William C. Martel's Grand Strategy in Theory and Practice: The Need for an Effective American Foreign Policy

2016 ◽  
Vol 48 (1) ◽  
pp. 99-101
Author(s):  
Nguyen Thi Thuy Hang
2021 ◽  
pp. 152-164
Author(s):  
Rebecca Lissner

This chapter summarizes the main findings and conclusions of the book, discusses the cross-national generalizability of the informational theory of strategy adjustment, considers directions for future research, and reflects on the implications of this book for American foreign policy in the 2020s.


Author(s):  
Kevin Narizny

Nearly everything a state does has distributional consequences, including grand strategy. Societal groups with different stakes in the international economy and defense spending often have conflicting strategic priorities, and these groups pursue their parochial interests by supporting the nomination and election of like-minded politicians. Thus, grand strategy is a product of political economy. An overview of American foreign policy over the last several decades illustrates this logic. In the 1980s, the Democratic and Republican coalitions had conflicting interests over the international economy, so the two parties diverged on grand strategy. The recovery of the Rust Belt in the 1990s and 2000s, however, brought increasing convergence. Political discourse over foreign policy was fiercely partisan, but, with the notable exception of George W. Bush’s decision to go to war in Iraq in 2003, the two parties shared essentially the same view of America’s role in the world. The disastrous outcome in Iraq led the Bush administration back to the middle ground in its second term, and Obama followed the same course. In contrast, the election of Donald Trump augurs change. Trump’s electoral coalition consists of a different balance of interests in the international economy than that of past Republican presidents, so he is likely to pursue different strategic priorities.


Author(s):  
S. Kislitsyn

The research examines the main problems of a grand strategy in the US foreign policy. Attention is paid to the conceptual understanding of this term, its historical development, and the current state. The article analyzes the positions of American foreign policy elites and the expert community regarding the problem of the US self-positioning in the outside world. The article consists of three parts. The first analyses the main conceptual provisions of the “grand strategy” as a term. It describes its development from a military term, reflecting the general tactics in interstate confrontation to its comprehensive understanding as a coordination principle of long-term and medium-term goals with short term actions. The second part of the article focuses on the American foreign policy elites, their approaches, as well as public opinion on this issue. It is noted that the ideology of global leadership has become an important component of the establishment's thinking. It largely impedes the development of new foreign policy concepts and, as a result, reformatting the grand strategy. The third part is devoted to the positions of the expert community on the issue of grand strategy. Four main versions are considered: "Offensive", "Selective engagement", "Offshore Balancing", "Zero-sum". The author comes to a conclusion that the US foreign policy mixes several types of strategies at the moment. It is noted that as China strengthens, the United States faces a new competition, which, unlike the Soviet threat, implies not military-political, but economic confrontation. The implementation of the scenario of a "new Cold War" between Washington and Beijing can define the new goals of the grand strategy. At the same time, this also creates an ideological dilemma of recognizing a new challenge, an increasing alternative for American global leadership - the idea of which is still popular among representatives of American foreign policy elites.


Reviews: Political Theory and Practice, Man and, The Social Sciences, Political Images and Realities, The Sociology of Social Movements, Politics in Science, The Politics of Consumer Protection, Constitutional Law and Judicial Policy Making, Working Papers in Canadian Politics, Nazis and Workers: National Socialist Appeals to German Labour, 1919–1933, The West German Legislative Process—A Case Study of Two Transportation Bills, Gaullism: The Rise and Fall of A Political Movement, Class and Society in Soviet Russia, Politics and History in the Soviet Union, Politics and the Labour Movement in Chile, Revolution in Peru: Mariátegui and the Myth, Interest Conflict and Political Change in Brazil, The Dynamics of Indian Political Factions: A Study of District Councils in the State of Maharashtra, The Political Elite of Iran, Patrimonialism and Political Change in the Congo, The Theory and Practice of Dissolution of Parliament, The New Government of London: The First Five Years, Governing the London Region: Reorganisation and Planning in the 1960s, Constraints and Adjustments in British Foreign Policy, Rise to Globalism, American Foreign Policy since 1938, The Peers and the People: The General Election of 1910, the Politics of Authenticity: Radical Individualism and the Emergence of Modern Society, Philosophy, Politics and Society, Fourth Series, Socialism since Marx, Democracy and Reaction, Hegel's Theory of the Modern State, Friedrich Meinecke: Historism. The Rise of a New Historical Outlook, the Aberystwyth Papers: International Politics 1919–1969

1973 ◽  
Vol 21 (2) ◽  
pp. 224-263
Author(s):  
W. H. Greenleaf ◽  
Robert E. Dowse ◽  
Colin Seymour-Ure ◽  
Paul Wilkinson ◽  
Roger Williams ◽  
...  

Book Reviews: The Press, Politics and the Public, The Press: A Case for Commitment, Government and Nationalism in Scotland, Scottish Nationalism, Constitutional Bureaucracy, Statesmen in Disguise: The Changing Role of the Administrative Class of the British Home Civil Service 1853–1966, Politicians and the Slump: The Labour Government of 1929–1931, Socialism and Foreign Policy: Theory and Practice in Britain to 1931, Idealism, Politics and History; Sources of Hegelian Thought, Four Essays on Liberty, An Interpretation of the Political Ideas of Marx and Engels, The State in Capitalist Society, The Origins of British Sociology: 1834–1914, Victorian Minds, Scritti Politici, The Process of Politics: A Comparative Approach, Small Group Methods and the Study of Politics, Aggregate Data Analysis: Political and Social Indicators in Cross-National Research, Modern European Governments, The Foreign Policies of the Powers, The Making of United States Foreign Policy, The Making of British Foreign Policy, Soviet Foreign Policy, Alliances and American Foreign Policy, Parliament, Parties and Society in France 1946–1958, Affluence and the French Worker in the Fourth Republic, The History of Germany since 1789, The Commonwealth Experience, the Commonwealth at Work, Responsible Government in Ontario, Politics in Saskatchewan, Pendulum of Power: Canada's Federal Elections, Canadian Party Platforms 1867–1968, Comparative Social Administration, French Pensions, the Learning Society, Resources for Education

1970 ◽  
Vol 18 (2) ◽  
pp. 251-280
Author(s):  
A. J. Beith ◽  
J. Barry Jones ◽  
A. D. Lane ◽  
J. D. Fraser ◽  
R. N. Berki ◽  
...  

Author(s):  
Melvyn P. Leffler

This introductory chapter chronicles how the author's study of American foreign policy over the decades gravitated toward an analysis of the meaning of national security. This was not intentional. It resulted from a long struggle to wrestle with evidence that led to attempts to synthesize the three levels of analysis that scholars of international relations often talk about: the individual, the domestic/state, and the international. By using the concept of national security, the author was able to analyze the motives shaping U.S. policymakers, examine their perception of threat and opportunity, assess their willingness to incur commitments and responsibilities abroad, study their readiness to employ military power, and gain an appreciation of how they saw the links between external configurations of power and the preservation of democratic capitalism at home. As the author embraced complexity, studied the evolving literature on grand strategy, and grappled with contingency, his empathy for the policymakers grew.


Sign in / Sign up

Export Citation Format

Share Document