Combined Ultrasound and Nerve Stimulator-Guided deep nerve block may decrease the rate of local anesthetics systemic toxicity especially in HBV carriers: A Randomized clinical trial
Abstract Background: Ultrasound-guidance might decrease the incidence of local anesthetics systemic toxicity(LAST) for many peripheral nerve blocks compared with nerve stimulator-guidance. However, it remained uncertain whether ultrasound-guidance would be superior to the nerve stimulator-guidance for deep nerve block in the lower extremity. This study was designed to investigate that whether ultrasound-guided deep nerve block would decrease the incidence of LAST comparing with those with nerve stimulator-guidance, and to find out associated risk factors for LAST. Methods: Three hundred patients for elective lower limb surgery and desiring lumbar plexus blocks(LPBs) and sciatic nerve blocks(SNBs) were enrolled in this study. Patients were randomly assigned to receive LPBs and SNBs with ultrasound-guidance (Group U), nerve stimulator-guidance (Group N) or dual-guidance (Group M). The primary outcome was the incidence of the LAST. The secondary outcomes were the number of needle redirection, motor and sensory block onset and restoration time in the nerve distributions, and associated risk factors. Results: There were 18 patients occurring with LAST, including 12 in group U, 4 in group N and 2 in group M. For multiple comparisons among the three groups, we found that the incidence of LAST in group U(12%) was significantly higher than that in group N(4%)(P=0.037) and group M(2%)(P=0.006). The OR of LAST with hepatitis B (HBV) infection and female gender were 3.352(95% CI,1.233-9.108, P=0.013 ) and 9.488(95% CI,2.142-42.093, P=0.0004), respectively. Conclusions: Ultrasound-guidance, HBV infection and female gender were risk factors for LAST in LPBs and SNBs. For patients with HBV infection or female gender undergoing LPBs and SNBs, we recommended that combined ultrasound and nerve stimulator-guidance should be used to improve the safety. Trial registration: This study was approved by the Ethical Committee from the first affiliated hospital of Army Medical University. The protocol was registered prospectively with Chinese Clinical Trial Registry (ChiCTR-IOR-16008099) on March 15th,2016. Key words: ultrasound; nerve stimulation; nerve block; female; HBV; LAST