Anita McConnell,
Instrument Makers to the World. A history of Cooke, Troughton, and Simms
. University of York, William Sessions, York, 1992. Soft covers, 116 pp. £16.00. Eleanor Mennim,
Transit Circle. The story of William Simms
, 1793-1860. William Sessions, York, 1992. Soft covers. 302 pp. £9.50 It is unusual to find two books on such closely related subjects issued by the same publisher at virtually the same time. Yet both seem to have been funded independently of the publisher; Dr McConnell s excellent critical company history has been backed by Messrs Vickers of York, and Dr Mennim’s life of her ancestor, William Simms, by her own sponsors. One suspects, therefore, that William Sessions of York stand to be in pocket either way. In spite of their apparent similarity of theme and the fact that the eminent Victorian scientific instrument maker, William Simms, plays a starring role in both, they are none the less very different books. Anita M cConnell’s
Instrument Makers to the World
is clearly the work of a thorough-going professional scholar who traces the history of a scientific instrument- making firm through two and a half centuries down to its closure in 1988. Eleanor Mennim is a medical doctor who has produced a wandering and rather over-long biography of her great-great-grandfather without ever properly telling her readers what a Transit Circle actually is. Both books are quite independent creations with no collusion having taken place between the authors.