scholarly journals High-throughput monitoring of integration site clonality in preclinical and clinical gene therapy studies

2015 ◽  
Vol 2 ◽  
pp. 14061 ◽  
Author(s):  
Frank A Giordano ◽  
Jens-Uwe Appelt ◽  
Barbara Link ◽  
Sebastian Gerdes ◽  
Christina Lehrer ◽  
...  
2021 ◽  
Vol 12 (1) ◽  
Author(s):  
Natalia Izotova ◽  
Christine Rivat ◽  
Cristina Baricordi ◽  
Elena Blanco ◽  
Danilo Pellin ◽  
...  

AbstractOur mathematical model of integration site data in clinical gene therapy supported the existence of long-term lymphoid progenitors capable of surviving independently from hematopoietic stem cells. To date, no experimental setting has been available to validate this prediction. We here report evidence of a population of lymphoid progenitors capable of independently maintaining T and NK cell production for 15 years in humans. The gene therapy patients of this study lack vector-positive myeloid/B cells indicating absence of engineered stem cells but retain gene marking in both T and NK. Decades after treatment, we can still detect and analyse transduced naïve T cells whose production is likely maintained by a population of long-term lymphoid progenitors. By tracking insertional clonal markers overtime, we suggest that these progenitors can support both T and NK cell production. Identification of these long-term lymphoid progenitors could be utilised for the development of next generation gene- and cancer-immunotherapies.


2008 ◽  
Vol 40 (2) ◽  
pp. 262
Author(s):  
Annette Deichman ◽  
Manfred Schmidt ◽  
Salima Hacein-Bey Abina ◽  
Marina Cavazzana-Calvo ◽  
Kerstin Schwarzwaelder ◽  
...  

Blood ◽  
2016 ◽  
Vol 128 (22) ◽  
pp. 3872-3872
Author(s):  
Elias Simon Peter Eckert ◽  
Peer Wünsche ◽  
Manfred Schmidt ◽  
Claudia Ball ◽  
Friederike Herbst ◽  
...  

Abstract Within this study we have developed a novel approach to identify hematopoietic regulatory genes by re-analyzing genome-wide viral integration site (IS) data from a clinical gene therapy trial of 10 Wiskott-Aldrich syndrome patients. We observed a statistically enriched contribution of individual cell clones marked by IS to benign human long-term hematopoiesis within a dataset comprising 130,699 unique IS in the proximity of 12,437 genes. Furthermore, when we assessed the genomic distribution of the IS, we found that clusters of IS (CIS) are significantly over-represented at certain coding and non-coding genetic loci, indicating a viral marking of actively transcribed genes or a proliferation advantage of specific clones due to viral induced deregulation of adjacent genes. Notably, 42 % of the 50 most enriched regions encode for human HSC regulators such as MECOM, LMO2 and HMGA2. Based on a stepwise and stringent selection process evaluating IS number, location and CIS size, we chose the top 12 ranked miRNA genes for further analysis. Of those, three miRNAs (miR-132, miR-142, miR-146a) have described roles in hematopoiesis, strongly validating our selection strategy. In order to functionally investigate the influence of selected candidate genes on hematopoiesis we developed a lentiviral (LV) based pooled overexpression (OE) approach using uniquely barcoded (BC) vectors encoding for the top 8 candidate miRNA HSC regulators in lin- sca1+ ckit+ (LSK) cells. The LV based library consists of two vectors per gene including corresponding GFP control vectors, and harbor a unique BC cassette serving as a molecular tag to allow its unbiased amplification and high-throughput sequencing of up to 96 indexed samples simultaneously. To assess the influence of the selected miRNA candidates on hematopoietic differentiation in vitro, we performed serial CFU assays using BC library transduced LSK-SLAM cells as a starting population. Low infection rates were used to ensure one vector copy per cell. We detected a 1.58±0.03 [SEM] fold increase (p=0.003, n=5) in myeloid colony forming potential of miRNA library OE cells compared to GFP control cells without a shift in colony phenotypes. After three rounds of serial replating, colonies expressing 2/8 candidates were significantly overrepresented (1.6±0.23 to 2.0±0.20 fold; p=0.049 and p=0.005; n =5) while BC vectors encoding for two other candidate miRNAs were significantly reduced (0.4±0.11 to 0.5±0.14 fold, p=0.006 and p=0.027) compared to GFP control (fc=1.0±0.12). To address the influence of candidate miRNA OE on multi-lineage engraftment and self-renewal in vivo, we serially transplanted miRNA or GFP control library transduced LSK cells in a cohort of 18 recipient mice. We revealed efficient candidate BC representation in all mice with a median read count of 7.1E4 (min=2451, max=8.4E5) 20 weeks post-transplant. In line with our results in vitro, we observed a 1.23±0.23 (p=0.044) fold enrichment of the same two miRNA candidates and a depletion of the two other miRNA genes (0.63±0.09 to 0.68±0.13fold; p=0.002 and p=0.033) in PB samples already eight weeks after transplantation. Interestingly, BC sequencing of lineage sorted fractions suggests that one of the overrepresented candidates has a strong influence on T-cell differentiation (fc=1.5±0.2, p=0.029, 20 weeks post TP) whereas the other candidate impacts on myelopoiesis (fc=1.6±0.35, p=0.114). In summary, our systematic stepwise approach combining the comprehensive analysis of the complete integration site repertoire in a clinical gene therapy study with subsequent functional validation using a pooled lentiviral overexpression approach is a useful strategy to identify and characterize novel HSC regulators. Disclosures No relevant conflicts of interest to declare.


2007 ◽  
Vol 82 (5) ◽  
pp. 2448-2455 ◽  
Author(s):  
S. Bleier ◽  
P. Maier ◽  
H. Allgayer ◽  
F. Wenz ◽  
W. J. Zeller ◽  
...  

ABSTRACT Analysis of the fate of retrovirally transduced cells after transplantation is often hampered by the scarcity of available DNA. We evaluated a promising method for whole-genome amplification, called multiple displacement amplification (MDA), with respect to even and accurate representation of retrovirally transduced genomic DNA. We proved that MDA is a suitable method to subsequently quantify engraftment efficiencies by quantitative real-time PCR by analyzing retrovirally transduced DNA in a background of untransduced DNA and retroviral integrations found in primary material from a retroviral transplantation model. The portion of these retroviral integrations in the amplified samples was 1.02-fold (range 0.2, to 2.1-fold) the portion determined in the original genomic DNA. Integration site analysis by ligation-mediated PCR (LM-PCR) is essential for the detection of retroviral integrations. The combination of MDA and LM-PCR showed an increase in the sensitivity of integration site analysis, as a specific integration site could be detected in a background of untransduced DNA, while the transduced DNA made up only 0.001%. These results show for the first time that MDA enables large-scale sensitive detection and reliable quantification of retrovirally transduced human genomic DNA and therefore facilitates follow-up analysis in gene therapy studies even from the smallest amounts of starting material.


Blood ◽  
2007 ◽  
Vol 110 (11) ◽  
pp. 3733-3733
Author(s):  
Kerstin Schwarzwaelder ◽  
Manfred Schmidt ◽  
Annette Deichmann ◽  
Steven J. Howe ◽  
Marion G. Ott ◽  
...  

Abstract To enhance the safety and efficacy of future gene therapy trials using integrating vector systems it is necessary to analyse the clonality of the genetically modified cell pool. The comparative analyses of integration site distribution and cellular gene expression will further reveal causal mechanisms of in vivo clone selection. We followed the repopulation clonality of 21 patients which participated in 3 successful clinical gene therapy trials via linear amplification mediated PCR (LAM PCR). We identified the integration sites (IS) of pre and post transplantation samples by Sanger sequencing and accomplished RNA analyses. The comparative results from all trials showed that vector integration is favoured in gene coding regions, in particular transcriptional start sites. In both X-SCID trials significantly more post transplantation IS were located in or in the vicinity of genes encoding proteins with kinase or transferase activity. In pre transplantation samples no uniform gene class was overrepresented. In both trials we detected common insertion sites mainly post transplantation and the effect was more pronounced in the trial where 4 patients developed vector induced leukemia. Notably, we detected no significant differences regarding the IS distribution in leukemic versus non leukemic patients. The gene corrected repopulation of patient 1 and 2 of the X-CGD trial was polyclonal until 542 and 777 days after transplantation, respectively. 5 months after therapy dominant clones appeared. In patient 1, between 616 and 820 days post transplantation (post mortem time point) the number of participating clones and the contribution of a dominant clone decreased while the contribution of another dominant clone increased. In both patients the integrated vector induced the upregulation of the genes MDS1/EVI1, PRDM16 or SETBP1 and thus led to the in vivo expansion of affected cell clones. From these trials we sequenced >2000 unique IS by Sanger sequencing and several thousand via pyrosequencing (datamining is ongoing). Our data show that the integration site distribution was non random, that the integrated vector influenced the cellular gene expression which caused subtle to massive changes in the repopulation clonality and that it will soon be possible to define the clonal inventory of patients using next generation sequencing technologies.


Blood ◽  
2008 ◽  
Vol 112 (11) ◽  
pp. 2351-2351
Author(s):  
Richard Gabriel ◽  
Anna Paruzynski ◽  
Ralph Eckenberg ◽  
Cynthia C. Bartholomae ◽  
Ali Nowrouzi ◽  
...  

Abstract Retroviral vectors are commonly used gene delivery tools in clinical gene therapy providing stable integration and continuous gene expression of the transgene in the treated host cell. However, integration of the reverse transcribed vector DNA into the host genome is, by itself, a mutagenic eventthat may directly contribute to severe adverse events. The latter has dramatically been obbserved in individual cases in several, otherwise successful, gene therapy trials. Thus, a comprehensive analysis of the existing integration site pool in a transduced sample is indispensable to identify potential in vivo selection of affected cell clones and uncontrolled vector-induced cell proliferation. To date, there are several methods available to study the integration site distribution of retroviral vectors or other integrating elements as transposons. Each of these techniques makes use of restriction enzymes to digest the genomic DNA. To reveal particular vector integrations, a recognition motif of the used restriction enzyme has to be located in an appropriate distance to the integration locus in the host genome. Therefore, the genomic distribution of the recognition sequences directly impact the outcome of restriction enzyme dependent integration site analysis. We here report a validated genomic accessibility model which precisely determines the fraction of the human genome that can be analyzed with one reaction set up (i.e. restriction enzyme used). For our modeling, we used the clinically relevant linear amplification mediated PCR (LAM-PCR) as integration site analysis method of choice and the commonly used frequently cutting restriction enzymes (‘four-cutters’). We show that the most frequent four cutter motif (AATT) gives access to 54.5% of all possible integrations in the human genome, whereas the rarest distributed motif (CGCG) only identifies 2.9%. This restriction bias can be minimized by analyzing the same sample with different enzymes. A combination of the 5 most potent four cutter restriction enzymes gives access to 88.7% of the analyzable genome. Furthermore, we established an unbiased, non-restrictive integration site analysis technique based on (nr) LAM-PCR. Direct ligation of a single-stranded DNA sequence to the linear PCR product evades the need for restriction enzymes to recover integration sites. While standard LAM-PCR was done repeatedly with 3 different enzymes to detect integration sites present in lentivirally transduced single cell clones, nrLAM-PCR detected all integrations in these clones in one single reaction setup. This newly developed method comprehensively recovers genomic locations of integrating elements regardless of a restriction enzyme introduced bias. Our data show that the recovery rate of integration sites present in a transduced sample strongly depends on the restriction enzyme(s) used. However, we demonstrate that the genomic accessibility of viral integration sites indeed can be determined and minimized a priori, and that a non restrictive LAM-PCR approach circumvents the existing limitations. Analysis of the clonal inventory by these methods will allow determining the pharmacodynamics of insertional vectors with unprecedented precision, facilitating development and clinical testing of insertional vector systems.


2010 ◽  
Vol 84 (22) ◽  
pp. 11771-11780 ◽  
Author(s):  
Sanggu Kim ◽  
Namshin Kim ◽  
Angela P. Presson ◽  
Dong Sung An ◽  
Si Hua Mao ◽  
...  

ABSTRACT Retroviral vector-mediated gene therapy has been successfully used to correct genetic diseases. However, a number of studies have shown a subsequent risk of cancer development or aberrant clonal growths due to vector insertion near or within proto-oncogenes. Recent advances in the sequencing technology enable high-throughput clonality analysis via vector integration site (VIS) sequencing, which is particularly useful for studying complex polyclonal hematopoietic progenitor/stem cell (HPSC) repopulation. However, clonal repopulation analysis using the current methods is typically semiquantitative. Here, we present a novel system and standards for accurate clonality analysis using 454 pyrosequencing. We developed a bidirectional VIS PCR method to improve VIS detection by concurrently analyzing both the 5′ and the 3′ vector-host junctions and optimized the conditions for the quantitative VIS sequencing. The assay was validated by quantifying the relative frequencies of hundreds of repopulating HPSC clones in a nonhuman primate. The reliability and sensitivity of the assay were assessed using clone-specific real-time PCR. The majority of tested clones showed a strong correlation between the two methods. This assay permits high-throughput and sensitive assessment of clonal populations and hence will be useful for a broad range of gene therapy, stem cell, and cancer research applications.


2017 ◽  
Vol 6 ◽  
pp. 124-134 ◽  
Author(s):  
Miguel G. Toscano ◽  
Jeroen van der Velden ◽  
Sybrand van der Werf ◽  
Machteld Odijk ◽  
Ana Roque ◽  
...  

Sign in / Sign up

Export Citation Format

Share Document