Evaluations of Remote Sensing-Based Global Evapotranspiration Datasets at Catchment Scale in Mountain Regions

Evapotranspiration (ET) is essential for connecting ecosystems and directly affects the water consumption of forests, grasslands, and farmlands. Eight global remote sensing-based ET (RS_ET) datasets generated using satellite imagery and ground-based observations were comprehensively assessed using monthly ET time series simulated by the water balance (WB) method at the catchment scale in the Hengduan Mountain (HDM) region, including the Nu River, Lancang River, and Jinsha River basins. The complementary relationship (CR) model, which derives ET from meteorological data, was also evaluated against WB-based ET (WB_ET). In addition, WB_ET, RS_ET, and CR-based ET (CR_ET) data were used to investigate ET spatial and temporal variations at the catchment, grid, and site scale, respectively. Most RS_ET datasets accurately simulated monthly ET with an average index of agreement ranging from 0.71–0.91. The Operational Simplified Surface Energy Balance dataset outperformed other RS_ET datasets, with Nash–Sutcliffe efficiency coefficient (NSE) and Kling–Gupta efficiency values of 0.80 and 0.90, respectively. RS_ET datasets generally performed better in northern semiarid areas than in humid southern areas. The monthly ET simulation by the CR model was consistent with that of the WB_ET in the HDM region, with mean values of correlation coefficient (cc) and NSE at each site of 0.89 and 0.68, respectively. The model showed better performance in simulating monthly ET in the Lancang River Basin than in the Nu River and Lancang River basins, with mean cc and NSE of 0.92 and 0.83, respectively. Generally, annual ET trends were consistent at the catchment, grid, and site scale, as estimated by the WB method, RS_ET datasets, and CR model. It showed a significant decreasing trend in the northern semiarid region of the HDM while exhibiting an increasing trend in the humid southern region.

STATE-MOVEMENT ALLIANCES: STATE ELITES AS POLITICAL MEDIATORS IN CHINA’S ANTI-DAM MOVEMENT*

This article describes a state-movement alliance of environmental ministry officials, scientists, the media, and environmental NGOs formed to mobilize against the controversial Nu River hydropower dam project in Yunnan, a Southwest province in China. The study presents the first case of a state-led environmental alliance in China. Elites in the State Environmental Protection Administration identified common ground with an anti-dam movement and served as key mediators. They allied with movement actors to create popular support for their own policy goal (the enforcement of an environmental impact assessment), which, in turn, increased the influence of movement actors on policy outcomes (in this case, halting the dam project). The preexisting personal ties among state elites and movement actors in this authoritarian context may have lowered perceptions of collaboration risks and thereby reduced uncertainty in the political mediation processes.

Characteristics of Water Isotopes and Water Source Identification During the Wet Season in Naqu River Basin, Qinghai-Tibet Plateau

Climate change is affecting the discharge of headstreams from mountainous areas on the Qinghai–Tibet Plateau. To constrain future changes in discharge, it is important to understand the present-day formation mechanism and components of runoff in the basin. Here we explore the sources of runoff and spatial variations in discharge through measurements of δ2H and δ18O in the Naqu River, at the source of the Nu River, on the Qinghai–Tibet plateau, during the month of August from 2016 to 2018. We established thirteen sampling sites on the main stream and tributaries, and collected 39 samples from the river. We examined all the water samples and analyzed them for isotopes. We find a significant spatial variation trend based on one-way analysis of variance (ANOVA) (p < 0.05) between Main stream-2 and tributaries. The local meteoric water-line (LMWL) can be described as: δ2H = 7.9δ18O + 6.29. Isotopic evaporative fractionation in water and mixing of different water sources are responsible for the spatial difference in isotopic values between Main stream-2 and tributaries. Based on isotopic hydrograph separation, the proportion of snowmelt in runoff components ranges from 15% to 47%, and the proportion of rainwater ranges from 3% to 35%. Thus, the main components of runoff in the Naqu River are snowmelt and groundwater.