Phytochemical Profile, Safety and Efficacy of a Herbal Mixture Used for Contraception by Traditional Health Practitioners in Ngaka Modiri Molema District Municipality, South Africa

The use of medicinal plants for contraception remains a common practice among South African ethnic groups. The present study assessed the phytochemical profile, cytotoxicity, acute oral toxicity and efficacy of a herbal mixture used for contraception by the Batswana of South Africa. An aqueous extract was prepared from equal quantities (in terms of weight) of Bulbine frutescens (roots), Helichrysum caespititium (leaves) and Teucrium trifidum (leaves) based on a recipe used by traditional health practitioners. The phytochemical profiles of the freeze-dried herbal mixture were analyzed using gas chromatography–mass spectrometry (GC-MS). In addition, cytotoxicity was determined using an MTT assay on Vero cells and in vivo contraceptive efficacy was evaluated using seven Sprague Dawley rats per control and treatment groups. The control group received distilled water while test groups received 5, 50 and 300 mg/kg of the herbal mixture, which was administered orally once a day for three consecutive days. Subsequently, female rats were paired 1:1 with males for 3 days. Their weights were measured weekly and incidence of pregnancy was recorded. The GC-MS chromatogram revealed the presence of 12 identified and 9 unidentified compounds. In terms of safety, the herbal mixture had an IC50 value of 755.2 μg/mL and 2000 mg/kg, which was the highest tested dose that caused no mortality or morbidity in the rats. A contraceptive efficacy of 14.5% was exerted with 50 mg/kg herbal mixture extract while other doses had no effects given that all the rats were pregnant. Based on a chi-square test (p < 0.05), there was no correlation between the tested herbal mixture doses and contraception, nor on the weight of the rats. Overall, the herbal mixture extract was found to be safe but had limited contraceptive efficacy at the tested doses. In future studies, exploring increased dose range, solvent extract types and hormonal analysis will be pertinent.

Pearl Index study with levonorgestrel-releasing intravaginal rings: using pharmacokinetic results to investigate treatment compliance as a potential contributor for contraceptive failure

STUDY QUESTION What is the reason for insufficient contraceptive efficacy of levonorgestrel (LNG) delivered by intravaginal ring (IVR) releasing comparable amounts of LNG as approved progestogen-only pills (POPs)? SUMMARY ANSWER The pharmacokinetic (PK) evaluation in a subpopulation indicated that the steady-state concentration of plasma LNG was markedly lower in the participants in the USA compared to those in Japan suggesting non-compliance in the US participants which may explain a clearly higher Pearl Index (PI) in USA (8.2, unadjusted PI) compared to Japan (1.4, unadjusted PI). WHAT IS KNOWN ALREADY Contraceptive efficacy of LNG in POPs has been demonstrated following different routes of administration (e.g. orally, implants, intrauterine systems), and the PK is well-characterized including a target exposure needed for contraception. Exposure above this target concentration was reached in Phase 1 studies using IVR delivering 40 µg LNG per day. STUDY DESIGN, SIZE, DURATION The primary objective of this multicenter, open-label, single-arm study conducted in the USA and in Japan was to assess the contraceptive efficacy of an LNG-containing IVR during a planned treatment period of 1 year in healthy women 18–35 years of age. The study was planned to be conducted in 1600 participants (1300 in the USA, 300 in Japan). The study was prematurely terminated after approximately one-third of the planned exposure was reached due to a high number of pregnancies (28) in the US study population. PARTICIPANTS/MATERIALS, SETTING, METHODS In total, 1471 participants were treated (1166 participants in the USA and 305 participants in Japan). The PI as a measure of contraceptive efficacy was calculated from the frequency of unintended pregnancies during treatment. LNG exposure in the systemic circulation was assessed during treatment in 136 participants (PK subgroups: 106 in the USA and 30 in Japan). MAIN RESULTS AND THE ROLE OF CHANCE The PK evaluation in the PK subgroups indicated that the steady-state concentration of plasma LNG after 6 months was markedly lower in the participants in the USA (geometric mean 91.2 ng/l) compared to those in Japan (263.8 ng/l). This PK finding cannot be explained by the regional differences in body weight observed between the PK subgroups, thus suggesting non-compliance in the US participants. In 15.7% of the samples collected in the USA and 3.5% samples in Japan, the LNG concentration at steady state was below the lower limit of quantification (10 ng/l), which is not expected with the required continuous use of the IVR documented in most of the eDiaries. LIMITATIONS, REASONS FOR CAUTION The planned duration of treatment was 12 months, but due to the premature termination of the study none of the participants completed the 12-month treatment. All data collected until the study termination were considered, but it is to be noted that the amount of missing data limits the conclusions that can be drawn from the data. WIDER IMPLICATIONS OF THE FINDINGS The results of this study triggered the termination of the project, because the objective to show sufficient contraceptive efficacy of the LNG IVR was not met. The choice of a user-dependent contraceptive method with an LNG dose that is not inhibiting ovulation is not advisable for women who may have compliance issues. STUDY FUNDING/COMPETING INTEREST(S) The study was funded by Bayer AG and all authors are employees of Bayer AG. TRIAL REGISTRATION NUMBER NCT02403401

A study to compare the efficacy, acceptability and side effect of combined contraceptive vaginal ring with the combined oral contraceptive pills in a tertiary health centre located in central India

Background: A study to compare the efficacy, acceptability and side effect of combined contraceptive vaginal ring with the combined oral contraceptive pills in a tertiary health centre (RKDF Medical College and Research Centre, Bhopal) located in central India.Methods: This prospective randomized comparative trial enrolled hundred women aged between 20 to 40 years seeking for contraception with no contraindication to hormonal contraception. After proper counseling and informed consent, women divided into two groups, study group (50) includes women using contraceptive vaginal ring and control group (50) include women using combined oral contraceptives. The contraceptive efficacy, acceptability, tolerability and adverse events were recorded at each follow-up visit at RKDF Medical College and Research Centre, Bhopal.Results: Vaginal ring and combined oral contraceptives were found to have comparable contraceptive efficacy. In study group no pregnancy reported during study period while one pregnancy reported in control group, which was statistically insignificant. Satisfaction, continuation and recommendation to others were more with vaginal ring which were not significant statistically. Cycle control is superior with vaginal ring. Incidence of adverse effects was same in both groups.Conclusions: Combined contraceptive vaginal ring is an effective and reliable contraception with excellent cycle control, well-tolerated and highly acceptable to most women.