The Role of Disciplinary Parenting Practices in Early Childhood Socio-Emotional Development: An Examination in the Millennium Cohort Study
Objective: Patterson’s coercion model describes a gradual escalation in maladaptive parent-child transactions whereby externalizing behaviors lead to increases in maladaptive parenting, and vice versa. Little research has investigated whether the model’s implied mechanisms are also relevant for illuminating the role of parent-child interactions in internalizing problems. Also, most studies have been limited by a methodological mismatch between the within-family effects implied by Patterson’s model and parameters estimated by statistical models, such as cross-lagged panel models, that conflate within- and between-family effects. Method: The current study investigates the role of two types of disciplinary parenting practices (harsh parenting and withdrawal tactics) in the within-person development of conduct problems, hyperactive/inattentive behaviors and emotional problems. A random-intercept cross-lagged panel model was fit across ages 3, 5 and 7 (N=14037) using the UK population representative Millennium Cohort Study.Result: Results suggested bidirectional relations between harsh parenting tactics and hyperactive/inattentive behaviors as well as emotional problems. Withdrawal tactics were associated with fewer hyperactive/inattentive behaviors and emotional problems over the age 3 to 5 lag, but more hyperactive/inattentive behaviors and conduct problems over the age 5 to 7 lag. Mediation analyses indicated that the combined effect of harsh parenting and withdrawal tactics mediated a cascade from conduct problems to emotional problems. Conclusion: Findings support Patterson’s coercion model, providing evidence for reciprocal within-family relations between parenting practices and child behaviors. They further confirm the importance of addressing parenting difficulties in families where children present with socio-emotional difficulties for the prevention of the accumulation of additional issues.