Length-specific Weight as a Measure of Growth Success of Adult Atlantic Herring (Clupea harengus)
We used length-specific weight (i.e., condition) to evaluate growth success of seven stocks of adult Atlantic herring (Clupea harengus) in the Northwest Atlantic. Condition of adult Atlantic herring showed large annual changes as a consequence of abundance-dependent effects. This contradicts the general conclusion that adult herring growth contains little abundance-dependent variation. The published literature, however, is based mainly on traditional growth estimators such as annual length increments which measure only a marginal fraction of annual production whereas condition reflects the seasonal accumulation and depletion of energy and therefore can provide a reliable index of total annual production. We found that annual changes in condition of adult Atlantic herring were only weakly correlated with traditional length-based growth estimates. We concluded that the weak evidence for abundance-dependent growth of adult herring in the literature is a consequence of inappropriate growth estimators. The implication of this finding is that the acquisition of surplus energy by herring can be abundance dependent whereas annual increases in length may not.