Disease emergence occurs within the context of ecological communities, and disease driven declines in host populations can lead to complex direct and indirect ecological effects. Varying effects of a single disease among multiple susceptible hosts could benefit relatively resistant species. Beginning in 2013, an outbreak of sea star wasting disease (SSWD) led to population declines of many sea star species along the west coast of North America. Through field surveys and laboratory experiments, we investigated how and why the relative abundances of two co-occurring sea star species,
Evasterias troschelii
and
Pisaster ochraceus
, shifted during the ongoing wasting epidemic in Burrard Inlet, British Columbia, Canada. We hypothesized that
Evasterias
is competitively inferior to
Pisaster
but more resistant to SSWD. Thus, we predicted that SSWD-induced declines of
Pisaster
could mitigate the negative effects of SSWD on
Evasterias
, as the latter would experience competitive release. We document shifts in sea star abundance from 2008–2017:
Pisaster
abundance and mean size declined during the outbreak, while
Evasterias
abundance increased from relatively rare to numerically dominant within the intertidal. When exposed to symptomatic sea stars,
Pisaster
and
Evasterias
both showed signs of SSWD, but transmission and susceptibility was lower in
Evasterias.
Despite diet overlap documented in our field surveys,
Evasterias
was not outcompeted by
Pisaster
in laboratory trails conducted with the relatively small
Pisaster
available after the outbreak. Interference competition with larger
Pisaster
, or prey exploitation by
Pisaster
during the summer when
Evasterias
is primarily subtidal, may explain the rarity of
Evasterias
prior to
Pisaster
declines. Our results suggest that indirect effects mediated by competition can mask some of the direct effects of disease outbreaks, and the combination of direct and indirect effects will determine the restructuring of a community after disturbance.