Interpolation and preservation for pebble logics
In Barwise and van Benthem [6], the authors give a general method for obtaining interpolation and preservation theorems for fragments of L∞ω, those for which there is a co-inductive pebble game Γ characterizing equivalence in the logic. The method is exemplified by an analysis of the following fragments: L∞ω itself, its existential fragment , its positive fragment , the k-variable fragment (and its existential and positive subfragments) and the modal fragment (and its existential and positive subfragments).While most of their method is general, there is one part (showing that Γ has the Scott property relative to the fragment) that required a case-by-case analysis. The purpose of our paper is to replace this case-by-case analysis by a general theorem, and to illustrate this method by obtaining their kinds of results for some additional fragments of L∞ω.Our general problem can be stated in the following way: Given a “nice” fragment F of L∞ω (one satisfying some natural closure conditions), find a pebble game characterization Γ of “preservation of F-formulas” and prove that Γ has the Scott property with respect to F. Applying the Abstract Interpolation Theorem from [6], we can conclude that F has Γ-interpolation, and the corresponding preservation result. In this paper, we shall give an answer to this question. (Our answer is “sufficient” but we don't know if our conditions are necessary.)