Selection of an organic acid analogue of dissolved organic matter for use in toxicity testing

Uncontaminated stream waters in the vicinity of a Co mine in Idaho were titrated with Cu to determine the Cu-binding characteristics of natural dissolved organic matter (DOM) and suspended particles. Nonlinear regressions of bound versus free Cu concentrations were consistent with a two-ligand model for DOM complexation of Cu, in which the conditional stability constants (log K) and complexation capacities (CC) were log K1 = 7.26, CC1 = 0.21 µmol Cu·mg dissolved organic carbon (DOC)-1 and log K2 = 5.13, CC2 = 2.89 µmol Cu·mg DOC-1. Copper-binding constants were similar in filtered (0.45 µm) and unfiltered water samples. Calcium, Mg, and Co did not compete appreciably with Cu for DOM complexation at concentrations present in site waters. Copper binding to amorphous iron oxide flocs also was not important at the Fe concentrations present in the stream waters. We selected a mixture of three organic acids, dipicolinic, oxalic, and malonic, to mimic the Cu-binding properties of this DOM. Geochemical models were developed to estimate Cu speciation and evaluate its bioavailability in companion fish toxicity tests using the DOM analogue (Marr et al. 1999. Can. J. Fish. Aquat. Sci. 56: 1471-1483).