Abstract
Background
Globally, undocumented migrants have relied on informal clinics for their healthcare services. Empirical explorations of physicians' moral, ethical, and legal consciousness surrounding practising within this context remain lacking. The present study sought to contribute to this gap.
Methods
Constructivist grounded theory was applied to qualitative interviews with 16 physicians working in informal humanitarian clinics in Sweden.
Results
Physicians' experiences were synthesised into three categories: Ambiguity in navigating illegality, due to awareness of vulnerabilities surrounding patient-safety and own involvement, whilst simultaneously feeling enriched through interactions in the clinic; Being exposed to patients' accounts of structural violence and social injustice; Experiencing isolation in practice, when discovering professional limitations and feeling severed from the conventional medical institution. In navigating the threshold between their societally commended role and structurally condemned undocumentedness, differing processes of alienation synthesised in physicians in medical, ethical, and legal terms; identified as a novel dimension of legal consciousness theory, a process coined medicolegal alienation.
Conclusions
The process of medicolegal alienation occurs when, functioning as arbiters of patients' rights within the conventional medical institution, questions surrounding undocumented migrants' deservingness force physicians into a position of moral, ethical, and professional dissonance. Struggling to dictate their own practice, they are propelled out into informal clinics, in search for congruence. Through this process, physicians become alienated from both their profession and from legality. Though able to navigate freely between the medical institution and humanitarian clinics, the burden of insight into the threshold between legal realms and the plight of the undocumented patient is heavily ambiguous, being both transformative and isolating.
Key messages
In navigating the threshold between their societally commended role and structurally condemned undocumentedness, differing processes of medical, ethical, and legal alienation synthesised in physicians. When undocumented migrants’ deservingness is questtioned, physicians are forced into a position of moral, ethical, and professional dissonance, giving rise to the process of medicolegal alienation.