Self-Concept, Social Comparison, and Ability Grouping: A Reply to Kulik and Kulik

1984 ◽  
Vol 21 (4) ◽  
pp. 799-806 ◽  
Author(s):  
Herbert W Marsh

This edited volume presents both classic and contemporary conceptual, empirical, and applied perspectives on the role of comparisons with other people—a core aspect of social life—that have implications for the self-concept, opinions, subjective and physical well-being, conformity, decision-making, group behavior, education, and social movements. The volume is comprised of original chapters, authored by noted experts, divided into three sections: basic comparison processes, neighboring fields, and applications. The first section is comprised of chapters that update classic theories and present advances, such as the dominating effect of local versus global comparisons, an analysis of the psychology of competition, how comparisons across different domains influence self-concept and achievement, and the integral connections between stereotyping and comparison. The second section introduces perspectives from neighboring fields that shed new light on social comparison. These chapters range from judgment and decision science, cognitive psychology, social network theory, and animal social behavior. The third section presents chapters that describe applications of comparison, including relative deprivation; health psychology; the effects of income inequality on well-being; the relationships among social hierarchies, power, and comparison; and the interconnections of psychological processes such as comparison and differential construal that favor the status quo and can discourage social action in the face of injustice and inequity.


Jurnal Niara ◽  
1970 ◽  
Vol 10 (2) ◽  
pp. 139-151
Author(s):  
Hevi Susanti ◽  
Nujanah

The phenomenon that lately occurs and entrenched in the environment of Indonesian society in general and in particular in the District of Kerumutan, Pelalawan Regency, which considers that talking harshly, berating, yelling, scolding, threatening to children is normal. But parents should be able to give good examples to children by using language or words that are good and right. This condition can occur where parents do not really understand and do not know that the verbal ability possessed by parents in communicating with children will be directly absorbed by children and form a sustainable behavior.Results Self-concept owned by teenagers in Kec. Kerumutan Kab. Pelalawan is influenced by significant others. Where, adolescent self-concept in Kec. Kerumutan Kab. Pelalawan is a negative self-concept that is the type of social comparison and Biased scannin. The negative self-concept of social comparision type is of the view that it is indeed like what is said by others so that the view of itself really looks irregular because the self-concept formed is influenced by others. While the negative self-concept is Biased scannin type. Shown from the attitude of adolescents that he tends to feel unliked by his parents and feel unnoticed. Reflected Appraisal states that a person's self-concept will be formed if he gets an award from someone else. Where, the giver of appreciation and the amount of appreciation received by a person will determine the degree of self-concept that is formed. Appreciation from people who are considered important to someone (significant others such as: parents, friends, relatives, etc.) also provide a very big influence on the development of self-concept.


2021 ◽  
Author(s):  
◽  
Rebecca Blackwood

<p>In New Zealand, schools use the term "tracking", "ability grouping", “setting” or “streaming” to define their class grouping and organisation for mathematics. This organisation of grouping may hinder students’ development of mathematical concepts in their primary and secondary school years. To group or not to group seems to be an important question facing many mathematical educators today. The aim of this study was to investigate if class organisation in regards to grouping affects female students’ mathematical self-concept. The research looks at possible factors affecting mathematical self-concept of students in a comparative study of their Year 6 and Year 7 mathematics learning by focusing on their attitudes to grouping in mathematics over a one-year period spanning two year levels. The Year 6 class organisation was mixed ability (within-class ability grouping for number strategies). The same cohort of girls was followed into Year 7 where three classes were taught using whole class teaching, with a cross-class ability grouping approach. This research draws from data collected from a purposive sample of one school in the Wellington area. Qualitative and quantitative methods were used in order to explore whether class organisation (cross-class or mixed ability grouping) affected students’ self-concept in relation to their mathematical learning. The underlying research paradigm was social constructivist, chosen in order to gain knowledge from students’ experiences and perceptions. Thirty-one questionnaires and nine one-to-one semi-structured interviews were used. The questionnaire answers were put into three categories of strategy groupings based on the expectations for Number from the New Zealand Curriculum (Ministry of Education, 2003a) in order to explore the responses from students of a broad range of abilities. Each semi-structured interview was recorded and transcribed in full for analysis. This study indicates that students are aware of their mathematical ability whether being taught in a small group or whole class situation. Year 6 students preferred learning within a small group ability approach. They felt that this way of organisation fostered an inclusive environment which allowed for individual differentiation, encouraged risk taking, collaboration, helping of others, and feeling confident to discuss ideas, strategies, and ask questions without feeling judged by their peers. Whole class contribution, test scores, and assessment was found to affect the Year 7 students’ mathematical self-concept negatively and positively. The students felt that learning within a whole class approach which was broadly ability grouped was a positive experience as all students could hear everyone’s questions, ideas, strategies, and points of view. Implications from this research include that more exploration is needed in New Zealand schools into the effects of class organisation on students’ mathematical self-concept in order to inform teacher practices of differentiation in relation to the organisation of small group and whole class situations. This and other such research can also inform professional development for teachers on effective ways to create inclusive mathematics learning community environments.</p>


Sign in / Sign up

Export Citation Format

Share Document