scholarly journals Illness as Metaphor? The Role of Linguistic Categories in the History of Medicine

1998 ◽  
Vol 22 (1) ◽  
Author(s):  
Ulrike Kistner
Author(s):  
Philip van der Eijk

This article focuses on a number of developments that have made the place of Graeco-Roman medicine in surveys of the history of medicine. A further development discussed is that medical history now also prominently includes the topic of health, both physical and mental health and related topics such as lifestyle, quality of life, well-being, fitness, and ‘flourishing’. It identifies a number of different mental states or conditions on a scale from an optimum to a pessimum, and thus presents a good example of the scalar, gradualist view of health characteristic of Greek medicine. This article shows philosophy competing with medicine for the role of authoritative guide to health, mental as well as physical, and diagnostic as well as therapeutic. The study of Graeco-Roman medicine has profited significantly from connections and comparisons with the study of the history of medicine, science, and culture from other time frames and other parts of the world.


2011 ◽  
Vol 55 (3) ◽  
pp. 301-306 ◽  
Author(s):  
Martin Edwards

Historians of medicine are often gloomily familiar with clinicians' incursions into their intellectual arena. We physicians offer hagiographic biographies of obscure nineteenth-century medical figures, triumphalist narratives of medical progress and – the most heinous offence – retrospective diagnosis of ailments afflicting historical characters. But clinicians have also offered some excellent insights to the discipline. As a medical practitioner, I intend to argue that clinical insight can be valuable; not in providing answers – here, clinicians' contemporary interpretations of disease and its treatment can lead us to become unstuck – but in raising questions which might not occur to historians.


2011 ◽  
Vol 55 (3) ◽  
pp. 355-360 ◽  
Author(s):  
Robert G.W. Kirk ◽  
Neil Pemberton

While some historians have noted the absence of animals in medical history, few have made the animal the central object of their historical gaze. Twenty years ago W.F. Bynum urged medical historians to follow historians of science in paying attention to the role of non-human animals in the material practices of medicine. Yet few have responded to his call. In this paper we again ask the question: what work can the non-human animal achieve for the history of medicine? We do so in the light of the conceptual possibilities opened up by the rapidly emerging field of ‘animal studies’. This interdisciplinary and sophisticated body of work has, in various ways, revealed the value of the ‘animal’ as a tool for exploring the co-constitution of species identity. We asked ourselves, surely, in our present biomedical world, this must be an area that we as medical historians are best placed to comment on; and what better place to start than the well-known, yet surprisingly little-studied, medical leech?


Cinema, MD ◽  
2020 ◽  
pp. 25-46
Author(s):  
Eelco F.M. Wijdicks

This chapter explores the different roles of nurses in the history of cinema- from the kind Florence Nightingale to the wicked Nurse Ratched. It is appropriate to ask whether a portrayal is inspiring or off-putting or merely cheap amusement. Nurses in cinema were sweetened and idealized in the late 1930s and 1940s. Films about nurses focused on romantic flings with doctors. Other depictions were misogynistic caricatures and shallow fantasies. Filmmakers seldom portrayed the nursing profession as disciplined and committed because this is not cinematic. It was more interesting to have the nurse look attractive and be courted. However, there are notable exceptions. This chapter recognizes the major role of nursing in the history of medicine and provides context to well-known feature films.


Author(s):  
Virginia Berridge

This article argues that the contemporary history of health and medicine presents some particular challenges, however, for the nature of historians' involvement in the object of their study and for their relationships with other disciplines and with the field of policy. It gives an overview of histories that encompass the nineteenth and twentieth century. Those that focus exclusively on the post-war years mostly deal with welfare, and the other one focuses on health. Oral history has continued to be a key resource for contemporary history. The methodology of elite oral history in contemporary health history is also analysed. It has implications for relationships between the researcher and those being researched. This article also discusses the role of ethical review for the contemporary history of health.


10.12737/9091 ◽  
2015 ◽  
Vol 22 (1) ◽  
pp. 116-121
Author(s):  
Терешкина ◽  
Olga Tereshkina

This article discusses the role of medical history in the solution of methodological problems pedagogy of medical institute and the methods of teaching the history of medicine. The author gives the general characteristic of the dif-ficulties that exist in the teaching and learning of the history of medicine at the moment, emphasizes the importance of applying a comprehensive interdisciplinary approach to the successful implementation of the educational process at the University, in particular, that the history of medicine is part of a more general fundamental degree “History and philosophy of science". Considerable attention is paid to the role of medical history in the educational system of medical school. The article reveals the role of research on the history of medicine and the use of the biographical method in the study of the life path of prominent representatives of the medical profession in the theoretical-methodological aspect of the problem of humanization of higher professional medical education


2020 ◽  
pp. 356-361
Author(s):  
A.D. GAIBOV ◽  
◽  
O. NEMATZODA ◽  
E.L. KALMYKOV ◽  
◽  
...  

The article reflects the main points of Avicenna’s contribution to vascular surgery. The scientist in his work described a very detailed pathogenesis of bleeding, the formation of a false aneurysm, thrombus formation in the venous system, and also the principles of their treatment, which was subsequently widely recognized by modern scientists. His great creation – «The Canon of Medicine» – contributed to the worldwide recognition of Avicenna both in the East and in the West. The role of Avicenna is also great in the development of pharmaceutical science and pharmacology. In particular, his main scientific ideas are still used to create modern medicines based on natural herbs and substances. Keywords: Abuali ibni Sino, Avicenna, history of medicine, vascular surgery, vascular injury, bleeding.


Author(s):  
Irina K. Cheremushnikova ◽  

The reliable reconstruction of the historical cultural past and the search for sources for such reconstructions remains important methodological task. This task becomes even more complex, if we deal with the reconstruction of the special spheres of human activity, such as Medicine. Culture science, historical psychology, cultural anthropology pay more and more attention to the analysis of complementary discourse. The author considers that the literary and art texts can prove to be incomparable sources on the value of information. When we study texts on the History of Medicine replacement of historical and cultural context by clinical one inevitably occur. Researcher moves from the field of culture into the space of the professional constructions, which reduce our thoughts about the investigated object. Thus medicine is to be considered not as the separate element of culture, taken out from the context, but as complex cultural configuration. During the late 30–40 years History of Medicine noticeably changed, it left beyond the framework of narrow medical themes and recognized historical and cultural contexts as really actual. The authentic narrations describe actions of concrete persons, and acts themselves cannot be separated from the cultural environment. Many themes of the History of Medicine become clear for us in their literary and artistic reflection and in correlation with the cultural experience. A. Chekhov, L. Tolstoy, M. Bulgakov are authors, for whom medical questions existed in the historical cultural and moral-philosophical context. The hermeneutic method of the considerate of the texts through comments and criticism can be described as the method, close to phenomenological description. Article demonstrates an ability of art text to penetrate directly to the cultural context of epoch. In the center of attention is the novel of Maupassant “Mont-Oriole” and the reconstructions, which can be made on the basis of the text analysis. In the novel in detail the picture of treatment on the waters is restored, that proved by the numerous revealed in the novel topics: the popular methods of treatment; the relation between the doctors and the patients; the types of doctors, medical ethics; fashion in medicine, the current theories of the origin of diseases; the methods of observation and inspection of patients; the role of advertisement in the popularization of health resorts, the first training equipment. The general conclusion that text analysis can be represented as a method of detecting of the general historical cultural component in the vital space of individual is made.


Sign in / Sign up

Export Citation Format

Share Document