The Ring Rotation Illusion: Properties and Links of a Novel Illusion of Motion

We report a novel visual illusion we call the Ring Rotation Illusion (RRI). When a ring of stationary points replaces a circular outline, the ring of points appears to rotate to a halt, although no actual motion has been displayed. Three experiments evaluate the clarity of the illusory rotation. Clarity decreased as the diameter of the circle and ring increased and increased as the number of points forming the ring increased. The optimal interstimulus interval (ISI) between the circle and ring was 90 ms when stimulus presentations lasted 100 ms but 0 ms with 500 ms presentations. We compare the RRI to the Motion Bridging Effect (MBE), a similar illusion in which a stationary ring of points replaces an initial ring of points that spins so rapidly it looks like a stationary outline. A rotation of the stationary ring is seen that usually matches the direction of the initial ring’s invisible spin. Participants reported a slightly more frequent and clearer motion percept with the MBE than RRI. ISI manipulations had similar effects on the two illusions, but the effects of number of points and ring diameter were largely restricted to the RRI. We suggest that both the RRI and MBE motion percepts are produced by a visual heuristic that holds that the transition from an outline circle to a ring of points is plausibly explained by a rapid spin decelerating to a halt, but in the case of the MBE, an additional direction-sensitive mechanism contributes to this percept.

Mechanism for analogous illusory motion perception in flies and humans

Visual motion detection is one of the most important computations performed by visual circuits. Yet, we perceive vivid illusory motion in stationary, periodic luminance gradients that contain no true motion. This illusion is shared by diverse vertebrate species, but theories proposed to explain this illusion have remained difficult to test. Here, we demonstrate that in the fruit fly Drosophila, the illusory motion percept is generated by unbalanced contributions of direction-selective neurons’ responses to stationary edges. First, we found that flies, like humans, perceive sustained motion in the stationary gradients. The percept was abolished when the elementary motion detector neurons T4 and T5 were silenced. In vivo calcium imaging revealed that T4 and T5 neurons encode the location and polarity of stationary edges. Furthermore, our proposed mechanistic model allowed us to predictably manipulate both the magnitude and direction of the fly’s illusory percept by selectively silencing either T4 or T5 neurons. Interestingly, human brains possess the same mechanistic ingredients that drive our model in flies. When we adapted human observers to moving light edges or dark edges, we could manipulate the magnitude and direction of their percepts as well, suggesting that mechanisms similar to the fly’s may also underlie this illusion in humans. By taking a comparative approach that exploits Drosophila neurogenetics, our results provide a causal, mechanistic account for a long-known visual illusion. These results argue that this illusion arises from architectures for motion detection that are shared across phyla.

The influence of eye movements and their retinal consequences on bistable motion perception

Eye related movements such as blinks and microsaccades are modulated during bistable perceptual tasks, however, the role of such movements in these purely internal perceptual switches is not known. We conducted two experiments involving an ambiguous plaid stimulus, wherein participants had to continuously report their motion percept. To dissociate the effect of blinks and microsaccades from the visual consequences of such eye movements, we added external blanks and microshifts.Our results showed that while blanks facilitated a switch to the coherent motion percept, this was not the case for a switch to component percept. A similar difference was found with respect to blinks. While both types of perceptual switches were preceded by a decrease in blinks, only the switch to coherent percept was followed by an increase in blinks. These blink related findings, which we largely replicated and refined in a second study, indicate distinct internal processes underlying the two perceptual switches. Microsaccade rates, on the other hand, only showed a weak relation with perceptual switches but their direction was modulated by the perceived motion direction. Additionally, our data showed that microsaccades are differently modulated around internal (blinks) and external events (blanks, microshifts), indicating an interaction between different eye related movements.This study shows that eye movements such as blinks and microsaccades are modulated by purely internal perceptual events independent of task related motor or attentional demands. Eye movements therefore can uncover distinct internal perceptual processes that might otherwise be hard to dissociate.

The Wandering Circles: A Flicker-Rate and Contour Dependent Motion Illusion

Our understanding of the visual system can be informed by examining errors in perception. In this vein, we present a novel illusion that we call the Wandering Circles in which stationary circles undergoing contrast polarity reversals (i.e., flicker), when viewed peripherally, appear to move about in a random fashion. Here we report the results of two psychophysical experiments in which participants rated the strength of the perceived illusory motion under varying stimulus conditions. The illusory motion percept was strongest when there was a light/dark alternation at the circle’s edge and when the edge faded smoothly to the background gray (i.e., a circular arrangement of the Craik-O’Brien-Cornsweet Illusion). Additionally, the percept of illusory motion is flicker-rate dependent, appearing when the circles flickered at 9.44Hz and 28.33Hz, and was virtually non-existent at 1.98Hz. The Wandering Circles differ from many other classic motion illusions as the light/dark alternation is perfectly balanced in time and position around the edges of the circle, and thus, there is no net directional local or global motion energy in the stimulus. Furthermore, the direction of the illusory motion does not seem to be in a particular direction. Thus, it appears that the perceived motion may rely on factors internal to the viewer such as top-down influences, asymmetries in luminance and motion perception across the retina, adaptation combined with positional uncertainty due to peripheral viewing, eye movements, and/or low contrast edges.

Self-motion processing in visual and entorhinal cortices: inputs, integration, and implications for position coding

The sensory signals generated by self-motion are complex and multimodal, but the ability to integrate these signals into a unified self-motion percept to guide navigation is essential for animal survival. Here, we summarize classic and recent work on self-motion coding in the visual and entorhinal cortices of the rodent brain. We compare motion processing in rodent and primate visual cortices, highlighting the strengths of classic primate work in establishing causal links between neural activity and perception, and discuss the integration of motor and visual signals in rodent visual cortex. We then turn to the medial entorhinal cortex (MEC), where calculations using self-motion to update position estimates are thought to occur. We focus on several key sources of self-motion information to MEC: the medial septum, which provides locomotor speed information; visual cortex, whose input has been increasingly recognized as essential to both position and speed-tuned MEC cells; and the head direction system, which is a major source of directional information for self-motion estimates. These inputs create a large and diverse group of self-motion codes in MEC, and great interest remains in how these self-motion codes might be integrated by MEC grid cells to estimate position. However, which signals are used in these calculations and the mechanisms by which they are integrated remain controversial. We end by proposing future experiments that could further our understanding of the interactions between MEC cells that code for self-motion and position and clarify the relationship between the activity of these cells and spatial perception.

How Motion Signals Are Integrated Across Frequencies: Study on Motion Perception and Ocular Following Responses Using Multiple-Slit Stimuli

Visual motion signals, which are initially extracted in parallel at multiple spatial frequencies, are subsequently integrated into a unified motion percept. Cross-frequency integration plays a crucial role when directional information conflicts across frequencies due to such factors as occlusion. We investigated the human observers' open-loop oculomotor tracking responses (ocular following responses, or OFRs) and the perceived motion direction in an idealized situation of occlusion—multiple-slits viewing (MSV)—in which a moving pattern is visible only through an array of slits. We also tested a more challenging viewing condition, contrast-alternating MSV (CA-MSV), in which the contrast polarity of the moving pattern alternates when it passes the slits. We found that changes in the distribution of the spectral content of the slit stimuli, introduced by variations of both the interval between the slits and the frame rate of the image stream, modulated the OFR and the reported motion direction in a rather complex manner. We show that those complex modulations could be explained by the weighted sum of the motion signal (motion contrast) of each spatiotemporal frequency. The estimated distribution of frequency weights (tuning maps) indicate that the cross-frequency integration of supra-threshold motion signals gives strong weight to low spatial frequency components (<0.25 cpd) for both OFR and motion perception. However, the tuning map estimated with the MSV stimuli were significantly different from those estimated with the CA-MSV (and from those measured in a more direct manner using grating stimuli), suggesting that inter-frequency interactions (e.g., interaction producing speed-dependent tuning) was involved.

Time Course and Magnitude of Illusory Translation Perception During Off-Vertical Axis Rotation

Human spatial orientation relies on vision, somatosensory cues, and signals from the semicircular canals and the otoliths. The canals measure rotation, whereas the otoliths are linear accelerometers, sensitive to tilt and translation. To disambiguate the otolith signal, two main hypotheses have been proposed: frequency segregation and canal–otolith interaction. So far these models were based mainly on oculomotor behavior. In this study we investigated their applicability to human self-motion perception. Six subjects were rotated in yaw about an off-vertical axis (OVAR) at various speeds and tilt angles, in darkness. During the rotation, subjects indicated at regular intervals whether a briefly presented dot moved faster or slower than their perceived self-motion. Based on such responses, we determined the time course of the self-motion percept and characterized its steady state by a psychometric function. The psychophysical results were consistent with anecdotal reports. All subjects initially sensed rotation, but then gradually developed a percept of being translated along a cone. The rotation percept could be described by a decaying exponential with a time constant of about 20 s. Translation percept magnitude typically followed a delayed increasing exponential with delays up to 50 s and a time constant of about 15 s. The asymptotic magnitude of perceived translation increased with rotation speed and tilt angle, but never exceeded 14 cm/s. These results were most consistent with predictions of the canal–otolith-interaction model, but required parameter values that differed from the original proposal. We conclude that canal–otolith interaction is an important governing principle for self-motion perception that can be deployed flexibly, dependent on stimulus conditions.