Modeling and Analysis of Main Flow–Shroud Leakage Flow Interaction in LP Turbines

Author(s):  
Jochen Gier ◽  
Karl Engel ◽  
Bertram Stubert ◽  
Ralf Wittmaack

Endwall losses significantly contribute to the overall losses in modern turbomachinery, especially when aerodynamic load and pressure ratios are increased. In turbines with shrouded airfoils a large portion of these losses are generated by the leakage flow across the shroud clearance. For the design of modern jet engine turbines it becomes increasingly important to include the impact of shroud leakage flows in the aerodynamic design. There are two main aspects connected to this issue. The first aspect is to optimize the cavity flow and its interaction with the main flow. The second aspect is to perform the airfoil design with boundary conditions, which include the shroud leakage flow effects. In comparison to the simplified approach of neglecting the real endwall geometry and leakage flow this should enable the designer to produce improved airfoils for the entire span. In order to address the second aspect of supporting the airfoil design with improved shroud leakage consideration within the airfoil design process, an efficient procedure for modeling the shroud leakage flow has been implemented into the design Navier-Stokes code. The intention is to model the major leakage flow phenomena without the necessity of pre-defining all details of the shroud geometry. In the paper the results of this model are compared to conventional computations, computations with mesh-resolved cavities and experimental data. The differences are discussed and the impact of certain configuration aspects are analyzed.

2003 ◽  
Vol 127 (4) ◽  
pp. 649-658 ◽  
Author(s):  
Jochen Gier ◽  
Bertram Stubert ◽  
Bernard Brouillet ◽  
Laurent de Vito

Endwall losses significantly contribute to the overall losses in modern turbomachinery, especially when aerodynamic airfoil load and pressure ratios are increased. In turbines with shrouded airfoils a large portion of these losses are generated by the leakage flow across the shroud clearance. Generally the related losses can be grouped into losses of the leakage flow itself and losses caused by the interaction with the main flow in subsequent airfoil rows. In order to reduce the impact of the leakage flow and shroud design related losses a thorough understanding of the leakage losses and especially of the losses connected to enhancing secondary flows and other main flow interactions has to be understood. Therefore, a three stage LP turbine typical for jet engines is being investigated. For the three-stage test turbine 3D Navier-Stokes computations are performed simulating the turbine including the entire shroud cavity geometry in comparison with computations in the ideal flow path. Numerical results compare favorably against measurements carried out at the high altitude test facility at Stuttgart University. The differences of the simulations with and without shroud cavities are analyzed for several points of operation and a very detailed quantitative loss breakdown is presented.


Author(s):  
Jan E. Anker ◽  
Ju¨rgen F. Mayer

This paper presents the simulation of the flow in a 1.5 stage low-speed axial turbine with shrouded rotor blades and focuses on the interaction of the labyrinth seal leakage flow with the main flow. The presented results were obtained using the Navier-Stokes code ITSM3D developed at University of Stuttgart. A comparison of the computational results with experimental data of this test case gained at Ruhr-Universita¨t Bochum verifies that the flow solver is capable of reproducing the leakage flow effects to a sufficient extent. The computational results are used to examine the influence of the leakage flow on the flow field of the turbine. By varying the clearance height of the labyrinth in the simulations, the impact of the re-entering leakage flow on the main flow is studied. As demonstrated in this paper, leakage flow not only introduces mixing losses but can also dominate the secondary flow and induce severe losses. In agreement with the experimental data the computational results show that at realistic clearance heights the leakage flow gives rise to negative incidence over a considerable part of the downstream stator which causes the flow to separate.


Author(s):  
A. Giboni ◽  
K. Wolter ◽  
J. R. Menter ◽  
H. Pfost

This paper presents the results of experimental and numerical investigations into the flow in a 1.5-stage low-speed axial turbine with a straight labyrinth seal on the rotor shroud. The paper focuses on the time dependent interaction between the leakage flow and the main flow. The experimental program consists of time accurate measurements of the three-dimensional properties of the main flow. The region of the entering leakage flow downstream of the rotor trailing edge was of special interest. The measurements were carried out using pneumatic five-hole probes and three dimensional hot-wire probes at the design operating point of the turbine. The measurement planes behind the three blade rows extend over one pitch from the shroud to the casing. The complex three-dimensional flow field is mapped in great detail by 1,008 points per measurement plane. The time-accurate experimental data of the three measurement planes was compared with the results of unsteady, numerical simulations of the turbine flow. The 3D-Navier-Stokes Solver CFX-TASCflow was used. The experimental and numerical results correspond well and allow detailed analysis of the mixing process. As demonstrated in this paper, the leakage flow causes strong fluctuations of the secondary flow behind the rotor and the second stator. Above all, the high number of numerical grid points reveals both the secondary flow phenomena and the vortex structures of the mixing zone. The time-dependence of both position and intensity of the vortices is shown. The development of the important leakage vortex is illustrated and explained. The paper shows that even at realistic clearance heights the leakage flow gives rise to negative incidence of considerable parts of the downstream stator which causes the flow to separate. Thus, labyrinth seal leakage flow should be taken properly into account in the design or optimization process of turbomachinery.


Author(s):  
Jochen Gier ◽  
Bertram Stubert ◽  
Bernard Brouillet ◽  
Laurent de Vito

Endwall losses significantly contribute to the overall losses in modern turbomachinery, especially when aerodynamic airfoil load and pressure ratios are increased. In turbines with shrouded airfoils a large portion of these losses are generated by the leakage flow across the shroud clearance. Generally the related losses can be grouped into losses of the leakage flow itself and losses caused by the interaction with the main flow in subsequent airfoil rows. In order to reduce the impact of the leakage flow and shroud design related losses a thorough understanding of the leakage losses and especially of the losses connected to enhancing secondary flows and other main flow interactions has to be understood. Therefore, a three stage LP turbine typical for jet engines is being investigated. For the three-stage test turbine 3D Navier-Stokes computations are performed simulating the turbine including the entire shroud cavity geometry in comparison with computations in the ideal flow path. Numerical results compare favourably against measurements carried out at the high altitude test facility at Stuttgart University. The differences of the simulations with and without shroud cavities are analysed for several points of operation and a very detailed quantitative loss breakdown is presented.


1991 ◽  
Vol 113 (1) ◽  
pp. 40-50 ◽  
Author(s):  
R. H. Tindell

The impact of computational fluid dynamics (CFD) methods on the development of advanced aerospace vehicles is growing stronger year by year. Design engineers are now becoming familiar with CFD tools and are developing productive methods and techniques for their applications. This paper presents and discusses applications of CFD methods used at Grumman to design and predict the performance of propulsion system elements such as inlets and nozzles. The paper demonstrates techniques for applying various CFD codes and shows several interesting and unique results. A novel application of a supersonic Euler analysis of an inlet approach flow field, to clarify a wind tunnel-to-flight data conflict, is presented. In another example, calculations and measurements of low-speed inlet performance at angle of attack are compared. This is highlighted by employing a simplistic and low-cost computational model. More complex inlet flow phenomena at high angles of attack, calculated using an approach that combines a panel method with a Navier-Stokes (N-S) code, is also reviewed. The inlet fluid mechanics picture is rounded out by describing an N-S calculation and a comparison with test data of an offset diffuser having massively separated flow on one wall. Finally, the propulsion integration picture is completed by a discussion of the results of nozzle-afterbody calculations, using both a complete aircraft simulation in a N-S code, and a more economical calculation using an equivalent body of revolution technique.


Author(s):  
Yang Chen ◽  
Jun Li ◽  
Chaoyang Tian ◽  
Gangyun Zhong ◽  
Xiaoping Fan ◽  
...  

The aerodynamic performance of three-stage turbine with different types of leakage flows was experimentally and numerically studied in this paper. The leakage flows of three-stage turbine included the shroud seal leakage flow between the rotor blade tip and case, the diaphragm seal leakage flow between the stator blade diaphragm and shaft, as well as the shaft packing leakage flow and the gap leakage flow between the rotor blade curved fir-tree root and wheel disk. The total aerodynamic performance of three-stage turbine including leakage flows was firstly experimentally measured. The detailed flow field and aerodynamic performance were also numerically investigated using three-dimensional Reynolds-Averaged Navier-Stokes (RANS) and S-A turbulence model. The numerical mass flow rate and efficiency showed well agreement with experimental data. The effects of leakage flows between the fir-tree root and the wheel disk were studied. All leakage mass flow fractions, including the mass flow rate in each hole for all sets of root gaps were given for comparison. The effect of leakage flow on the aerodynamic performance of three-stage was illustrated and discussed.


Author(s):  
Andreas Loos ◽  
Tobias Mayenberger ◽  
Florian Danner ◽  
Hans-Peter Kau

The flow field of high pressure compressors is strongly influenced by secondary flow phenomena which lead to performance degradations. A significant fraction of the associated losses arises from tip as well as hub clearance vortices and their interaction with the main flow. In order to decrease the negative effect of clearance vortices, the application of vanelets, winglet-like structures attached to the tips of a cantilevered stator, is studied within the present paper. Different vanelets of generic design are applied to the stator and evaluated with respect to their aerodynamic effect by comparison against a datum configuration. The model comprises the investigated stator enclosed between two rotating blade rows. Detailed insight into the underlying phenomena is provided by numerical investigations with the compressible Reynolds-averaged Navier-Stokes equations. The structures led to an increased efficiency at the aerodynamic design point due to the suppression of the clearance mass flow in combination with a reduced vortex cross section. Under strongly throttled conditions a so called vanelet corner stall developed, which induced blockage near hub. Thus the main flow was displaced towards casing enhancing stable operation of the downstream rotor. Surge margin was consequently increased.


Author(s):  
P. Peters ◽  
J. R. Menter ◽  
H. Pfost ◽  
A. Giboni ◽  
K. Wolter

This paper presents the results of experimental and numerical investigations into the flow in a 1.5-stage low-speed axial turbine with shrouded rotor blades and a straight through labyrinth seal. The paper focuses on the time dependent influence of the leakage flow on the downstream stator flow field. The experimental program consists of time accurate measurements of the three-dimensional properties of the flow through ten different measurement planes in the stator passage. The measurements were carried out using pneumatic five-hole probes and three dimensional hot-wire probes at the design operating point of the turbine. The measurement planes extend from the shroud to the casing. The complex three-dimensional flow field is mapped in great detail by 4,800 measurement points and 20 time steps per blade passing period. The time-accurate experimental data of the ten measurement planes was compared with the results of unsteady, numerical simulations of the turbine flow. The 3D-Navier-Stokes Solver CFX-TASCflow was used. The experimental and numerical results correspond well and allow detailed analysis of the flow phenomena. Additionally numerical data behind the rotor is used to connect the entry of the leakage flow with the flow phenomena in the downstream stator passage and behind it. The leakage flow causes strong fluctuations of the flow in the downstream stator. Above all, the high number of measurement points reveals both the secondary flow phenomena and the vortex structures within the blade passage. The time-dependence of both the position and the intensity of the vortices influenced by the leakage flow is shown. The paper shows that even at realistic clearance heights the leakage flow influences considerable parts of the downstream stator and gives rise to negative incidence and flow separation. Thus, labyrinth seal leakage flow should be taken properly into account in the design or optimization process of turbines.


Author(s):  
Keramat Fakhari ◽  
Thomas Hofbauer ◽  
Anton Weber

This paper focuses on the interaction of labyrinth seal leakage flows within two stages of a HP and an IP steam turbine. Numerical studies have been carried out with the DLR in-house code TRACE [1] to show the impact of the labyrinth seal leakage flow on the total loss generation in both steady and time accurate simulations. CFD results are verified by the in-house 2D through-flow method of Siemens Energy. The investigations are divided into five steps: 1. Real gas effects, 2. Steady simulations of the core flow alone and its interaction with the cavity flow to provide insights about loss production contributed by the mixing process of the re-entering leakage flow into the main flow, 3. Understanding and modeling of unsteady phenomena within such interacting flows, 4. Effects of reduction of the axial distance between the two stages on the mixing process in time accurate simulations. 5. Comparison of blade loads calculated by Siemens’ CAE tools and predicted by TRACE.


Author(s):  
Tian Liang ◽  
Bo Liu ◽  
Stephen Spence ◽  
Liying Jiao

To extend the current understanding of the circumferential groove casing suction applied to a counter-rotating axial flow compressor, the impact of different axial locations of the circumferential suction groove on the characteristics of the tip leakage flow (TLF) and the corresponding physical mechanisms producing the stability enhancement have been studied based on validated numerical simulations. The results show that the optimal location for the suction groove is at around 20% axial chord, which demonstrated a high potential for reducing additional stall mass flow coefficient with about 8.4% increment in the stall margin. After the casing suction groove was applied, the interface between the incoming main flow and TLF was pushed significantly downstream in the second rotor. The blade loading in the region below the groove, the tip leakage flow angle and the reversed axial momentum flux injected into main flow passage through the tip gap were all reduced, which contributed to the stall margin improvement. Detailed analysis of the tip leakage flow structures showed that the TLF originating from different chord locations played different roles in the stall inception process. It was found to be more effective to improve stall margin and adiabatic efficiency by controlling the front part of the TLF, which was most sensitive.


Sign in / Sign up

Export Citation Format

Share Document