Short- and Long-Term Results of Alternative Silviculture in Peatland Black Spruce in Minnesota, USA

2019 ◽  
Vol 66 (2) ◽  
pp. 256-265 ◽  
Author(s):  
Brian D Anderson ◽  
Marcella A Windmuller-Campione ◽  
Matthew B Russell ◽  
Brian J Palik ◽  
Douglas N Kastendick
Keyword(s):  
Stand Structure ◽  
Black Spruce ◽  
Structural Complexity ◽  
Basal Area ◽  
Long Term Results ◽  
Dwarf Mistletoe ◽  
Single Tree Selection ◽  
Alternative Silvicultural Systems ◽  
Compositional Diversity

Abstract Across the boreal forest in North America, the black spruce (Picea mariana) cover type is ecologically and economically important, occupying roughly 10 percent of Minnesota’s, USA 17.4 million acres (7.0 million hectares) of forestland. Traditionally managed through clearcut regeneration harvests, alternative silvicultural systems are being increasingly used in Canada. Here, we examine the 10- and 57-year effects of six silvicultural treatments (clearcut strips, clearcut patches, thinning, group selection, single-tree selection, shelterwood) on stand structure and dynamics in lowland black spruce. Treatments were installed in 1948 in northern Minnesota, and remeasured and re-treated 10 years later. A subset of the clearcut strips, clearcut patches, and shelterwood treatments were remeasured in 2017. After 10 years, diameter growth of residual stems varied by treatment, with the shelterwood experiencing the greatest growth, and basal area increased in all but the shelterwood treatment. Over the long term, the shelterwood exhibited larger diameters and heights and greater crown ratios, basal area, structural complexity, and compositional diversity than the clearcuts. Our results suggest that managers may consider using a shelterwood instead of traditional large clearcuts to achieve increased structural and compositional diversity, particularly when eastern spruce dwarf mistletoe (Arceuthobium pusillum) does not necessitate a traditional clearcut.

scholarly journals The Difficulty of Predicting Eastern Spruce Dwarf Mistletoe in Lowland Black Spruce: Model Benchmarking in Northern Minnesota, USA

Forests ◽  
2021 ◽  
Vol 12 (7) ◽  
pp. 843
Author(s):  
Ella R. Gray ◽  
Matthew B. Russell ◽  
Marcella A. Windmuller-Campione
Keyword(s):  
Stand Structure ◽  
Black Spruce ◽  
Forest Health ◽  
Basal Area ◽  
Predictive Performance ◽  
Stand Age ◽  
Management Decisions ◽  
Dwarf Mistletoe ◽  
Growing Seasons ◽  
Model Interpretation

Insects, fungi, and diseases play an important role in forest stand development and subsequently, forest management decisions and treatments. As these disturbance agents commonly occur within and across landscapes, modeling has often been used to inform forest planning and management decisions. However, models are rarely benchmarked, leaving questions about their utility. Here, we assessed the predictive performance of a Bayesian hierarchical model through on–the-ground sampling to explore what features of stand structure or composition may be important factors related to eastern spruce dwarf mistletoe (Arceuthobium pusillum Peck) presence in lowland black spruce (Picea mariana (Mill.) B. S. P.). Twenty-five state-owned stands included in the predictive model were sampled during the 2019 and 2020 growing seasons. Within each stand, data related to the presence of eastern spruce dwarf mistletoe, stand structure, and species composition were collected. The model accurately predicted eastern spruce dwarf mistletoe occurrence for 13 of the 25 stands. The amount of living and dead black spruce basal area differed significantly based on model prediction and observed infestation, but trees per hectare, total living basal area, diameter at breast height, stand age, and species richness were not significantly different. Our results highlight the benefits of model benchmarking to improve model interpretation as well as to inform our understanding of forest health problems across diverse stand conditions.

scholarly journals Six Decades of Growth and Yield and Financial Return in a Silviculture Experiment in Northern Hardwoods

2021 ◽  
Author(s):  
Maeve C Draper ◽  
Robert E Froese
Keyword(s):  
Financial Performance ◽  
Basal Area ◽  
Long Term Results ◽  
Northern Hardwoods ◽  
Partial Cutting ◽  
Upper Peninsula ◽  
Single Tree ◽  
Single Tree Selection ◽  
Upper Peninsula Of Michigan

Abstract The Cutting Methods Study at the Ford Forest in the Upper Peninsula of Michigan, USA, was established in 1956 and has been maintained continuously on a 10 year cycle. Methods consist of three diameter limits (DL; 13, 30, and 41 cm), single-tree selection to three residual basal area limits (STS; 11, 16, and 21 m2ha−1), and light improvement (LI) focused on improving tree grade. Long-term results show that the 41 cm DL produced the greatest managed forest value and cumulative sawlog production, followed by the STS to 11 m2ha−1 residual basal area. STS treatments and LI were uniformly superior at improving standing tree grade. In contrast, treatments that emphasize removal of large diameter trees while retaining moderate residual basal area (the 41 cm DL and 11 m2ha−1 STS) produced the largest harvest volumes of high-grade sawlogs, driving financial performance. Stand density has declined in all treatments except the 30 and 41 cm DL, where it has increased, and these two treatments have larger abundance of saplings and poles. Alternative partial cutting methods such as selection to lower residual basal areas and medium-intensity diameter-limit cuts thus may provide greater financial returns and higher average quality, and could have implications on regeneration and long-term sustainability. Study Implications: Long-term comparison of alternative partial cutting practices in northern hardwoods in the Upper Peninsula of Michigan over 60 years reveals that Arbogast-based single-tree selection is inferior using financial and volume yield criteria. Alternatives that remove more of the larger trees appear over time to increase regeneration and harvested tree quality, which in turn drives financial performance. However, treatments with extremely high volume removals perform poorly against all others, and have few, if any, redeeming financial, silvicultural, or ecological qualities.

Long-term black spruce plantation growth and structure after release and juvenile cleaning: A 24-year study

2009 ◽  
Vol 85 (3) ◽  
pp. 417-426 ◽  
Author(s):  
Guillaume Cyr ◽  
Nelson Thiffaul
Keyword(s):  
Sustainable Forest Management ◽  
Stand Structure ◽  
Black Spruce ◽  
Basal Area ◽  
Vegetation Management ◽  
Growth And Yield ◽  
Long Term Study ◽  
Conifer Plantations ◽  
Mechanical Release

Vegetation management is crucial to meet growth and yield objectives in conifer plantations. But, the combined and longterm effects of mechanical release and juvenile cleaning on growth and stand structure have yet to be documented in black spruce plantations. A long-term study was carried out in Quebec (Canada) to evaluate the interactions between initial mechanical release at age 2 years and juvenile cleaning at age 14 years (i.e., a second release treatment) on planted black spruce survival and dimensions at age 24 years. Population structure and stand species composition were also assessed. Results showed that release and juvenile cleaning had an additive, positive effect on survival, diameter at breast height (DBH), height, crown width, crown length, and the last 5-year DBH and height increments. Juvenile cleaning effects were of higher magnitude than release effects, especially on 5-year DBH increment. Combination of both treatments reduced DBH and height variability of saplings, whereas juvenile cleaning alone resulted in a higher proportion of saplings occupying higher height classes. Total merchantable basal area was constant among treatments. But, without juvenile cleaning, hardwoods occupied a higher proportion of the basal area and were taller than spruces. In a context of sustainable forest management, in which conifer plantations are expected to offer high wood yield, our results demonstrate the importance of juvenile cleaning following initial mechanical release to promote crop tree growth and yield. Key words: plantation, vegetation management, black spruce, growth, stand development

scholarly journals Tree mortality in the dynamics and management of uneven-aged Norway spruce stands in southern Finland

2020 ◽  
Vol 139 (6) ◽  
pp. 989-998
Author(s):  
Sauli Valkonen ◽  
Lucie Aulus Giacosa ◽  
Juha Heikkinen
Keyword(s):  
Tree Mortality ◽  
Stand Structure ◽  
Basal Area ◽  
Repeated Measurements ◽  
Common Causes ◽  
Single Tree Selection ◽  
Spruce Stands ◽  
Causes Of Mortality ◽  
Number Of Stems ◽  
Adverse Influence

Abstract This study focused on tree mortality in spruce-dominated stands managed using the single-tree selection method in southern Finland. Together with regeneration and tree growth, mortality is one of the basic elements of the stand structure and dynamics in selection stands. The study was based on data acquired from a set of 20 permanent experimental plots monitored with repeated measurements for 20 years. The average mortality in the number of stems (N) was 4.45 trees ha−1a−1, in basal area (G) 0.07 m2 ha−1a−1, and in stemwood volume (V) 0.56 m3 ha−1a−1. In relative terms it was 0.50% of N, 0.30% of G and 0.27% of V, respectively. Wind and snow were the most common causes of mortality, while deaths by biotic causes (mammals, insects, pathogens) were extremely rare. Some 6–10% of the total loss in the number of stems and volume was attributable to the loss or removal of trees that sustained serious damage in harvesting. Most of the mortality occurred in the smallest diameter classes of up to 20 cm. Such a high mortality among small trees can have an adverse influence on the sustainability of selection structures if not successfully checked in harvesting and management.

scholarly journals Stand Structure and Composition 32 Years after Precommercial Thinning Treatments in a Mixed Northern Conifer Stand in Central Maine

2011 ◽  
Vol 28 (2) ◽  
pp. 92-96 ◽  
Author(s):  
Aaron R. Weiskittel ◽  
Laura S. Kenefic ◽  
Rongxia Li ◽  
John Brissette
Keyword(s):  
Stand Structure ◽  
Abies Balsamea ◽  
Basal Area ◽  
Long Term Effects ◽  
Mixed Species ◽  
Precommercial Thinning ◽  
Large Trees ◽  
Stand Attributes ◽  
And Control

Abstract The effects of four precommercial thinning (PCT) treatments on an even-aged northern conifer stand in Maine were investigated by examining stand structure and composition 32 years after treatment. Replicated treatments applied in 1976 included: (1) control (no PCT), (2) row thinning (rowthin; 5-ft-wide row removal with 3-ft-wide residual strips), (3) row thinning with crop tree release (rowthin+CTR; 5-ft-wide row removal with crop tree release at 8-ft intervals in 3-ft-wide residual strips), and (4) crop tree release (CTR; release of selected crop trees at 8×8-ft intervals). PCT plots had more large trees and fewer small trees than the control in 2008. There were no other significant differences between the rowthin and control. The rowthin+CTR and CTR treatments had lower total and hardwood basal area (BA) and higher merchantable conifer BA than the control. CTR also resulted in more red spruce (Picea rubens [Sarg.]) and less balsam fir (Abies balsamea [L.]) than the other treatments. Although stand structures for rowthin+CTR and CTR were similar, the percentage of spruce in CTR was greater. Although the less-intensive rowthin+CTR treatment may provide many of the same benefits as CTR, the latter would be the preferred treatment if increasing the spruce component of a stand is an objective. Overall, early thinning treatments were found to have long-term effects on key stand attributes, even more than 30 years after treatment in areas with mixed species composition and moderate site potential.

Selection of Piceamariana for growing space efficiency

1987 ◽  
Vol 17 (5) ◽  
pp. 421-427 ◽  
Author(s):  
Laird Van Damme ◽  
William H. Parker
Keyword(s):  
Black Spruce ◽  
Basal Area ◽  
Selection Method ◽  
Stem Volume ◽  
Base Line ◽  
Short Term ◽  
Space Efficiency ◽  
Early Results ◽  
Light Interaction

In an attempt to select black spruce (Piceamariana (Mill.) B.S.P.) based on growing space efficiency, 398 candidate black spruce trees from a 60-year-old upland stand were measured for various growth and crown parameters. The best 10 trees were selected by two base lines: basal area increment vs. crown area and stem volume vs. crown radius. For comparison 10 trees were also selected by a height vs. age base line and 10 were randomly chosen to serve as a control. Only one tree was selected by all three base lines, but four other trees were selected by two of the three methods. Although discriminant analysis correctly classified 85% of the trees into the four selection and control groups, the high levels of variation associated with the growing-space efficiency base line trees made it impossible to identify a generalized form (crop ideotype) that was associated with either method. Short-term and long-term progeny tests were established to determine the relative gains associated with the different base-line selection methods. A greenhouse test was conducted over one growing season and included light intensity as a treatment; the long-term test was planted in 1984 and included spacing as a treatment. Results of the short-term test demonstrated strong family differences and strong family × light interaction, but no selection method differences or selection method × light interaction. While the long-term test was not yet mature enough to test the effect of spacing, the 2-year height growth results demonstrated strong family differences and no selection method differences. Correlation between the results of the two tests was significant (r = 0.61, P < 0.01), indicating a fairly high level of reproducibility in the juvenile progeny results. A weak, but consistent, trend of slower growth by the progeny of selected parents relative to randomly selected controls was observed. These early results suggest that if black spruce trees selected for superior growing space efficiency have inherent advantages in lower light intensities or more densely spaced situations in mature stands, their open-pollinated progeny do not express these qualities after one or two season's growth.

scholarly journals Changes in forest structure over 60 years: tree densities continue to increase in the Pilliga forests, New South Wales, Australia

2012 ◽  
Vol 60 (1) ◽  
pp. 1 ◽  
Author(s):  
Robyn K. Whipp ◽  
Ian D. Lunt ◽  
Peter G. Spooner ◽  
Ross A. Bradstock
Keyword(s):  
Stand Structure ◽  
New South ◽  
New South Wales ◽  
Basal Area ◽  
Forest Types ◽  
Natural Ecosystems ◽  
South Wales ◽  
Eucalyptus Crebra ◽  
Callitris Glaucophylla

Studies of long-term vegetation changes are critical for enhancing our understanding of successional dynamics in natural ecosystems. By comparing forest inventory data from the 1940s against field data from 2005, we document changes in stand structure over 60 years in forests co-dominated by Callitris glaucophylla J.Thompson & L.Johnson, Allocasuarina luehmannii (R.Baker) L.Johnson and Eucalyptus crebra F.Muell., in central Pilliga, New South Wales (NSW), Australia. Sampling was stratified across two forest types and across a 1951 wildfire boundary, to assess the effects of initial stand structure and early disturbance on stand dynamics. Stems in the size range tallied in the 1940s (>8.9 cm DBH for Callitris and >11.4 cm for Allocasuarina and Eucalyptus) of each genus increased about three-fold in density and about four-fold in basal area over 60 years, with similar trends in both forest types and fire zones. On average, there were 3638 stems ha–1 in 2010, of which 86% were small Allocasuarina and Callitris (<11.4-cm and <8.9-cm diameter at breast height, DBH, respectively). These results illustrate a continuation of forest encroachment that was initially documented in the late 1800s. However, increases in Allocasuarina have received little attention compared with Callitris recruitment. In the absence of disturbance, ongoing increases in stand stocking may be expected.

Loblolly pine and mixed hardwood stand dynamics for 27 years following chemical, mechanical, and manual site preparation

1993 ◽  
Vol 23 (10) ◽  
pp. 2126-2132 ◽  
Author(s):  
Glenn R. Glover ◽  
Bruce R. Zutter
Keyword(s):  
Loblolly Pine ◽  
Stand Structure ◽  
Growth Yield ◽  
Basal Area ◽  
Site Preparation ◽  
Growth And Yield ◽  
Long Term Effects ◽  
Fayette County ◽  
Stand Basal Area

A site-preparation study installed in 1959 in Fayette County, Alabama, U.S.A., provides data to evaluate long-term effects of varying densities of hardwood on loblolly pine (Pinustaeda L.) plantation growth, yield, and stand structure. Six treatments (hand girdle; bulldoze scarification; herbicide applied to axe frill, chain frill, and with an injector; and an untreated check) were installed as a randomized complete block with five replications. Periodic measurements of pine and hardwood size and density show that higher hardwood densities existing early in the pine plantation had a substantial negative effect on loblolly pine survival and basal area yield, with the bulldoze and herbicide treatments having less hardwood and higher survival and stand basal area. Pine total height and diameter at breast height were reduced by increasing hardwood density early in the life of the plantation, but size of surviving trees differed little among treatments at later ages, except on plots where most pine trees were suppressed by hardwoods. Strong relationships between pine basal area per hectare at age 27 and both number of hardwood stems at age 3 and percentage of stand basal area in hardwood at age 6 were noted. These relationships indicate promise for predicting long-term growth and yield of loblolly pine plantations from early measures of hardwood interference.

Long-Term Evolution of Composition and Structure after Repeated Group Selection Over Eight Decades

2020 ◽  
Author(s):  
Nicole Rogers ◽  
Anthony W. D'Amato ◽  
William Leak
Keyword(s):  
Group Selection ◽  
Stand Structure ◽  
Fagus Grandifolia ◽  
Long Term Results ◽  
Northern Hardwood Forests ◽  
Composition And Structure ◽  
Shade Tolerant Species ◽  
Bartlett Experimental Forest ◽  
Developmental Dynamics

: In northeastern North America, group selection is frequently used in northern hardwood forests to maintain uneven-aged stand structure and promote regeneration of tree species spanning a range of shade tolerances. For this study, long-term application of group selection at the Bartlett Experimental Forest, New Hampshire, USA provided a unique opportunity to address cohort and stand level progression after 80-years of treatment. Cohort-level evolution reflected successional and developmental dynamics associated with even-aged forest systems, whereas aggregate, stand-level conditions were consistent with expectations for uneven-aged systems. As cohorts aged, diameter distributions progressed towards descending monotonic forms and species composition transitioned from shade-intolerant species to shade-tolerant species. Standing deadwood and downed woody material in cohorts followed trajectories of aging even-aged stands through time. Although American beech (Fagus grandifolia Ehrh.) was a primary species across cohorts and at the stand level, stand level regeneration included a mixture of ecologically and commercially valuable species. These long-term results offer important insights into emergent cohort and stand-level conditions and processes that may affect continued recruitment of desirable compositional and structural conditions in stands managed using group selection over numerous cutting cycles.

scholarly journals Long-term effects of peatland black spruce regeneration treatments in northeastern Ontario

2005 ◽  
Vol 81 (1) ◽  
pp. 42-49 ◽  
Author(s):  
Arthur Groot ◽  
Michael J Adams
Keyword(s):  
Picea Mariana ◽  
Black Spruce ◽  
Stocking Density ◽  
Basal Area ◽  
Long Term Effects ◽  
Seeding Rate ◽  
Site Class ◽  
Advance Regeneration ◽  
Rate Effects

Studies of black spruce (Picea mariana (Mill.) BSP) broadcast seeding and of harvest methods for advance regeneration protection were remeasured 17 to 20 years after establishment on peatland sites in northeastern Ontario. The effects of seeding rate on black spruce stocking, density or basal area were apparent at two study locations 20 years after treatment, but high levels of advance regeneration masked seeding rate effects at two other study locations. The effects of different harvest methods on black spruce stocking, density and basal area, which were evident at earlier ages, were no longer statistically significant 17 to 19 years after treatment. Black spruce density increased moderately with time because of gradual recruitment of new seedlings. Density of black spruce stems taller than 1.3 m tall exceeded 4000 ha-1 for nearly all treatments, but these stems were spatially aggregated at the 4-m2 scale. The stand characteristics of these regenerated peatland stands are consistent with site class 2 stands in the Ontario normal yield tables. Key words: black spruce; Picea mariana; advance regeneration; direct seeding; regeneration; peatland; stand dynamics

Sign in / Sign up

Export Citation Format

Share Document