Double-countershading as a means of camouflage in larvae of Orange-tip Anthocharis cardamines (Linnaeus, 1758) (Lepidoptera: Pieridae)
In Shaw & Otto (2020), Shaw described larvae of the butterfly, Orange-tip Anthocharis cardamines (Linnaeus, 1758), that were visually obvious yet apparently immune to bird predation. He speculated that mustard oils in the foodplants may render them distasteful to birds so that being conspicuous is of little consequence, allowing them to bask in sunshine possibly to aid digestion. In contrast, I argue that in certain lighting conditions larger larvae of Orange-tip can be very well camouflaged. These two different defence mechanisms are not mutually exclusive and each may come into play under different conditions of lighting, larval age and/or food-plant availability. For disguise the larvae make use of double-countershading in what Süffert (1932) called the 'two-surface effect'. Here I briefly describe its mechanism along with that of the better-known ordinary (single) countershading. Photographs are shown of both.