Thither Algebra
The Recent Article by Mr. Betz is a classic of timeliness and wisdom. It arouses the faintly breathing hope that something may yet be done. Mark Twain's remark about the weather might well be applied to the situation in mathematics. There is still however an observation which is perhaps worth making. Our splendid physical prosperity must have some educational basis which is partially responsible for it. Now surely if there is a weakness in our present national development it is spiritual rather than material, it is in culture rather than in mechanical advances. So we are compelled to ask those who raise the cry that we have not taught mathematics efficiently enough just what they have a right to expect. They have set up certain expectations for various stages of mathematical development in the child and have been disappointed to test and find their expectations are not met. Perhaps they were optimistic rather than wise. The technical schools may claim all the credit but it still leaves nothing to complain about as far as the mechanical side of our celebrated prosperity is concerned. The thing that we need most to be concerned about is whether those that succeeded in mathematics furnished a smaller per cent of bootleggers and divorcees than those who failed. I have no statistics to offer but I have always pursued my work as a teacher of elementary algebra and geometry encouraged by the hope that if my students were led to think straighter in mathematics they would have a greater chance of leading useful happy lives. No one has come right out and said that the faulty teaching of algebra and the rest of the debatable high school subjects were responsible for the increase in crime except perhaps Henry Ford with his announcement of millions for education. His proposals do not sound feasible enough as a general solution to warrant our sitting back and waiting for his specifications for the reforming of our high schools.