Comparing Turbine Gaspath Component Alternatives

Author(s):  
Fred T. Willett ◽  
Rodger O. Anderson ◽  
Michael R. Pothier

The large installed base of large frame industrial gas turbines has prompted a number of replacement part offerings, in addition to the replacement parts offered by the OEM. The quality and rigor of the offerings varies considerably. The replacement parts can be broken down into three categories: replicated parts, reverse-engineered parts, and re-engineered parts. The processes of replication, reverse engineering, and re-engineering are examined in detail. Specific differences between the three approaches are identified and discussed. The economic model presented by Willett and Pothier [2003] is used to examine the potential economic benefits of replacement parts and quantify differences in potential benefits as a function of engineering approach. The benefits of each approach depend not only on the engineering process, but also on the customer (power plant operator) profile. Base load, cyclic duty, and peaking operation, along with risk tolerance, influence the predicted benefit and determine the most effective engineering approach.

Author(s):  
Alexander Stankowski

Hot gas path components of modern Industrial Gas Turbines (IGT) are exposed to extreme thermal, mechanical and chemical loading that ultimately leads to their deterioration. Modern GT designs provide for safe operation for a certain operation period. Higher firing temperatures and changing machine loads as a result of the deregulated markets call for highly sophisticated part designs and the use of cost-intensive superalloys. As the lifetime of critical parts is not infinite, they are reconditioned periodically or replaced to regain efficiency losses and to mitigate the risk of unscheduled outages due to hot gas path (HGP) failures. This paper presents advanced thermochemical preparation treatments that form the basis for the subsequent structural repairs, such as high temperature brazing. Before executing any repair step, coated components must be stripped of the consumed and degenerated coatings. Not all of the many techniques that are commonly used can guarantee reproducible and complete removal without damaging the substrate. Recently improved thermochemical techniques, such as a combination of advanced Chemical Stripping and Salt Bath Cleaning, enables the OEM to obtain clean components at low unit costs and for short processing times. In previous approaches, CrF2- and PTFE-based processes were used to clean surfaces and, principally, cracks from oxide scales before welding or brazing was carried out. These preparation techniques were indispensable for reworking superalloys, which cannot be cleaned sufficiently using conventional methods such as exposure under reducing atmospheres at high temperatures. Today, the high versatility of the “Dynamic Subatmospheric Fluoride Ion Cleaning” process (FIC) enables the OEM to run precisely tailored processes, allowing complete freedom to adjust the chemical activity of the gas phase and in so doing fulfil the specific conditions for any superalloy being reworked, even taking into account the varying grade of degradation sustained during service exposure. Weld repairs on superalloys are very sensitive to hot cracking, and high temperature brazing has established itself as a successful method for overcoming this problem. Furthermore, the intensively FIC cleaned surfaces can be regarded as the most important condition to enable a high quality bonding. Other key advantages of braze repairs are the uniform heat input that is possible, the high shape tolerance and the fact that multiple cracks can be simultaneously repaired. In addition, the brazing heat treatment allows controlled adjustment of the microstructural properties. Besides the economic benefits of the treatment, the brazed parts show excellent results in respect of their mechanical integrity. A schematic presentation of the repair sequence described in this paper is shown in the appendix (Fig. 17).


Author(s):  
Peter Wolfe ◽  
Howard F. May

This paper describes the present base load gas turbine regenerator. Covered herein are the basic design parameters, the actual physical configurations of these units along with considerable construction detail, and the service experience covering the eleven years of its existence. The evolution of the design is described.


Author(s):  
Michael B. Boyns ◽  
Rajeshri Patel

Dry low NOX combustion technology has been successfully applied to the EGT Tornado and Tempest industrial gas turbines. This lean-premix technology has been based on that being employed in the EGT Typhoon gas turbine, as reported by Norster & De Pietro (1996) but with a number of modifications to suit the individual engines. The Tornado is a 6.1 MWe machine designed in the late 1970’s for power generation and mechanical drive applications. The worldwide emissions legislation of recent years has provided the requirement to reduce NOX emissions in the exhaust, both for new machines and for those already in operation. Hence a system suitable for retrofitting as well as new production was required. The Tornado utilises similar burners to the Typhoon but with different combustion chambers and a different centre casing from the standard Tornado. Due to the differing cycle conditions, a different reaction zone stoichiometry has been used. A short rig test program followed by engine testing have achieved NOX emissions at base load significantly lower than the initial program target of 42 ppmv and led to the program target being revised to 25 ppmv. The Tempest, launched into the market in 1995 produces 7.49 MWe in single shaft configuration and is aimed at the electrical power generation market. To comply with current emissions legislation, a DLN system has been developed. The Tempest is a 25% scale up of the Typhoon but its mechanical design incorporates a simplified main and pilot burner arrangement and a fully fabricated combustor. At base load, the Tempest operates at a higher turbine entry temperature than the Typhoon but has been designed such that the equivalence ratio in the reaction zone is slightly lower. A comprehensive test programme has demonstrated hardware which significantly improves upon the target emissions limit of 25 ppmv NOX.


2021 ◽  
Author(s):  
Doug Straub ◽  
Sridharan Ramesh ◽  
Matthew Searle ◽  
Arnab Roy ◽  
James Black

Abstract Industrial gas turbines are commonly used in steam combined heat and power (CHP) applications. Combined heat and power applications have significant environmental and economic benefits that are consistent with the goals of the U.S. Department of Energy. One area that is currently being studied includes the potential benefits of CHP turbine operation at higher turbine inlet temperatures. Although these benefits will be described briefly in this paper, the primary focus will address a means to achieve these performance benefits through improvements in airfoil cooling. Specifically, internal cooling concepts enabled by additive and hybrid manufacturing are of primary interest. This paper will describe the conventional cooling technologies that have been identified after a thorough review of public literature as a baseline for more detailed analysis and future testing. This effort is unique because the cooling features (i.e., leading edge, mid-chord, and trailing edge) are integrated together within an airfoil of realistic scale. The engineering models that have been developed to characterize the cooling performance for these baseline configurations will be described. It is believed that the cooling designs described in this paper are representative of gas turbines in the 5–10 MWe size range, but not identical to any commercial product. The present effort to establish a state-of-the-art cooling scheme is a first, and necessary, step in an on-going project to identify and test more advanced cooling concepts for CHP systems that are enabled by additive manufacturing.


Author(s):  
Fred T. Willett ◽  
Michael R. Pothier

The large installed base of large frame industrial gas turbines has prompted a number of replacement part offerings, in addition to the replacement parts offered by the OEM. Willett [1] proposed an economic model developed to evaluate gas turbine component alternatives for base load and cyclic duty operation. The improved method expands the capability of the earlier model by including risk level as a variable. Power plant operator value of alternative replacement turbine components for a popular large frame industrial gas turbines is evaluated. A baseline case is established to represent the current component repair and replacement situation, assuming no risk. Each of the modes of power plant operation is evaluated from a long-term financial focus. A short-term financial focus is evaluated for contrast and discussed briefly. Long-term focus is characterized by a nine-year evaluation period, while short-term focus is based on first year benefit only. Four factors are varied: part price, output increase, simple cycle efficiency increase, and additional risk. Natural gas fuel is considered at two different gas prices. Peak, off-peak, and spot market electricity prices are considered. Results are calculated and compared using net present value (NPV) criteria. A case study is presented to demonstrate the method’s applicability to a range of different risk scenarios, from ill-fitting replacement parts to catastrophic turbine failure.


Author(s):  
John S. Joyce

The predominant role of large gas turbines has shifted from peaking-load duty to midrange and base-load electric power generation, especially within combined-cycle plants. Such applications require heavy-duty industrial gas turbines to ensure the same high reliability and availability for continuous service as the associated steam turbines. It is also important that the gas turbines be designed for low maintenance to minimize the necessary outage times and costs for component repair and replacement. The basic design principles and applications of Model V94 gas turbines are discussed with special reference to highly reliable and economic bulk power generation.


1975 ◽  
Author(s):  
J. W. Byam ◽  
S. S. Dreymann ◽  
A. A. Pitrolo

This paper is a discussion of the methods of heavy fuel treatment for industrial gas turbines and the effects of fuel characteristics on washability. A summary of recent experience with burning heavy fuels by a typical industrial user is presented. The paper includes a discussion of the latest design improvements in fuel treating equipment and the resulting improvements in washed fuel quality. The effect of fuel parameters on system size, cost and performance is evaluated.


2004 ◽  
Vol 126 (1) ◽  
pp. 119-126 ◽  
Author(s):  
F. G. Elliott ◽  
R. Kurz ◽  
C. Etheridge ◽  
J. P. O’Connell

Industrial Gas Turbines allow operation with a wide variety of gaseous and liquid fuels. To determine the suitability for operation with a gas fuel system, various physical parameters of the proposed fuel need to be determined: heating value, dew point, Joule-Thompson coefficient, Wobbe Index, and others. This paper describes an approach to provide a consistent treatment for determining the above physical properties. Special focus is given to the problem of determining the dew point of the potential fuel gas at various pressure levels. A dew point calculation using appropriate equations of state is described, and results are presented. In particular the treatment of heavier hydrocarbons, and water is addressed and recommendations about the necessary data input are made. Since any fuel gas system causes pressure drops in the fuel gas, the temperature reduction due to the Joule-Thompson effect has to be considered and quantified. Suggestions about how to approach fuel suitability questions during the project development and construction phase, as well as in operation are made.


Sign in / Sign up

Export Citation Format

Share Document