Species-specific vulnerability to angling and its size-selectivity in sympatric stream salmonids
In mixed fisheries where multiple species are caught, to manage resources sustainably, knowledge about the species-specific vulnerability to fishing is equally or even more important than knowledge of size-selectivity of the gear. We compared the vulnerability to bait recreational angling in four salmonids in natural streams. The ranking of species-specific angling vulnerability was as follows (from highest to lowest): rainbow trout, white-spotted charr, masu salmon, and Dolly Varden. In all species, larger individuals were more vulnerable to angling, but there were differences in the size-dependence between species. In rainbow trout and Dolly Varden (which have a non-anadromous life-history in the study area) the probability of being caught monotonically increased with body size, while the vulnerability to angling in masu salmon and white-spotted charr (which have an anadromous life-history in the study area) showed a domed shaped pattern. We found that across the species the catch-per-unit effort showed a hyperstable relationship with population density. Therefore, diminishing local populations are prone to collapse, and this collapse would be hard to foresee based on catch rate data alone.