered, in line with its HIT, however, the model conceptualized the herd immunity incorrectly. Model B simulated the epidemic waning at 75.6%, slightly above its HIT and was in line with the fundamental of herd immunity. The difference between model A and model B can be attributed to the proportion of infectious individuals, and this would increase in infectious disease with high transmissibility. The threshold theorem derived based on r0 may not be sufficient for optimal control and eradication of infectious disease with high transmissibility like the COVID-19.Conclusion: The newly developed SIR model that includes the inverse of proportion of recovered individuals into its force of infection is more accurate and credible for modelling infection with high transmissibility or vaccine-induced herd immunity in a randomly mixed population, especially in COVID-19.

scholarly journals The attainment of herd immunity with a restructured risk of contact infection in compartmental models

2021 ◽  
Author(s):  
Kian Boon Law ◽  
Kalaiarasu M Peariasamy ◽  
Hishamshah Ibrahim ◽  
Noor Hisham Abdullah
Keyword(s):  
Infectious Disease ◽  
Herd Immunity ◽  
Approximate Solutions ◽  
Sir Model ◽  
Compartmental Models ◽  
Mixed Population ◽  
Reproduction Ratio ◽  
Force Of Infection ◽  
Infection Dynamics ◽  
The Difference

Abstract Introduction: The risk of contact infection among susceptible individuals in a randomly mixed population can be reduced by the presence of immune individuals and this concept is referred to as herd immunity. Although herd immunity is observed in vaccinated populations for some infectious diseases, it has never been truly attained in compartmental models such as the susceptible-infectious-recovered (SIR) model. This paper introduces a new SIR framework to overcome the limitation of the conventional SIR model in attaining herd immunity.Methods: Two SIR models were newly developed based on the reduced risk of contact infection. The first model A assumes that the risk of contact infection reduces as soon as susceptible individuals are infected and move from class S(t) to I(t), therefore incorporating prevalence of both infectious and susceptible individuals into its force of infection. The second model B assumes the risk of contact infection would reduce after infected individuals have recovered from infection and move from class I(t) to R(t), therefore incorporating the prevalence of infectious and the inverse of prevalence of recovered individuals into its force of infection. Then, numerical simulations were applied to obtain approximate solutions for all three conventional SIR model, new SIR model A and model B for comparison under exact and arbitrary conditions with β = 0.3 and σ = 0.1 to mimic the infection dynamics with basic reproduction ratio (r0) of 3.0 and herd immunity threshold (HIT) of 0.667 (66.7%).Results and discussion: All three models performed likewise at the initial stage of the epidemic. The conventional SIR model simulated the epidemic diminishing when 94.0% of the population had been infected and recovered, way above its HIT. Model A simulated the epidemic waning when 66.7% of the population had been infected and recovered, in line with its HIT. However, the model conceptualized herd immunity incorrectly. Model B simulated the epidemic waning at 75.6%, slightly above its HIT and was more in line with the fundamental of herd immunity. The difference between model A and model B can be attributed to the proportion of infectious individuals, and this would increase in infectious disease with high transmissibility. The threshold theorem derived based on r0 may not be sufficient for optimal control and eradication of infectious disease with high transmissibility like the COVID-19.Conclusion: The newly developed SIR model that includes the inverse of proportion of recovered individuals into its force of infection is more accurate and credible for modelling infection with high transmissibility or vaccine-induced herd immunity in a randomly mixed population, especially in COVID-19.

scholarly journals The attainment of herd immunity with reduced risk of contact infection in modelling

2021 ◽  
Author(s):  
Kian Boon Law ◽  
Kalaiarasu M Peariasamy ◽  
Hishamshah Ibrahim ◽  
Noor Hisham Abdullah
Keyword(s):  
Infectious Disease ◽  
Herd Immunity ◽  
Sir Model ◽  
Mixed Population ◽  
Reproduction Ratio ◽  
Force Of Infection ◽  
Population Immunity ◽  
Modelling Framework ◽  
And Control ◽  
Reduced Risk

Abstract The risk of contact infection among susceptible individuals in a randomly mixed population can be reduced by the presence of immune individuals and this concept is referred to as herd immunity1–3. The conventional susceptible-infectious-recovered (SIR) model does not feature a reduced risk of susceptible individuals in the transmission dynamics of infectious disease, therefore violates the fundamental of herd immunity4. Here we show that the reduced risk of contact infection among susceptible individuals in the SIR model can be attained by incorporating the proportion of susceptible individuals (model A) or the inverse of proportion of recovered individuals (model B) in the force of infection of the SIR model. We simulated the conventional SIR model and both new SIR models under the exact condition with a basic reproduction ratio of 3.0 and an expected herd immunity threshold of 0.667 (66.7%). All three models performed likewise at the initial stage of an epidemic. In the conventional SIR model, the epidemic continued until 94.0 % of the population had been infected and recovered, way above the threshold for eradication and control of the epidemic. Both models A and B simulated the epidemic waning when 66.7% and 75.6% of the population had been infected, as a result of the herd effect. As a result, model A provides a better framework for modelling vaccine-induced herd or population immunity, while model B provides a better framework for modelling infection-induced herd or population immunity. Our results demonstrate how the new modelling framework overcomes the drawback of the conventional SIR model and attain the effect of herd immunity in modelling outputs, which is important for modelling infectious disease in a randomly mixed population, especially for the COVID-19 pandemic.

scholarly journals The attainment of herd immunity with a reducing risk of contact infection in modelling 

2021 ◽  
Author(s):  
Kian Boon Law ◽  
Kalaiarasu M Peariasamy ◽  
Hishamshah Ibrahim ◽  
Noor Hisham Abdullah
Keyword(s):  
Infectious Disease ◽  
Disease Transmission ◽  
Herd Immunity ◽  
Sir Model ◽  
Mixed Population ◽  
Transmission Model ◽  
Force Of Infection ◽  
Initial Stage ◽  
And Control ◽  
Model Features

Abstract The risk of contact infection among susceptible individuals in a randomly mixed population can be reduced by the presence of immune individuals and this principle forms the fundamental of herd immunity. The conventional susceptible-infectious-recovered (SIR) model features an infection-induced herd immunity model, but does not include the reducing risk of contact infection among susceptible individuals in the transmission model, therefore tends to overestimate the transmission dynamics of infectious diseases. Here we show that the reducing risk of contact infection among susceptible individuals can be achieved by incorporating the proportion of susceptible individuals (model A) or the inverse of proportion of recovered individuals (model B) in the force of infection of the SIR model. We numerically simulated the conventional SIR model and both new SIR models A and B under the exact condition with a basic reproduction number of 3·0. Prior to the numerical simulation, the threshold for the eradication of infectious disease through herd immunity was expected to be 0·667 (66·7%) for all three models. All three models performed likewise at the initial stage of disease transmission. In the conventional SIR model, the infectious disease subsided when 94·0 % of the population had been infected and recovered, way above the expected threshold for eradication and control of the infectious disease. Both models A and B simulated the infectious disease to diminish when 66·7% and 75·6% of the population had been infected, showing herd immunity might protect more susceptible individuals from the infectious disease as compared to the projection generated by the conventional SIR. Our study shows that model A provides a better framework for modelling herd immunity through vaccination, while model B provides a better framework for modelling herd immunity through infection. Both models overcome the insufficiency of the conventional SIR model in attaining the effect of herd immunity in modelling outputs, which is important and relevant for modelling infectious disease, such as the COVID-19 in a randomly mixed population.

scholarly journals Modelling infectious diseases with herd immunity in a randomly mixed population

2021 ◽  
Author(s):  
Kian Boon Law ◽  
Kalaiarasu M. Peariasamy ◽  
Hishamshah Mohd. Ibrahim ◽  
Noor Hisham Abdullah
Keyword(s):  
Infectious Disease ◽  
Infectious Diseases ◽  
Transmission Rate ◽  
Herd Immunity ◽  
Sir Model ◽  
Mixed Population ◽  
Transmission Dynamics ◽  
Transmission Model ◽  
Infection Model ◽  
Vaccination Rates

Abstract Background The conventional susceptible-infectious-recovered (SIR) model tends to overestimate the transmission dynamics of infectious diseases and ends up with total infections and total immunized population exceeding the threshold required for control and eradication of infectious diseases. The study aims to overcome the limitation by allowing the transmission rate of infectious disease to decline along with the reducing risk of contact infection. Methods Two new SIR models were developed to mimic the declining transmission rate of infectious diseases at different stages of transmission. Model A mimicked the declining transmission rate along with the reducing risk of transmission following infection, while Model B mimicked the declining transmission rate following recovery. Then, the conventional SIR model, Model A and Model B were used to simulate an infectious disease with a basic reproduction number (r0) of 3.0 and a herd immunity threshold (HIT) of 0.667 with and without vaccination. The infectious disease was expected to be controlled or eradicated when the total immunized population either through infection or vaccination reached the level predicted by the HIT. Outcomes of simulations were assessed at the time when the total immunized population reached the level predicted by the HIT, and at the end of simulations. Findings All three models performed likewise at the beginning of the transmission when sizes of infectious and recovered were relatively small as compared with the population size. The infectious disease modelled using the conventional SIR model appeared completely out of control even when the HIT was achieved in all scenarios with and without vaccination. The infectious disease modelled using Model A appeared to be controlled at the level predicted by the HIT in all scenarios with and without vaccination. Model B projected the infectious disease to be controlled at the level predicted by the HIT only at high vaccination rates. At lower vaccination rates or without vaccination, the level at which the infectious disease was controlled cannot be accurately predicted by the HIT. Conclusion Transmission dynamics of infectious diseases with herd immunity can accurately be modelled by allowing the transmission rate of infectious disease to decline along with the combined risk of contact infection. Model B provides a more credible framework for modelling infectious diseases with herd immunity in a randomly mixed population.

scholarly journals Modelling infectious diseases with herd immunity in a randomly mixed population

2021 ◽  
Author(s):  
Kian Boon Law ◽  
Kalaiarasu M Peariasamy ◽  
Hishamshah Ibrahim ◽  
Noor Hisham Abdullah
Keyword(s):  
Infectious Disease ◽  
Infectious Diseases ◽  
Transmission Rate ◽  
Herd Immunity ◽  
Sir Model ◽  
Mixed Population ◽  
Transmission Dynamics ◽  
Transmission Model ◽  
Infection Model ◽  
Vaccination Rates

Abstract Background The conventional susceptible-infectious-recovered (SIR) model tends to overestimate transmission dynamics of infectious diseases and ends up with total infections exceeding the threshold required for control and eradication of infectious diseases. The study aims to overcome the limitation by allowing the transmission rate of infectious disease to decline along with the reducing risk of contact infection. MethodsTwo new SIR models were developed to mimic the declining transmission rate of infectious diseases at different stages of transmission. Model A mimicked the declining transmission rate along with the reducing risk of transmission following infection, while Model B mimicked the declining transmission rate following recovery. Then, the conventional SIR model, Model A and Model B were used to simulate an infectious disease with a basic reproduction number (r0) of 3.0 and a herd immunity threshold (HIT) of 0.667 with and without vaccination. The infectious disease was expected to be controlled or eradicated when the total immunized population either through infection or vaccination reached the level predicted by the HIT. Outcomes of simulations were assessed at the time when the total immunized population reached the level predicted by the HIT, and at the end of simulations.Findings All three models performed likewise at the beginning of transmission when sizes of infectious and recovered were relatively small as compared with the population size. The infectious disease modelled using the conventional SIR model appeared completely out of control even when the HIT was achieved in all scenarios with and without vaccination. The infectious disease modelled using Model A appeared to be controlled at the level predicted by the HIT in all scenarios with and without vaccination. Model B projected the infectious disease to be controlled at the level predicted by the HIT only at high vaccination rates. At lower vaccination rates or without vaccination, the level at which the infectious disease was controlled cannot be accurately predicted by the HIT. ConclusionTransmission dynamics of infectious diseases with herd immunity can accurately be modelled by allowing the transmission rate of infectious disease to decline along with the combined risk of contact infection. Model B provides a more realistic framework for modelling infectious diseases with herd immunity in a randomly mixed population.

scholarly journals Modelling infectious diseases with herd immunity in a randomly mixed population

2021 ◽  
Author(s):  
Kian Boon Law ◽  
Kalaiarasu M. Peariasamy ◽  
Hishamshah Mohd. Ibrahim ◽  
Noor Hisham Abdullah
Keyword(s):  
Infectious Disease ◽  
Infectious Diseases ◽  
Transmission Rate ◽  
Herd Immunity ◽  
Sir Model ◽  
Mixed Population ◽  
Transmission Dynamics ◽  
Transmission Model ◽  
Infection Model ◽  
Vaccination Rates

Abstract Background The conventional susceptible-infectious-recovered (SIR) model tends to overestimate the transmission dynamics of infectious diseases and ends up with total infections and total immunized population exceeding the threshold required for control and eradication of infectious diseases. The study aims to overcome the limitation by allowing the transmission rate of infectious disease to decline along with the reducing risk of contact infection. Methods Two new SIR models were developed to mimic the declining transmission rate of infectious diseases at different stages of transmission. Model A mimicked the declining transmission rate along with the reducing risk of transmission following infection, while Model B mimicked the declining transmission rate following recovery. Then, the conventional SIR model, Model A and Model B were used to simulate an infectious disease with a basic reproduction number (r0) of 3.0 and a herd immunity threshold (HIT) of 0.667 with and without vaccination. The infectious disease was expected to be controlled or eradicated when the total immunized population either through infection or vaccination reached the level predicted by the HIT. Outcomes of simulations were assessed at the time when the total immunized population reached the level predicted by the HIT, and at the end of simulations.Findings All three models performed likewise at the beginning of the transmission when sizes of infectious and recovered were relatively small as compared with the population size. The infectious disease modelled using the conventional SIR model appeared completely out of control even when the HIT was achieved in all scenarios with and without vaccination. The infectious disease modelled using Model A appeared to be controlled at the level predicted by the HIT in all scenarios with and without vaccination. Model B projected the infectious disease to be controlled at the level predicted by the HIT only at high vaccination rates. At lower vaccination rates or without vaccination, the level at which the infectious disease was controlled cannot be accurately predicted by the HIT. Conclusion Transmission dynamics of infectious diseases with herd immunity can accurately be modelled by allowing the transmission rate of infectious disease to decline along with the combined risk of contact infection. Model B provides a more credible framework for modelling infectious diseases with herd immunity in a randomly mixed population.

scholarly journals Modelling infectious diseases with herd immunity in a randomly mixed population

2021 ◽  
Vol 11 (1) ◽  
Author(s):  
Kian Boon Law ◽  
Kalaiarasu M. Peariasamy ◽  
Hishamshah Mohd Ibrahim ◽  
Noor Hisham Abdullah
Keyword(s):  
Infectious Disease ◽  
Infectious Diseases ◽  
Transmission Rate ◽  
Herd Immunity ◽  
The United States ◽  
Sir Model ◽  
Mixed Population ◽  
Transmission Dynamics ◽  
Vaccination Rates ◽  
Reduced Risk

AbstractThe conventional susceptible-infectious-recovered (SIR) model tends to magnify the transmission dynamics of infectious diseases, and thus the estimated total infections and immunized population may be higher than the threshold required for infection control and eradication. The study developed a new SIR framework that allows the transmission rate of infectious diseases to decline along with the reduced risk of contact infection to overcome the limitations of the conventional SIR model. Two new SIR models were formulated to mimic the declining transmission rate of infectious diseases at different stages of transmission. Model A utilized the declining transmission rate along with the reduced risk of contact infection following infection, while Model B incorporated the declining transmission rate following recovery. Both new models and the conventional SIR model were then used to simulate an infectious disease with a basic reproduction number (r0) of 3.0 and a herd immunity threshold (HIT) of 0.667 with and without vaccination. Outcomes of simulations were assessed at the time when the total immunized population reached the level predicted by the HIT, and at the end of simulations. Further, all three models were used to simulate the transmission dynamics of seasonal influenza in the United States and disease burdens were projected and compared with estimates from the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. For the simulated infectious disease, in the initial phase of the outbreak, all three models performed expectedly when the sizes of infectious and recovered populations were relatively small. As the infectious population increased, the conventional SIR model appeared to overestimate the infections even when the HIT was achieved in all scenarios with and without vaccination. For the same scenario, Model A appeared to attain the level predicted by the HIT and in comparison, Model B projected the infectious disease to be controlled at the level predicted by the HIT only at high vaccination rates. For infectious diseases with high r0, and at low vaccination rates, the level at which the infectious disease was controlled cannot be accurately predicted by the current theorem. Transmission dynamics of infectious diseases with herd immunity can be accurately modelled by allowing the transmission rate of infectious diseases to decline along with the reduction of contact infection risk after recovery or vaccination. Model B provides a credible framework for modelling infectious diseases with herd immunity in a randomly mixed population.

scholarly journals Persistence of a pandemic in the presence of susceptibility and infectivity distributions in a population: Mathematical model

2021 ◽  
Author(s):  
Saumyak Mukherjee ◽  
Sayantan Mondal ◽  
Biman Bagchi
Keyword(s):  
Infectious Disease ◽  
Kinetic Monte Carlo ◽  
Herd Immunity ◽  
Sir Model ◽  
Multiple Infection ◽  
Combined Effects ◽  
Disease Cluster ◽  
Rate Of Spread ◽  
Range Migration ◽  
Spatio Temporal

The birth and death of a pandemic can be region specific. Pandemic seems to make repeated appearance in some places which is often attributed to human neglect and seasonal change. However, difference could arise from different distributions of inherent susceptibility (σ_{inh}) and external infectivity (ι_{ext}) from one population to another. These are often ignored in the theoretical treatments of an infectious disease progression. While the former is determined by the immunity of an individual towards a disease, the latter depends on the duration of exposure to the infection. Here we model the spatio-temporal propagation of a pandemic using a generalized SIR (Susceptible-Infected-Removed) model by introducing the susceptibility and infectivity distributions to comprehend their combined effects. These aspects have remained inadequately addressed till date. We consider the coupling between σ_{inh} and ι_{ext} through a new critical infection parameter (γ_{c}). We find that the neglect of these distributions, as in the naive SIR model, results in an overestimation in the estimate of the herd immunity threshold. That is, the presence of the distributions could dramatically reduce the rate of spread. Additionally, we include the effects of long-range migration by seeding new infections in a region. We solve the resulting master equations by performing Kinetic Monte Carlo Cellular Automata (KMC-CA) simulations. Importantly, our simulations can reproduce the multiple infection peak scenario of a pandemic. The latent interactions between disease migration and the distributions of susceptibility and infectivity can render the progression a character vastly different from the naive SIR model. In particular, inclusion of these additional features renders the problem a character of a living percolating system where the disease cluster can survive by spatial migration.

scholarly journals SPATIAL HETEROGENEITY IN SIMPLE DETERMINISTIC SIR MODELS ASSESSED ECOLOGICALLY

2012 ◽  
Vol 54 (1-2) ◽  
pp. 23-36 ◽  
Author(s):  
E. K. WATERS ◽  
H. S. SIDHU ◽  
G. N. MERCER
Keyword(s):  
Infectious Disease ◽  
Spatial Heterogeneity ◽  
Disease Transmission ◽  
Herd Immunity ◽  
Epidemic Models ◽  
Final Size ◽  
Infectious Disease Transmission ◽  
Epidemic Dynamics ◽  
Mean Crowding ◽  
Rate Of Movement

AbstractPatchy or divided populations can be important to infectious disease transmission. We first show that Lloyd’s mean crowding index, an index of patchiness from ecology, appears as a term in simple deterministic epidemic models of the SIR type. Using these models, we demonstrate that the rate of movement between patches is crucial for epidemic dynamics. In particular, there is a relationship between epidemic final size and epidemic duration in patchy habitats: controlling inter-patch movement will reduce epidemic duration, but also final size. This suggests that a strategy of quarantining infected areas during the initial phases of a virulent epidemic might reduce epidemic duration, but leave the population vulnerable to future epidemics by inhibiting the development of herd immunity.

Sign in / Sign up

Export Citation Format

Share Document