Teachers are not just teachers. They may also be spouses, parents, members of specific religious, political, and ethnic groups and many other identities. Each of these identities orients them morally and sometimes metaphysically. When people try to become excellent in any of these identities, they will also need to learn how to integrate the moral tradition of a particular identity with the moral traditions associated with other identities. One’s professional, teaching identity is no different. Professors must then undertake the merging of this professional identity with their Christian identity thoughtfully, and for Christians, “Christianly.” This requires a complex approach. This book explores the argument that faith does make a difference in terms of how faculty teach and provides examples of this integration. Overall, this chapter sets the stage for the book’s argument by explaining these conflicts, defining key terms used throughout the book, clarifying the focus of the argument, and providing an outline of the remainder of the argument.