This paper presents the findings of a research study to determine the benefits of fiber-reinforced asphalt mixtures used to mitigate distresses observed in the field. Control asphalt mixture test sections were constructed on US-30 in Idaho, along with fiber-reinforced asphalt mixture test sections. Three types of fibers were evaluated: Fiber 1 (i.e., aramid and polyolefin fiber), Fiber 2 (i.e., wax-treated aramid fiber), and Fiber 3 (i.e., glass fiber). Several laboratory tests were conducted on laboratory-prepared test samples and extracted field cores. The laboratory tests included dynamic modulus, flow number, Hamburg wheel-track test, indirect tensile test, creep compliance, and semicircular bending, in addition to performance evaluation with AASHTOWare Pavement ME Design software. The laboratory results showed no significant improvement to the properties of asphalt mixtures at the fiber content recommended by the manufacturer. However, the performance of asphalt mixtures did improve at a fiber dosage higher than the one recommended by the manufacturer. This study demonstrated the need to evaluate different fiber contents when asphalt mixtures are designed, because the dosage recommended by the manufacturer may not be optimal for various asphalt mixtures.