Alternative Fuels Based on Biomass: An Experimental and Modeling Study of Ethanol Co-Firing to Natural Gas

Author(s):  
Marina Braun-Unkhoff ◽  
Jens Dembowski ◽  
Jürgen Herzler ◽  
Jürgen Karle ◽  
Clemens Naumann ◽  
...  

In response to the limited resources of fossil fuels as well as to their combustion contributing to global warming through CO2 emissions, it is currently discussed to which extent future energy demands can be satisfied by using biomass and biogenic by-products, e.g. by co-firing. However, new concepts and new unconventional fuels for electric power generation require a re-investigation of at least the gas turbine burner if not the gas turbine itself to ensure a safe operation and a maximum range in tolerating fuel variations and combustion conditions. Within this context, alcohols, in particular ethanol, are of high interest as alternative fuel. Presently, the use of ethanol for power generation — in decentralized (micro gas turbines) or centralized gas turbine units, neat, or co-fired with gaseous fuels like natural gas and biogas — is discussed, besides its role within the transport sector. Chemical kinetic modeling has become an important tool for interpreting and understanding the combustion phenomena observed; for example, focusing on heat release (burning velocities) and reactivity (ignition delay times). Furthermore, a chemical kinetic reaction model validated by relevant experiments performed within a large parameter range allows a more sophisticated computer assisted design of burners as well as of combustion chambers, when used within CFD (computational fluid dynamics) codes. Therefore, a detailed experimental and modeling study of ethanol co-firing to natural gas will be presented focusing on two major combustion properties within a relevant parameter range: (i) ignition delay times measured in a shock tube device, at ambient (p = 1 bar) and elevated (p = 4 bar) pressures, for lean (φ = 0.5) and stoichiometric fuel-air mixtures, and (ii) laminar flame speed data at several preheat temperatures, also for ambient and elevated pressure, gathered from literature. Chemical kinetic modeling will be used for an in-depth characterization of ignition delays and flame speeds at technical relevant conditions. An extensive database will be presented identifying the characteristic differences of the combustion properties of natural gas, ethanol, and ethanol co-fired to natural gas.

Author(s):  
Marina Braun-Unkhoff ◽  
Jens Dembowski ◽  
Jürgen Herzler ◽  
Jürgen Karle ◽  
Clemens Naumann ◽  
...  

In response to the limited resources of fossil fuels as well as to their combustion contributing to global warming through CO2 emissions, it is currently discussed to which extent future energy demands can be satisfied by using biomass and biogenic by-products, e.g., by cofiring. However, new concepts and new unconventional fuels for electric power generation require a re-investigation of at least the gas turbine burner if not the gas turbine itself to ensure a safe operation and a maximum range in tolerating fuel variations and combustion conditions. Within this context, alcohols, in particular, ethanol, are of high interest as alternative fuel. Presently, the use of ethanol for power generation—in decentralized (microgas turbines) or centralized gas turbine units, neat, or cofired with gaseous fuels like natural gas (NG) and biogas—is discussed. Chemical kinetic modeling has become an important tool for interpreting and understanding the combustion phenomena observed, for example, focusing on heat release (burning velocities) and reactivity (ignition delay times). Furthermore, a chemical kinetic reaction model validated by relevant experiments performed within a large parameter range allows a more sophisticated computer assisted design of burners as well as of combustion chambers, when used within computational fluid dynamics (CFD) codes. Therefore, a detailed experimental and modeling study of ethanol cofiring to NG will be presented focusing on two major combustion properties within a relevant parameter range: (i) ignition delay times measured in a shock tube device, at ambient (p = 1 bar) and elevated (p = 4 bar) pressures, for lean (φ = 0.5) and stoichiometric fuel–air mixtures, and (ii) laminar flame speed data at several preheat temperatures, also for ambient and elevated pressure, gathered from literature. Chemical kinetic modeling will be used for an in-depth characterization of ignition delays and flame speeds at technical relevant conditions. An extensive database will be presented identifying the characteristic differences of the combustion properties of NG, ethanol, and ethanol cofired to NG.


Author(s):  
Pierre A. Glaude ◽  
Rene´ Fournet ◽  
Roda Bounaceur ◽  
Michel Molie`re

Many investigations are currently carried out in order to reduce CO2 emissions in power generation. Among alternative fuels to natural gas and gasoil in gas turbine applications, dimethyl ether (DME; formula: CH3-O-CH3) represents a possible candidate in the next years. This chemical compound can be produced from natural gas or coal/biomass gasification. DME is a good substitute for gasoil in diesel engine. Its Lower Heating Value is close to that of ethanol but it offers some advantages compared to alcohols in terms of stability and miscibility with hydrocarbons. While numerous studies have been devoted to the combustion of DME in diesel engines, results are scarce as far as boilers and gas turbines are concerned. Some safety aspects must be addressed before feeding a combustion device with DME because of its low flash point (as low as −83°C), its low auto-ignition temperature and large domain of explosivity in air. As far as emissions are concerned, the existing literature shows that in non premixed flames, DME produces less NOx than ethane taken as parent molecular structure, based on an equivalent heat input to the burner. During a field test performed in a gas turbine, a change-over from methane to DME led to a higher fuel nozzle temperature but to a lower exhaust gas temperature. NOx emissions decreased over the whole range of heat input studied but a dramatic increase of CO emissions was observed. This work aims to study the combustion behavior of DME in gas turbine conditions with the help of a detailed kinetic modeling. Several important combustion parameters, such as the auto-ignition temperature (AIT), ignition delay times, laminar burning velocities of premixed flames, adiabatic flame temperatures, and the formation of pollutants like CO and NOx have been investigated. These data have been compared with those calculated in the case of methane combustion. The model was built starting from a well validated mechanism taken from the literature and already used to predict the behavior of other alternative fuels. In flame conditions, DME forms formaldehyde as the major intermediate, the consumption of which leads in few steps to CO then CO2. The lower amount of CH2 radicals in comparison with methane flames seems to decrease the possibility of prompt-NO formation. This paper covers the low temperature oxidation chemistry of DME which is necessary to properly predict ignition temperatures and auto-ignition delay times that are important parameters for safety.


Author(s):  
Andreas Koch ◽  
Clemens Naumann ◽  
Wolfgang Meier ◽  
Manfred Aigner

The objective of this work was the improvement of methods for predicting autoignition in turbulent flows of different natural gas mixtures and air. Measurements were performed in a mixing duct where fuel was laterally injected into a turbulent flow of preheated and pressurized air. To study the influence of higher order hydrocarbons on autoignition, natural gas was mixed with propane up to 20% by volume at pressures up to 15 bar. During a measurement cycle, the air temperature was increased until autoignition occurred. The ignition process was observed by high-speed imaging of the flame chemiluminescence. In order to attribute a residence time (ignition delay time) to the locations where autoignition was detected the flow field and its turbulent fluctuations were simulated by numerical codes. These residence times were compared to calculated ignition delay times using detailed chemical simulations. The measurement system and data evaluation procedure are described and preliminary results are presented. An increase in pressure and in fraction of propane in the natural gas both reduced the ignition delay time. The measured ignition delay times were systematically longer than the predicted ones for temperatures above 950 K. The results are important for the design process of gas turbine combustors and the studies also demonstrate a procedure for the validation of design tools under relevant conditions.


Author(s):  
Torsten Methling ◽  
Sandra Richter ◽  
Trupti Kathrotia ◽  
Marina Braun-Unkhoff ◽  
Clemens Naumann ◽  
...  

Over the last years, global concerns about energy security and climate change have resulted in many efforts focusing on the potential utilization of non-petroleum-based, i.e. bio-derived, fuels. In this context, n-butanol has recently received high attention because it can be produced sustainably. A comprehensive knowledge about its combustion properties is inevitable to ensure an efficient and smart use of n-butanol if selected as a future energy carrier. In the present work, two major combustion characteristics, here laminar flame speeds applying the cone-angle method and ignition delay times applying the shock tube technique, have been studied, experimentally and by modeling exploiting detailed chemical kinetic reaction models, at ambient and elevated pressures. The in-house reaction model was constructed applying the RMG-method. A linear transformation method recently developed, linTM, was exploited to generate a reduced reaction model needed for an efficient, comprehensive parametric study of the combustion behavior of n-butanol/hydrocarbon mixtures. All experimental data were found to agree with the model predictions of the in-house reaction model, for all temperatures, pressures, and fuel-air ratios. On the other hand, calculations using reaction models from the open literature mostly overpredict the measured ignition delay times by about a factor of two. The results are compared to those of ethanol, with ignition delay times very similar and laminar flame speeds of n-butanol slightly lower, at atmospheric pressure.


Author(s):  
Jürgen Herzler ◽  
Julia Herbst ◽  
Thomas Kick ◽  
Clemens Naumann ◽  
Marina Braun-Unkhoff ◽  
...  

Fuels from low quality feedstock such as biomass and biomass residues are currently discussed with respect to their potential to contribute to a more sustainable electrical power supply. In the present work, we report on the study of generic representative gas mixtures stemming from the gasification of different feedstock, from wood and algae. Two major combustion properties — burning velocities and ignition delay times — were measured for different parameters: (i) for two pressures −1 bar and 3 bar – at a constant preheat temperature T0 = 373 K, to determine burning velocities by applying the cone angle method; and (ii) for elevated pressures — up to 16 bar — in the temperature range between about 1000 and 2000 K, at fuel-equivalence ratios φ of 0.5 and 1.0, to obtain ignition delay times by applying the shock tube method. Additional studies performed in our group on gas mixtures of natural gas, methane, and hydrogen were also taken into account -as major components of biogenic gas mixtures. It was found that the reaction behavior of the wood gasification product (N2, CO, H2, CO2, CH4) is mainly determined by its H2 content, besides CH4; methane determines the kinetic behavior of the algae fermentation product (CH4, CO2, N2) due to its relatively high amount. Detailed chemical kinetic reaction models were used to predict the measured data. The trends and main features were captured by predictions applying different reaction models. The agreement of the experiments and the predictions is dependent on the pressure range.


Author(s):  
Jürgen Herzler ◽  
Julia Herbst ◽  
Thomas Kick ◽  
Clemens Naumann ◽  
Marina Braun-Unkhoff ◽  
...  

Fuels from low quality feedstock such as biomass and biomass residues are currently discussed with respect to their potential to contribute to a more sustainable electrical power supply. In the present work, we report on the study of generic representative gas mixtures stemming from the gasification of different feedstock, from wood and algae. Two major combustion properties—burning velocities and ignition delay times—were measured for different parameters: (i) for two pressures—1 bar and 3 bar—at a constant preheat temperature T0 = 373 K, to determine burning velocities by applying the cone angle method; and (ii) for elevated pressures—up to 16 bar—in the temperature range between about 1000 and 2000 K, at fuel-equivalence ratios φ of 0.5 and 1.0, to obtain ignition delay times by applying the shock tube method. Additional studies performed in our group on gas mixtures of natural gas, methane, and hydrogen were also taken into account as major components of biogenic gas mixtures. It was found that the reaction behavior of the wood gasification product (N2, CO, H2, CO2, CH4) is mainly determined by its H2 content, besides CH4; methane determines the kinetic behavior of the algae fermentation product (CH4, CO2, N2) due to its relatively high amount. Detailed chemical kinetic reaction models were used to predict the measured data. The trends and main features were captured by predictions applying different reaction models. The agreement of the experiments and the predictions is dependent on the pressure range.


Author(s):  
Apeng Zhou ◽  
Shirin Jouzdani ◽  
Ben Akih-Kumgeh

Abstract This study presents four separate reduced chemical kinetic models of methanol/ethanol, propanol isomers, n- and iso-butanol, and n- and s-butanol isomers, derived from a comprehensive chemical kinetic model of C1-C5 alcohols using the Alternate Species Elimination approach. It is motivated by complexity of the detailed model (comprising 600 species and 4100 elementary reactions) and the need for simpler kinetic models for analysis of combustion of smaller alcohols. The reduced models are obtained on the basis of ignition delay time simulations with imposed thresholds on the resulting normalized changes in ignition delay times. The following reduced models are obtained: methanol/ethanol: 38 species and 197 reactions; propanol isomers: 68 species and 419 reactions; n- and iso-butanol: 140 species and 745 reactions; and n- and s-butanol: 134 species and 739 reactions. Predictions of ignition delay times by the reduced models are found to be in good with the detailed models. The reduced models are further tested against other relevant combustion properties. These properties include burning velocities of laminar premixed flames, global pyrolysis time scales, and heat release timing in Homogeneous Charge Compression Ignition engines. This verification shows that reduced models can replace the comprehensive model in combustion analysis without loss of predictive performance. The reduced models can also serve as starting models for developing combined chemical kinetic models of gasoline/diesel and alcohol blends.


Author(s):  
Marissa L. Brower ◽  
Olivier Mathieu ◽  
Eric L. Petersen ◽  
Nicola Donohoe ◽  
Alexander Heufer ◽  
...  

Applications of natural gases that contain high levels of hydrogen have become a primary interest in the gas turbine market. While the ignition delay times of hydrogen and of the individual hydrocarbons in natural gases can be considered well known, there have been few previous experimental studies into the effects of different levels of hydrogen on the ignition delay times of natural gases at gas turbine conditions. To examine the effects of hydrogen content at gas turbine conditions, shock-tube experiments were performed on nine mixtures of an L9 matrix. The L9 matrix was developed by varying four factors: natural gas higher-order hydrocarbon content of 0, 18.75, or 37.5%; hydrogen content of the total fuel mixture of 30, 60, or 80%; equivalence ratios of 0.3, 0.5, or 1; and pressures of 1, 10, or 30 atm. Temperatures ranged from 1092 K to 1722 K, and all mixtures were diluted in 90% Ar. Correlations for each mixture were developed from the ignition delay times and, using these correlations, a factor sensitivity analysis was performed. It was found that hydrogen played the most significant role in the ignition delay times of a mixture. Pressure was almost as important as hydrogen content, especially as temperature increased. Equivalence ratio was slightly more important than hydrocarbon content of the natural gas, but both were less important than pressure or hydrogen content. Comparison with a modern chemical kinetic model demonstrated that the model captures well the relative impacts of H2 content, temperature, and pressure, but some improvements are still needed in terms of absolute ignition delay times.


Author(s):  
Torsten Methling ◽  
Sandra Richter ◽  
Trupti Kathrotia ◽  
Marina Braun-Unkhoff ◽  
Clemens Naumann ◽  
...  

Over the last years, global concerns about energy security and climate change have resulted in many efforts focusing on the potential utilization of nonpetroleum-based, i.e., bioderived, fuels. In this context, n-butanol has recently received high attention because it can be produced sustainably. A comprehensive knowledge about its combustion properties is inevitable to ensure an efficient and smart use of n-butanol if selected as a future energy carrier. In the present work, two major combustion characteristics, here laminar flame speeds applying the cone-angle method and ignition delay times applying the shock tube technique, have been studied, experimentally, and by modeling exploiting detailed chemical kinetic reaction models, at ambient and elevated pressures. The in-house reaction model was constructed applying the reaction model generation (RMG)-method. A linear transformation method recently developed, linTM, was exploited to generate a reduced reaction model needed for an efficient, comprehensive parametric study of the combustion behavior of n-butanol-hydrocarbon mixtures. All experimental data were found to agree with the model predictions of the in-house reaction model, for all temperatures, pressures, and fuel-air ratios. On the other hand, calculations using reaction models from the open literature mostly overpredict the measured ignition delay times by about a factor of two. The results are compared to those of ethanol, with ignition delay times very similar and laminar flame speeds of n-butanol slightly lower, at atmospheric pressure.


Sign in / Sign up

Export Citation Format

Share Document